Brum ratings (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
A complete performance, aside from the pot shot at the end Birmingham had nothing all game. Only criticism is 2-0 flattered them.
Wilson 7
Cuffy 8
McNally 7
McF 7
Doyle 7
Bidwell 7
Hamer 8
Eccles 7
Kelly 8
Godden 7
Gyo 8
Subs N/A
Wilson 7
Cuffy 8
McNally 7
McF 7
Doyle 7
Bidwell 7
Hamer 8
Eccles 7
Kelly 8
Godden 7
Gyo 8
Subs N/A
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Wilson 6 - didn't do anything wrong, nothing really to do either, so resolutely average! Not his fault, but would rather the keeper ended up with an average mark for just needing to turn up.
Norton-Cuffy 8 - his best defensive performance for us by far. Stuck to his man, was a decent roadblock, and tried to offer an outlet too.Up front didn't work so well, but...
McNally 7 - OK, bit casual at times.
McFadzean 8 - dominant first half, a little less second, but a proper captain's performance.
Doyle 8 - he's come on strong recently, at exactly the right time. More aggressive today, asserted himself and didn't let himself get dominated.
Bidwell 8 - always an outlet, a couple of decent shots, burst forward well, solid in defence.
Hamer 7 - passing on point in the main, couple of times again I can see why he goes for the quick pass to try and set us on the break, it does mean when it goes wrong it comes straight back at us.
Eccles 8 - forget the goal (not really his anyway was it!) but the best performance I've seen from him. Aggressive in the tackle, and his passing was a lot better than lately.
Kelly 7 - solid, been a bonus him coming back and just when a spot of experience to carry us over the line could be crucial. Who knew he had it in him still!
Godden 7 - (awaits the wrath of Evo!).Sometimes good, a couple of lovely turns, a beautiful break and ball to gyokeres who was offside. he and Gyokeres still don't gel though, do they? It's so hard to mark him on a day like today because I can fully see why some might give him higher today. I dunno, maybe I should abstain on giving him a mark! Do think that forget anything else, the first choice, and most reliable penalty taker at the club should be allowed to take the penalty when it comes!
Gyokeres 8 - he does have the uncanny knack of seeming to lose the ball, then come away with it! Brave /selfish / confident to demand the penalty, but it was a really good one at least. He's super-driven isn't he.
MOTM a toss-up between Eccles and Norton-Cuffy, mainly for general involvement in the game. Proper team performance today, though. Even Gyokeres looked to pass!
Norton-Cuffy 8 - his best defensive performance for us by far. Stuck to his man, was a decent roadblock, and tried to offer an outlet too.Up front didn't work so well, but...
McNally 7 - OK, bit casual at times.
McFadzean 8 - dominant first half, a little less second, but a proper captain's performance.
Doyle 8 - he's come on strong recently, at exactly the right time. More aggressive today, asserted himself and didn't let himself get dominated.
Bidwell 8 - always an outlet, a couple of decent shots, burst forward well, solid in defence.
Hamer 7 - passing on point in the main, couple of times again I can see why he goes for the quick pass to try and set us on the break, it does mean when it goes wrong it comes straight back at us.
Eccles 8 - forget the goal (not really his anyway was it!) but the best performance I've seen from him. Aggressive in the tackle, and his passing was a lot better than lately.
Kelly 7 - solid, been a bonus him coming back and just when a spot of experience to carry us over the line could be crucial. Who knew he had it in him still!
Godden 7 - (awaits the wrath of Evo!).Sometimes good, a couple of lovely turns, a beautiful break and ball to gyokeres who was offside. he and Gyokeres still don't gel though, do they? It's so hard to mark him on a day like today because I can fully see why some might give him higher today. I dunno, maybe I should abstain on giving him a mark! Do think that forget anything else, the first choice, and most reliable penalty taker at the club should be allowed to take the penalty when it comes!
Gyokeres 8 - he does have the uncanny knack of seeming to lose the ball, then come away with it! Brave /selfish / confident to demand the penalty, but it was a really good one at least. He's super-driven isn't he.
MOTM a toss-up between Eccles and Norton-Cuffy, mainly for general involvement in the game. Proper team performance today, though. Even Gyokeres looked to pass!
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
7/10 is fair , played well today ran his bollocks off
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
You scared me enought to mark his original rating up from 6! I just find it very difficult when it's a thankless task really, so it's hard to know if he's dipping out the game because of himself, or because Gyokeres is monopolising, or because we're just not very good at getting the ball to him. We won't get many strikers ever who can do what Gyokeres can and make something from nothing, so he spoils us atm too.
Last edited by a moderator:
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Everyone was decent but surprised I'm the only one who thinks Hamer was motm. Expected it to be echoing everyone else's view, personally thought he ran the show.
Most pleasing was the workrate from the entire side and Ben Wilson shithousing on that orrible fkr Hannibal.
Most pleasing was the workrate from the entire side and Ben Wilson shithousing on that orrible fkr Hannibal.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Forgot to add mine in, I’d agree with that.
