Matty godden (8 Viewers)

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
Yes but single shot xG or single game xG isn't much use, the whole point of xG is over a large dataset. That said, he has the highest xG & npxG per 90 in our team, which is encouraging that he's getting into good positions, but simply put he's not taking the chances.

He actually ranks in the top 5 players in the league for npxG per Shot so these are really good chances but he is actually in the bottom 10 for npG:xG ratio.
Thanks for clarifying 👍

What site you using so I can keep it on my pc
 

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Yes but single shot xG or single game xG isn't much use, the whole point of xG is over a large dataset. That said, he has the highest xG & npxG per 90 in our team, which is encouraging that he's getting into good positions, but simply put he's not taking the chances.

He actually ranks in the top 5 players in the league for npxG per Shot so these are really good chances but he is actually in the bottom 10 for npG:xG ratio.
Which I guess backs up what we're saying. In that we know that he doesn't contribute much to our general play, and is in for his finishing. But he isn't finishing the good chances he is getting. And my point which was he isn't scoring the crucial match winning goals at the minute - football is often about the fine margins and big moments.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
 

Frostie

Well-Known Member
Which I guess backs up what we're saying. In that we know that he doesn't contribute much to our general play, and is in for his finishing. But he isn't finishing the good chances he is getting.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Think there's a fair debate about what he offers other than goals. I think his role has changed a bit with the way we're playing now - especially in the absence of O'Hare but what's undeniable is his finishing isn't at his usual standard. This is the first time since we've been back in the Championship that he hasn't outperformed his xG.
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
Which I guess backs up what we're saying. In that we know that he doesn't contribute much to our general play, and is in for his finishing. But he isn't finishing the good chances he is getting. And my point which was he isn't scoring the crucial match winning goals at the minute - football is often about the fine margins and big moments.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

The fine margin against Millwall and Hull was Simon Moore playing like a pitch invader.
 

Evo1883

Well-Known Member
Think there's a fair debate about what he offers other than goals. I think his role has changed a bit with the way we're playing now - especially in the absence of O'Hare but what's undeniable is his finishing isn't at his usual standard. This is the first time since we've been back in the Championship that he hasn't outperformed his xG.
I also feel that his workrate is often overlooked too , but hey .. some people say that's just running
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
Great what about the other 22 games he's played in?

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

I've said I think we need to move him on, but to assess his contribution in the way you have is fairly strange, it's hardly his fault the keeper fucked up badly.
 

stupot07

Well-Known Member
So we are now at , godden has been shit every match he's played in ?

Think we are bordering on bizarre now
That's not what I've said at all. You're seeing something that isn't there. That's more bizarre


Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
 

SBAndy

Well-Known Member
He is but the XG isn't large to begin with , per 90 he's under performing by 0.13 or so .. it's minimal stuff

They aren't huge sitters basically

If he’s performing at -0.13 per game (haven’t checked the stats so hopefully I’m assuming this correctly) that’s basically equating to a big chance every 2 games he’s missing (think ‘big chance’ is usually 0.3). I do take into account the later comments around his work rate and that’s fair. I suppose if we don’t have goals spread throughout the team we can’t really afford to carry someone renowned for his finishing who’s not delivering.

I don’t dislike Godden, think he’s served us very well over time, but it feels like the right time to accept he’s the next to fall by the wayside (whether out the door or down the pecking order).
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Fair enough , so what's goddens role then ? We all know if he wasn't playing to instructuctions he'd be pulled out , as we've seen with others in the past
Isn't it as much Robins trusts him based on past performances? He's clearly got a good attitude too - it's him and Dabo were the indispensables, you can probably add Allen to that list now as well, players that do exactly what they're asked to do, put their hands up even if not 100% fit, and keep going for the team even if in a dip.

I dunno, maybe Walker didn't react in the right way after his start against Blackpool too. Maybe Godden scoring won him the place and Walker has reacted badly to that? I dunno.

As a small aside, if Gyokeres leaves then maybe Godden will work better with whoever replaces him, too. It's not all Godden being anonymous, it's also a system that isn't playing to Godden's strengths.
 

Ashdown

Well-Known Member
If Gyokeres leaves then we will need to buy two more decent strikers with the money. We couldn’t possibly rely on Godden or Walker as our main strike force .
 

Skybluedownunder

Well-Known Member
If Gyokeres leaves then we will need to buy two more decent strikers with the money. We couldn’t possibly rely on Godden or Walker as our main strike force .

