Hamer (20 Viewers)

procdoc

Well-Known Member
Never got the hatred of Max - he was part of our revival iirc, and not part of the downward spiral.
He wasn’t a very good footballer. I didn’t hate him, just thought he was nowhere near good enough in the championship. One particular incident sticks out when he made a run that impeded our other forward (might have been Godden) rather than created space for him
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
oh he said we needed to keep biamou and get rid of Gyokeres and preferred Kelly to hamer - I’ve linked these posts numerous times and he denies it

a lot of people were prepared to die on the Max Biamou hill. At one point it was only me and you that said how shite he was
Not sure that's true.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
He wasn’t a very good footballer. I didn’t hate him, just thought he was nowhere near good enough in the championship. One particular incident sticks out when he made a run that impeded our other forward (might have been Godden) rather than created space for him
For me it was the bizarre 'pass' against Forest that they then scored from in the 92nd minute to win the game. It was 100% the right decision to let him go as his career since has shown.
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
weren’t he injured all season when we got promoted when he did his ACL?
No?

League 2 he played 40 games. Started playoff final

League 1 promotion season played 18 games. Scored last min winner be Bolton just before seaosn packed up iirc

Think acl season was the year we didn't go up in league 1.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
He was a good striker for the level that we were. If he was shit as people like to say we wouldn't have got promoted twice with him.

in the league 1 promotion season he featured for less than 800 minutes in total

we finished 6th in league two - hardly a mega achievement either
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
No?

League 2 he played 40 games. Started playoff final

League 1 promotion season played 18 games. Scored last min winner be Bolton just before seaosn packed up iirc

Think acl season was the year we didn't go up in league 1.

As I’ve said in league 1 he played less than 800 minutes
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
in the league 1 promotion season he featured for less than 800 minutes in total

we finished 6th in league two - hardly a mega achievement either
He contributed to two promotions regardless.

Dont have to have him as your favourite player but he clearly was never shite.

The issue with biamou is that he had some diehard fans who would still want him in prem etc. But any posters issue should be with those weirdos rather than trying to put max the player down .
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Tbf he was at times. His improvement this past season has been phenomenal.

The Birmingham game ironically proved a water shed moment
 

fatso

Well-Known Member
Never got the hatred of Max - he was part of our revival iirc, and not part of the downward spiral.
It's not hatred at all, just an honest assessment of his talent. We needed better, and in Vik we got better.

It's weird how whenever someone points out a players obvious shortcomings, it's interpreted as hatred! Where the fuck did that come from?
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Tavares is not at the level, but I don't see us spending money on a 4th choice striker to get 5 or 10 mins off the bench now and then.

Unless we sign two more strikers and bump Godden down to 4th choice, which also seems unlikely. He would surely be the best 4th choice striker in the division.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Tavares is not at the level, but I don't see us spending money on a 4th choice striker to get 5 or 10 mins off the bench now and then.

Unless we sign two more strikers and bump Godden down to 4th choice.

That’s what I’d expect. Another perm to partner Simms and a Prem loanee to challenge, then Godden.
 

Sky Blue Harry H

Well-Known Member
It's not hatred at all, just an honest assessment of his talent. We needed better, and in Vik we got better.

It's weird how whenever someone points out a players obvious shortcomings, it's interpreted as hatred! Where the fuck did that come from?
Poor choice of word from me - perhaps detractors would have been more appropriate.
 

mmttww

Well-Known Member
oh he said we needed to keep biamou and get rid of Gyokeres and preferred Kelly to hamer - I’ve linked these posts numerous times and he denies it

In fact he spends more times searching my posts as attending live games. To be fair he’d only have to search three a season to achieve that
Someone with a bit of a humility would just hold their hands up and admit they dropped a clanger. Hamer turned it round and with Vik, carried us to Wembley. You just go on the offensive and fire shots at anyone you can think of on unrelated subjects. It's a bit grim.
 

Sick Boy

Super Moderator
Tavares is not at the level, but I don't see us spending money on a 4th choice striker to get 5 or 10 mins off the bench now and then.

Unless we sign two more strikers and bump Godden down to 4th choice, which also seems unlikely. He would surely be the best 4th choice striker in the division.
He needs to play first team football for his own sake. The way some go on about him you’d think he’s a 16 year old wonderkid when in reality he’ll be 23 in less than 6 months and has never played first team football.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Someone with a bit of a humility would just hold their hands up and admit they dropped a clanger. Hamer turned it round and with Vik, carried us to Wembley. You just go on the offensive and fire shots at anyone you can think of on unrelated subjects. It's a bit grim.

Im hardly going on the offensive - I’m certainly not taking lessons either from someone who wanted shot of Gyokeres after his loan spell and extending biamous contract
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
He needs to play first team football for his own sake. The way some go on about him you’d think he’s a 16 year old wonderkid when in reality he’ll be 23 in less than 6 months and has never played first team football.

That’s the reality - we need two more forwards even if we keep godden
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Im hardly going on the offensive - I’m certainly not taking lessons either from someone who wanted shot of Gyokeres after his loan spell and extending biamous contract

Can you point out where I wanted shot of Gyokeres after his loan spell?
 

skyblu3sk

Well-Known Member
Im hardly going on the offensive - I’m certainly not taking lessons either from someone who wanted shot of Gyokeres after his loan spell and extending biamous contract
"I'm hardly going in the offensive" he says then goes on the offensive 🤣 you dropped the ball on this one own it.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Can you point out where I wanted shot of Gyokeres after his loan spell?

it was during his loan spell and I’ve posted the link several times as you well know
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Here you bracket him ability wise to hillsner

 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
So no then. Thought so.

As you were.

but we’ve had these discussions several times shall I now start posting links to the links to the links - you seem very forgetful these days
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Here you bracket him ability wise to hillsner


Can you read?
 

Ccfcisparks

Well-Known Member
Here you bracket him ability wise to hillsner

To be fair you did say a few posts down that Reid would be first choice in the 21/22 season. We all have rubbish opinions sometimes.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
At the same time I made that post you were saying Gyökeres was as bad as Biamou.

Just get a fucking life you weirdo.

Yes you keep saying that - I think @mmttww will say you are being defensive

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top