Ratings v Swansea (8 Viewers)

[Nick]

Jwe played well. Wilson made a couple of good saves.

Gyo and hamer awful.

 

---

[pusbccfc]

Vik, Hamer, Godden absolutely awful.

Ref a disgrace.

Robins baffling again.

Well done to Wilson. Phenomenal effort with the clean sheets again.

 

[Sick Boy]

Wilson was probably MOTM - the rest were poor-average at best.

 

[PVA]

Credit to Wilson he's gone from a liability to a pretty solid keeper.

 

[Perryccfc]

Thought Sheaf and Eccles looked good. Defence solid, Wilson doing what a keeper should do. Hamer was terrible, as was Gyo and Norton-Cuffy

 

[steve101]

Wilson 8 motm
Norton-Cuffy 6
McNally 7
McFadzean 7
Doyle 7
Wilson-Esbrand 7
Eccles 7
Hamer 6
Sheaf 7
Allen 6
Gyokeres 5

Godden 6
Dabo 6
Bidwell 6
Howley na

 

[mark82]

Wilson 8 motm
Norton-Cuffy 6
McNally 7
McFadzean 7
Doyle 7
Wilson-Esbrand 7
Eccles 7
Hamer 6
Sheaf 7
Allen 6
Gyokeres 5

Godden 6
Dabo 6
Bidwell 6
Howley na

Some generous ratings there.

 

[Boosh]

Wilson 7

BNC 6
McNally 6
Fadz 6
Doyle 7
JWE 7

Eccles 7
Sheaf 7
Hamer 3
Allen 6

Gyo 6

Godden 7
Bidwell 6
Dabo 6

 

[stevefloyd]

Wtf Godden 7 pmsl

 

[clint van damme]

Wilson deserves the high marks and praise, 18 clean sheets and a new record, fair play to him.

 

[The Philosopher]

Wilson 9

Why not? Couple of great saves, good distribution particularly towards the end putting Vic in a good break position, came out well and a clean sheet and a club record. 9 you get.

Not-on Bench 7

No real complaints about him. Physical as usual, awkward but effective. Ok.

McNally 7

Alright. Clean sheet defence, nothing fancy, nothing daft.

Fadz 7

I do wish he’d get into the ref’s ear early about Vic on the receiving end of fouls abd grabbing. C’mon skip, get vocal. Defensively ok.

Doyle 7

Clean sheet. Ok. Shame he missed his shot.

Woolly-Headband 7

Better attacker than defender. Tricky. Direct. Final ball needs to be better.

Sheaf 7

A few loose passes but overall fine.

Eccles 7

Didn’t notice him do too much which on balance suggests he did ok. No silly fouls or many loose passes.

Allen 6

Glad he’s back. Only half a game so 7 is not so easy to get. Couldn’t get away from his marker a couple of times and caught offside a bit.

Hamer 6

Missed a sitter. What’s with the short corners? At least mix it up. Free kicks off kilter. He’s still brilliant but not his day.

Gyok 6

Not at the races today and that late wallop to nowt summed his day.

Subs

Godden 5

Sigh

Dabo 5

Out of form

Bidwell 6

Ok.

Howley n/a

Overall.

Gus should have buried that sitter.

 

[Grendel]

Wilson 9

Why not? Couple of great saves, good distribution particularly towards the end putting Vic in a good break position, came out well and a clean sheet and a club record. 9 you get.

Not-on Bench 7

No real complaints about him. Physical as usual, awkward but effective. Ok.

McNally 7

Alright. Clean sheet defence, nothing fancy, nothing daft.

Fadz 7

I do wish he’d get into the ref’s ear early about Vic on the receiving end of fouls abd grabbing. C’mon skip, get vocal. Defensively ok.

Doyle 7

Clean sheet. Ok. Shame he missed his shot.

Woolly-Headband 7

Better attacker than defender. Tricky. Direct. Final ball needs to be better.

Sheaf 7

A few loose passes but overall fine.

Eccles 7

Didn’t notice him do too much which on balance suggests he did ok. No silly fouls or many loose passes.

Allen 6

Glad he’s back. Only half a game so 7 is not so easy to get. Couldn’t get away from his marker a couple of times and caught offside a bit.

Hamer 6

Missed a sitter. What’s with the short corners? At least mix it up. Free kicks off kilter. He’s still brilliant but not his day.

Gyok 6

Not at the races today and that late wallop to nowt summed his day.

Subs

Godden 5

Sigh

Dabo 5

Out of form

Bidwell 6

Ok.

Howley n/a

Overall.

Gus should have buried that sitter.

2 bottles of JD already?

 

[Deleted member 9744]

Some generous ratings there.

In what way? The way you are going on you'd have thought we had lost heavily. We drew away to a reasonable team and we've had some key players injured and Allen went off at half time.

 

[Terry_dactyl]

In what way? The way you are going on you'd have thought we had lost heavily. We drew away to a reasonable team and we've had some key players injured and Allen went off at half time.

Expectations get raised and a lot of people become ultra critical.
I heard some lads talking about Eccles on the way out the ground, saying he was a league 1 player at best

Hamer wasn’t firing on all cylinders today for sure but did some good things, and was generally s positive impact on things.

