Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
McNally wasnt a MASSIVe step up from Hyam. Yes big step up from Rose agreed.
I think Hyam went for over £2M and is worth probably double that now hes an international and was their player of the season.
Hamer (11 Viewers)
- Thread starter Covcraig@bury
- Start date
I think Hyam went for over £2M and is worth probably double that now hes an international and was their player of the season.
Balli001
Well-Known Member
In my opinion mcnally was far better than hyam
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
I respect your opinion.
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Pete in Portugal
Well-Known Member
21 games playing for a minor team in league 2
51 games playing in league 1
No experience of playing in Championship
He'd have to be rated as an outstanding prospect to be valued at £1m. He might be, but I think it's unlikely, given his career to date.
I think Burnley are overvaluing him, and to a lesser extent McNally, in order to reduce the cash element.
Balli001
Well-Known Member
Neither had mcnally or Doyle until last season
Your valuation of the guy is completely off, but you have at least hit the nail on the head as to why part-exchange deals are usually bad ideas.
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
As for the chances of Hamer signing a new contract at City, Robins said: "Look, that's something that he knows where we stand and he knows where he stands, and we just get on with things. There's a massive respect there from him. He respects everything we do and have done for him, and continue to do, and I think that's something that. you know, the way that he is and the way that he works, that's why everyone loves him because his attitude is good.
"He works with everyone and doesn't pull against anyone. He's not shown any dissent. He is coming into the last year of his contract so he knows where he sits, but he also knows that we want him and would like him to stay for at least another 12 months, and then let's see where we are after that.
"He works with everyone and doesn't pull against anyone. He's not shown any dissent. He is coming into the last year of his contract so he knows where he sits, but he also knows that we want him and would like him to stay for at least another 12 months, and then let's see where we are after that.
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
His passing isn’t very good
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
As I said he is a good defender. However his passing was poor and I think this season we may want to play more of a passing game rather than the long ball to Gyokeres approach of parts of last season.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
That was in Portugal where Burnley’s mind control contrails can’t reach.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
He runs himself into trouble as well. You can see why he didn’t play for Burnley. I think people rate him a bit higher because of how poor our RCB position was since Hyam left. He’s very good, but he’s not worth more than Ellis Simms.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Neither was Hyam's which was what the inference was
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Balli001
Well-Known Member
No I rate him highly because he is an excellent defender
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
I’d have McNally back for reasonable price but if Burnley start quoting silly amount I’d look elsewhere.
Esoterica
Well-Known Member
Hyam was good at passing - behind his wingback and onto his wrong foot.
Flying Fokker
Well-Known Member
It's good isn't it? We aren't talking about SISU, administration, Timmy, Joy, Northampton, Birmingham, NOPM, Loyal fans, shit managers, shit owners or anything like that. What a refreshing change.
Here's hoping there is some more stuff going on in the background. In the meantime, I'm happy with the way things are!
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Balli001
Well-Known Member
Both. Clearly he has a valuation I don't deny that but I'd go to 4 million.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Up front? For me we’ve just paid £3.5m for a young striker who has played in the Prem and was on for 20 goals last season, I wouldn’t pay more for an older defender who has only made it above L1 with us.
Balli001
Well-Known Member
But simms is up to 8 million.
HuckerbyDublinWhelan
Well-Known Member
Yeah this arguing over football matters is tedious…
Where’s the stadium ownership arguments ffs
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
If we play on the moon or whatever. In a cash plus players deal McNally would only be worth the up front fee.
Say £2m rising to £4m with add ons I’d be OK with.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
That's exactly what I was thinking about, the amount of times he failed to play the ball at the right time into the player's path and it broke our momentum.
Can't remember that being an issue with McNally and can't remember a pass from Hyam at anywhere near the level as the one McNally made to play Gyokeres in for the first goal v Sunderland.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Balli001
Well-Known Member
They paid 2 and he now has half a season championship experience.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
They are both very good defenders. Diateibution can be better. McNally is still 23 so can will improve. Hyams played well over 100 games in championship and more than proven himself at 2 clubs.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
When you think about it Hyam what a signing that was. Did the whole journey with us up the leagues. Signed for peanuts as decelopement player. Sold for upwards of £2.5M profit potentially more to come. And we got 5 years good service out of him.
If we can half of that service/contribution/profit from any of our new defenders will be great.
If we can half of that service/contribution/profit from any of our new defenders will be great.
Old Warwickshire lad
Well-Known Member
Think we are looking at McNally through sky blue tinted glasses.
He was good yea,but not that good when he first came.
Plenty of mistakes in him at the start. We improved him and he was becoming a good prospect by the end of the season.He has a lot of improving to do.
Personally I think Burnley paid too much for him.
He was good yea,but not that good when he first came.
Plenty of mistakes in him at the start. We improved him and he was becoming a good prospect by the end of the season.He has a lot of improving to do.
Personally I think Burnley paid too much for him.
Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
Wait, what? We didn't get over £2.5m for Hyam??
Matt smith
Well-Known Member
Think we did, apparently there was reports it was more than the supposed 1.5 million that was being quoted everywhere
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Financial revelation emerges on Blackburn Rovers and Coventry City transfer agreement for Dom Hyam
The defender joined for a bigger fee than reported.
footballleagueworld.co.uk
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Hmm, think he was pretty good straight away, no?
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
According to some reports ..more to come.
Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
Wowzers - didn't see that.
And all those that moaned that we sold him for peanuts/next to nothing when it happened.
Just shows that no one really knows what's going on.
And all those that moaned that we sold him for peanuts/next to nothing when it happened.
Just shows that no one really knows what's going on.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
It was a one off payment of around £1.8 million