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
Everyone 7/8. Probably give Fadz motm
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Came very close to finding the net
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Never seen the game today, the missus wanted to go away for the weekend grrrrrrr sounds like I missed a belter
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Everyone clearly understood what they needed to do and carried it out pretty much perfectly. We didn’t look tired even on 90 minutes, Brum looked out on their arses.
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Wilson 7
Cuffy 8
McNally 8
McF 8
Doyle 8
Bidwell 8
Hamer 7
Eccles 8.5 MOTM
Kelly 8
Godden 7
Gyo 8
Cuffy 8
McNally 8
McF 8
Doyle 8
Bidwell 8
Hamer 7
Eccles 8.5 MOTM
Kelly 8
Godden 7
Gyo 8
Alkhen
Well-Known Member
Nobody froze, really happy with that professional performance.
Norton-Cuffy was great today, he is growing into a good player.
Could have been a mauling if a few things went out way. That move where Godden dummies and let the ball run through his legs was great. Bidwells shot would have been special too
Norton-Cuffy was great today, he is growing into a good player.
Could have been a mauling if a few things went out way. That move where Godden dummies and let the ball run through his legs was great. Bidwells shot would have been special too
long way home
Well-Known Member
All 8s
Apart from Cuffy, Eccles and Bidwell who got 8.5 best games in City shirts for those 3. Great to see Eccles get his goal, that is another massive step in his development.
Apart from Cuffy, Eccles and Bidwell who got 8.5 best games in City shirts for those 3. Great to see Eccles get his goal, that is another massive step in his development.
I wish Godden had taken the shot on after his clever turn. An unselfish performance again. Thought Fadz or Norton-Cuffy were motm. Liam Kelly put in a great shift again. Two full games back to back after so long out and looking like he has never been away is a real credit to him.
Gyokeres looked like he was really struggling with an ankle injury. I thought he might not have come out second half. Hopefully nothing serious.
Gyokeres looked like he was really struggling with an ankle injury. I thought he might not have come out second half. Hopefully nothing serious.
Wilson 7 Elite-tier game management
BNC 7 Definitely his best game for us
McNally 7 Did a good job scrapping with Juke
McFadzean 7 Did all the usual McFadz stuff…are we about to see his last few games for us?!
Doyle 8 Getting better and better, such a talented player
Bidwell 8 Oozed confidence from the start, he was excellent
Kelly 7 May not have the legs anymore but his experience is what we need in this kind of game
Hamer 7 Comparatively low-key performance by his recent standards
Eccles 8 Scored a goal and won a penalty…needs some more bite in his game but he’s a key part of the squad now
Gyokeres 8 MOTM Two types of teams in this league - the ones who make a plan to contain him and the ones who don’t. Birmingham the latter - whoops.
Godden 7 Showed maturity with the penalty shenanigans and even released Vik for the offside goal
Allen N/A
All in all one of the most complete performances of the season. Once again Robins has tweaked the way we play mid-season and we’re hitting our stride at the right time of the year. What a guy.
BNC 7 Definitely his best game for us
McNally 7 Did a good job scrapping with Juke
McFadzean 7 Did all the usual McFadz stuff…are we about to see his last few games for us?!
Doyle 8 Getting better and better, such a talented player
Bidwell 8 Oozed confidence from the start, he was excellent
Kelly 7 May not have the legs anymore but his experience is what we need in this kind of game
Hamer 7 Comparatively low-key performance by his recent standards
Eccles 8 Scored a goal and won a penalty…needs some more bite in his game but he’s a key part of the squad now
Gyokeres 8 MOTM Two types of teams in this league - the ones who make a plan to contain him and the ones who don’t. Birmingham the latter - whoops.
Godden 7 Showed maturity with the penalty shenanigans and even released Vik for the offside goal
Allen N/A
All in all one of the most complete performances of the season. Once again Robins has tweaked the way we play mid-season and we’re hitting our stride at the right time of the year. What a guy.
Legia Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Teams that have a long throw specialist tend to over do it though, and seem to end up relying on it as their main attacking tactic. That's certainly the case with Birmingham. I'm also not sure its good for the development of players like Bellingham jnr, when the sole attacking aim is to play it long down the flanks hoping the opposition put it out for a throw, followed then by a long wait for the centre half to over before launching it in, and killing the momentum of the game in the process.
Last edited:
Captain_Slackbladder
Well-Known Member
Some are naturally better than others, but look at Gunnarson, came from a background of playing "handball" in Iceland. Perhaps get down the local athletic clubs and recruit some javelin throwers!
Nick
Administrator
We are Cov though?
Was it a long throw thing, or a way to stop people getting on the pitch? Either way, mostly worked!
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
Sure I read blues have only scored once this season from one of their long throws so if that's correct it's hardly the potent weapon some are making it out to be
Legia Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Its not just an attacking ploy though. It also slows the game down, making it a more scrappy stop start affair, and so making it more difficult for 'footballing' sides to get into a rhythm of play.