I thought it was a good game. Swansea always play good stuff…they missed a couple, we missed a couple.

Anyone who thinks different to me is wrong.

 

[SAJ]

Expectations get raised and a lot of people become ultra critical.
I heard some lads talking about Eccles on the way out the ground, saying he was a league 1 player at best

Hamer wasn’t firing on all cylinders today for sure but did some good things, and was generally s positive impact on things.

I thought it was a good game. Swansea always play good stuff…they missed a couple, we missed a couple.

Anyone who thinks different to me is wrong.

Well I’m right it was the most boring game of the season. You must be easily pleased if you thought that was a good game.

 

[SkyblueDad]

That’s a decent result today, important thing was not to lose we could have nicked it perhaps but not conceding after last week was vital and also great for our very young defence.

 

[shmmeee]

Thought Eccles did well TBH, I like that midfield three. Hamer not on it, Allen then Godden not very effective, Viks head already in the summer. Thought the wingbacks did OK today. Wilson continues to improve.

 

[Terry_dactyl]

Well I’m right it was the most boring game of the season. You must be easily pleased if you thought that was a good game.

I find Watching two technically good sides pleasing, yes. Not loads of goal mouth action but there was enough excitement = good game in my book.

 

[Deleted member 9744]

Expectations get raised and a lot of people become ultra critical.
I heard some lads talking about Eccles on the way out the ground, saying he was a league 1 player at best

Hamer wasn’t firing on all cylinders today for sure but did some good things, and was generally s positive impact on things.

I thought it was a good game. Swansea always play good stuff…they missed a couple, we missed a couple.

Anyone who thinks different to me is wrong.

Eccles is a good Championship player already and has a lot of potential. I thought he did well again today. I agree it was quite a good quality game on the whole. Disappointed we didn't win but a big improvement on the Stoke performance.

 

[Grendel]

Eccles is a good Championship player already and has a lot of potential. I thought he did well again today. I agree it was quite a good quality game on the whole. Disappointed we didn't win but a big improvement on the Stoke performance.

He isn’t a good championship player yet at all. If we had a fully fit squad he’d struggle to be on the bench

 

[Grendel]

Cuffey was dreadful today - let’s be honest if we are seriously trying to get enough points to get in the play offs he has to be bombed out

 

[Adge]

He isn’t a good championship player yet at all. If we had a fully fit squad he’d struggle to be on the bench

Don’t see it either myself. Another one of them ten a penny midfielders.

 

[Terry_dactyl]

Cuffey was dreadful today - let’s be honest if we are seriously trying to get enough points to get in the play offs he has to be bombed out

Not sure about bombed out but he’s definitely not the finished article. He seems really slow…which is a problem for a wingback.

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

Cuffey was dreadful today - let’s be honest if we are seriously trying to get enough points to get in the play offs he has to be bombed out

To be honest who’d be a better option. Dabo is out of form and Burroughs clearly isnt impressing Robins and Adi to not get a chance

 

[Kilclines curly mullet]

He isn’t a good championship player yet at all. If we had a fully fit squad he’d struggle to be on the bench

Agreed

Eccles will do a steady job for a lower level championship team but if we have aspirations for a proper play off push next year then for me, not good enough.

Ill add to that list Allen, Rose, Dabo, Godden, Wilson etc.

 

[Grendel]

Don’t see it either myself. Another one of them ten a penny midfielders.

Why is @PVA laughing?

 

[eastwoodsdustman]

I thought Godden made a difference when he came on. We created far more with him up front pressing their back 3 and keeper. He should have scored the chance he had but people saying he was poor need to look at the change from first to second half.

 

[CDK]

Lacking up top today not any creativity from midfield .defense very good Wilson had MOTM performance

 

[PVA]

Why is @PVA laughing?

 

[pusbccfc]

Cuffey was dreadful today - let’s be honest if we are seriously trying to get enough points to get in the play offs he has to be bombed out

Looks worse every week. Will be floating around the lower leagues in years to come.

 

[skybluepm2]

Cuffey was dreadful today - let’s be honest if we are seriously trying to get enough points to get in the play offs he has to be bombed out

Woeful yet again. Completely ineffective going forward and defensively. Seems to have no interest, desire or drive. Labours around on the touchline, not wanting the ball and when he does receive it, can’t beat a man or get a delivery into the box. At least on the other flank, Wilson-Esbrand was having a go and trying to create something today. By far the better of the 2.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Burroughs

Has he fallen out with management? After breaking through he seems to be being used less and less.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

He isn’t a good championship player yet at all. If we had a fully fit squad he’d struggle to be on the bench

He's alright as backup tbf, and this run of games will hopefully help him to improve next season

I did actually prefer him at RWB myself(!)

 

[WestEndAgro]

Good- Wilson, Doyle, Eccles, McNally.

Bang average - The rest

Atrocious - Hamer, Vik

 

[Blind-Faith]

Wilson 8
Norton-Cuffy 6
McNally 7
McFadzean 7
Doyle 7
Wilson-Esbrand 7
Eccles 6
Hamer 6
Sheaf 7
Allen 6
Gyokeres 5

Godden 5
Dabo 6
Bidwell 6