Referee (13 Viewers)

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member

Johhny Blue

Well-Known Member
100% agree with this. I'd also have a third man in rule. One player from each side can talk to the ref about any incident but if a third person starts moaning straight in the book

All this sort of shit could be stamped out pretty easily if they wanted to do something about it
Refs already have the power to do that
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
Refs already have the power to do that
There's a lot in the current rules that could be used to clamp down on things like diving and descent but there seems no will to do it

Then they act shocked when there's a situation with the one like the linesman last weekend
 

Nick

Administrator
Another interesting Guardian article on referees. It was the lino in our Watford game first match for 2 years due to Covid!

Which lino? I can't remember any of them being praised.

If it's the lino who got mcfadz booked and missed the penalty then surely they are just trolling?
 

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
Really good decision.

Thought he got a few wrong in the first half. Couldn't understand the McFadzean yellow. QPR fans saying he gave a lot of 50/50s to them, on their forum.
 
There was only 3 mins injury time. It should have been at least 7. Their guy went down in the 1st minute of the 2nd half and was down for 3 mins. They had another shorter injury and there were 3 or 4 substitution windows. I think he just felt sorry for a team with 10 men being 3 nil down
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
No idea how he only added on 5 mins. That was insane. It was so much more. Clearly.

He would have looked like a complete fool had their been VAR on the Panzo challenge, because he actually gave a free kick to them at first. He had to reverse that after talking to the linesman, but then would have had to have sent their player off too would'nt he?
 

Robinshio

Well-Known Member
No idea how he only added on 5 mins. That was insane. It was so much more. Clearly.

He would have looked like a complete fool had their been VAR on the Panzo challenge, because he actually gave a free kick to them at first. He had to reverse that after talking to the linesman, but then would have had to have sent their player off too would'nt he?
100% he was already booked, should definitely have gone
 

Frostie

Well-Known Member
No idea how he only added on 5 mins. That was insane. It was so much more. Clearly.

He would have looked like a complete fool had their been VAR on the Panzo challenge, because he actually gave a free kick to them at first. He had to reverse that after talking to the linesman, but then would have had to have sent their player off too would'nt he?
It would have only been VAR reviewed for a straight red card which it probably wasn't so he'd still have escaped the sending off.

The linesman must have seen it clearly to recommend the reversal of the decision though (we know they rarely get involved unless absolutely certain) so surely he should have been able to say exactly what happened & then the ref show the 2nd yellow.
 

Nick

Administrator
Even after that, he flew into a challenge after the whistle had gone. Can't remember who it was on.
 

MusicDating

Euro 2016 Prediction League Champion!!
No idea how he only added on 5 mins. That was insane. It was so much more. Clearly.

He would have looked like a complete fool had their been VAR on the Panzo challenge, because he actually gave a free kick to them at first. He had to reverse that after talking to the linesman, but then would have had to have sent their player off too would'nt he?

1681979929509.png
 

ProfessorbyGrace

Well-Known Member
It’s just basic decision making for a referee, according to the FA guidelines - THAT is a high foot, and therefore dangerous play: he should have had a straight red, let alone a second yellow. 🤷‍♂️

The standard of refereeing in the Championship is appalling.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top