Joel Latibeaudiere (10 Viewers)

[Grendel]

Is he worth more now ? He hasn’t featured for them hence the lower valuation , with add ons . Possibly up to £3 million in total

You can’t rate him if that’s all he’s worth

 

---

[Sky Blue Pete]

What did Burney pay 2M is that structured on add ons?
The only development he got was here for which they've obviously been compensated £2.5M Max.

How have they been compensated?

 

[Martin180]

You can’t rate him if that’s all he’s worth

What’s the going rate for championship defenders ?

 

[Ccfcisparks]

What’s the going rate for championship defenders ?

One's who've played half a season at that.

 

[Martin180]

One's who've played half a season at that.

Exactly , Hyam went for £2 million and he’s way more experienced

 

[Grendel]

How?

People on here said he’s made a massive difference in getting us to the play offs - he’s on a lengthy contract with a premier league club and wages - we want him to help us get another push yet he’s worth a token transfer fee?

 

[fernandopartridge]

Exactly , Hyam went for £2 million and he’s way more experienced

But an inferior player who is older

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Exactly , Hyam went for £2 million and he’s way more experienced

Don't get G started on that Hyam transfer.

 

[Grendel]

Exactly , Hyam went for £2 million and he’s way more experienced

So is Liam Kelly

 

[Martin180]

People on here said he’s made a massive difference in getting us to the play offs - he’s on a lengthy contract with a premier league club and wages - we want him to help us get another push yet he’s worth a token transfer fee?

How is £1.5 million a token fee for a defender ? I did say with add ons up to £3 million ! Do you value him higher ? Bearing in mind we’ve paid £3.5 for Simms and around a million for Sakamoto

 

[Ccfcisparks]

If McNally is worth north of £4m then theres no way that Hamer isnt worth more than £10m.

 

[Martin180]

So is Liam Kelly

If you want to have a debate I will debate , if you go back to be your usual obtusive self I’ll save my breath

 

[Martin180]

If McNally is worth north of £4m then theres no way that Hamer isnt worth more than £10m.

And Simms is £3.5 , go figure

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

If McNally is worth north of £4m then theres no way that Hamer isnt worth more than £10m.

Agree

 

[Martin180]

But an inferior player who is older

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Inferior is debatable

 

[TomRad85]

If i was the club I'd be looking at £3 million, can always offer them a bit extra if we get promoted too.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[Evo1883]

Inferior is debatable

Debatable ofcourse .. but I doubt there's many who believe hyam is better than mcnally .. because he's not

 

[Grendel]

And Simms is £3.5 , go figure

Its £5m with add ons

 

[Grendel]

Inferior is debatable

it isn’t

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Its £5m with add ons

Wheres this from?

 

[Perryccfc]

Think the issue with McNally will be wages more than the fee. He will more than likely have had a promotion pay rise in his contract. Would be interesting to know if that takes him out of our wage structure.

 

[fernandopartridge]

Inferior is debatable

It really isn't

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[SeaSeeEffCee]

I don't know how we can be arguing that Hamer is worth so much money based off the play-off run and then try and cheap out on McNally when the defence, which was transformed when he came in, were probably the biggest reason we qualified.

 

[Martin180]

I don't know how we can be arguing that Hamer is worth so much money based off the play-off run and then try and cheap out on McNally when the defence, which was transformed when he came in, were probably the biggest reason we qualified.

I’m not cheaping out on him , he’s surplus to requirements at Burnley . The question was what would you pay for him , I said an initial £1.5 million rising to £3 million with add ons included . I don’t feel we should be paying the £4 million that’s been suggested

 

[skyblueelephant76]

I don't know how we can be arguing that Hamer is worth so much money based off the play-off run and then try and cheap out on McNally when the defence, which was transformed when he came in, were probably the biggest reason we qualified.

We kept 12 clean sheets before he arrived and 10 after he signed. He was a good signing but I'm not sure he transformed the defence. Fadz getting fit and Doyle improving played as much of a part.

 

[Grendel]

And Simms is £3.5 , go figure

Nope

Everton set to bank £3.5m from Ellis Simms transfer to Coventry City

Everton will bank an initial £3.5m for one completed Goodison Park exit in a deal that will feature staggered payments and could be worth up to £8m - iNews.

www.goodisonnews.com

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Nope

Everton set to bank £3.5m from Ellis Simms transfer to Coventry City

Everton will bank an initial £3.5m for one completed Goodison Park exit in a deal that will feature staggered payments and could be worth up to £8m - iNews.

www.goodisonnews.com

Extremely unlike you to take paper talk as gospel.

 

[Martin180]

Nope

Everton set to bank £3.5m from Ellis Simms transfer to Coventry City

Everton will bank an initial £3.5m for one completed Goodison Park exit in a deal that will feature staggered payments and could be worth up to £8m - iNews.

www.goodisonnews.com

Now I’m totally lost I suggested 1.5 with add ons for McNally quoting we paid an initial 3.5 for Simms and you post something that says the same thing

 

[Grendel]

Now I’m totally lost I suggested 1.5 with add ons for McNally quoting we paid an initial 3.5 for Simms and you post something that says the same thing

no you kept comparing the two fees and saying we paid £3.5m - we haven’t - the general consensus it’s £5m as long as appearances are achieved and up to £8m if we get promoted

Simms has played fewer championship and league 1 games than McNally so why you think there should be much disparity I’ve no idea

 

[Ccfcisparks]

no you kept comparing the two fees and saying we paid £3.5m - we haven’t - the general consensus it’s £5m as long as appearances are achieved and up to £8m if we get promoted

Simms has played fewer championship and league 1 games than McNally so why you think there should be much disparity I’ve no idea

How often do defenders go for as much as strikers. Thats why there is so much disparity.

 

[Grendel]

How often do defenders go for as much as strikers. Thats why there is so much disparity.

Is he better than Hyam? Do you seriously think they’d sell for £1.5m?

 

[Martin180]

no you kept comparing the two fees and saying we paid £3.5m - we haven’t - the general consensus it’s £5m as long as appearances are achieved and up to £8m if we get promoted

Simms has played fewer championship and league 1 games than McNally so why you think there should be much disparity I’ve no idea

Because strikers go for more than defenders , anyway I’m out

 

[Martin180]

How often do defenders go for as much as strikers. Thats why there is so much disparity.

Give it up mate , you won’t win and end up wishing why you bothered

 

[Grendel]

Give it up mate , you won’t win and end up wishing why you bothered

Well you won’t be getting defenders for sub £2m from Burnley so we’d better give up and look at lower leagues or out of contracts

 

[Deleted member 9744]

Why would Burnley sell him for less than they paid last summer?

Because he is no use to them in the Premier League.