Wouldn’t mind seeing Liam Delap or Cole Palmer come on loan. Liam hasn’t really had a proper run at Preston and just coming on here and there, scored bags of goals in the Man City U’23s. Cole Palmer not getting game time in the first team obviously so will probably need to go out on loan next season.

It’s all well and good looking at their stats and saying yeah they have played this many games but only scored this many goals but it’s not a clear picture as he’s only playing 5 mins a game so it throws their stats out. They’ve both bagged a serious amount of goals in youth leagues so they’ve got the eye for goal but just not getting the minutes.

Sometimes the right management can get the best out of a player like we’ve been mentioning on this forum recently and perhaps Adi & Robbins could do for someone like Delap what they did with Gyokeres.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Wouldn’t mind seeing Liam Delap or Cole Palmer come on loan. Liam hasn’t really had a proper run at Preston and just coming on here and there, scored bags of goals in the Man City U’23s. Cole Palmer not getting game time in the first team obviously so will probably need to go out on loan next season.

It’s all well and good looking at their stats and saying yeah they have played this many games but only scored this many goals but it’s not a clear picture as he’s only playing 5 mins a game so it throws their stats out. They’ve both bagged a serious amount of goals in youth leagues so they’ve got the eye for goal but just not getting the minutes.

Sometimes the right management can get the best out of a player like we’ve been mentioning on this forum recently and perhaps Adi & Robbins could do for someone like Delap what they did with Gyokeres.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Delap has been terrible for Stoke and Preston.

That's not to say that Robins couldn't get a tune out of him, as you say. But he has been genuinely rubbish even if you ignore the stats.
 

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Delap has been terrible for Stoke and Preston.

That's not to say that Robins couldn't get a tune out of him, as you say. But he has been genuinely rubbish even if you ignore the stats.
You'd only want him for 3rd choice based on what he has done at Stoke and Preston.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
 

Matt smith

Well-Known Member
Matty godden could leave in the summer

past his best and anonymous most weeks this season

he’ll do as a fourth choice mind
 
Last edited:

Skybluedownunder

Well-Known Member
Delap has been terrible for Stoke and Preston.

That's not to say that Robins couldn't get a tune out of him, as you say. But he has been genuinely rubbish even if you ignore the stats.

It’s weird that it’s not gone so well for him at these clubs when he was so prolific going up through the ages. He’s not getting the minutes at Preston so it’s hard to judge him when he’s only getting 5 mins here and there, I couldn’t seem to get the stats on him of what he did at Stoke but him and Cole Palmer were supposed to both be very highly regarded at Man City. Did Delap have a few stinkers did he? Sometimes you just feel if someone is so highly regarded have they just had the wrong manager with them and could we do what we did with Gyokeres and it was just a case of wrong place wrong time.

But yeah my preference would be to take a gamble loan on a young up and coming who’s been banging them in for the U21s/U23s who needs the next step up challenge like we did with Adam Armstrong, he had a real Shearer style of play he did, great to watch when we had him.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Frostie

Well-Known Member
Very good today.
As others have said, he just looks that bit sharper. Obviously helps that he's playing more his natural role again now too rather than a foil for Vik.
Was never worried about the missed chances, good strikers always come through patches like that. Still not keen on the fingers in ears but can understand his thoughts.
 
Last edited:

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Very good today.
As others have said, he just looks that but sharper. Obviously helps that he's playing more his natural role again now too rather than a foil for Vik.
Was never worried about the missed chances, good strikers always come through patches like that. Still not keen on the fingers in ears but can understand his thoughts.
To be fair that's his first goal from open play since Millwall last season, which was 573 minutes before todays goal, and for someone who has to play because he's the man you want on the end of a chance, he's missed some really good chances in that period. He played well today, but he needs to back it up now.



Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
 

Ornitier

Well-Known Member
Glad he got the two goals. Matty Godden has been one of my favourite players of the last few years, and possibly in my top 5 ever, and was sensational in our League One promotion campaign.

Saying that, what’s with the fingers in the ears celebration? If it’s because a couple of bad eggs on twitter (sorry…X) were giving him a bit of abuse for not scoring against Leicester then it’s a shitty way to celebrate in front of 24k fans, the majority of which love him.
 

Paul Anthony

Well-Known Member
Credit to him today, he did very well. Hopefully that's just what he needed to get him back to his best form.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top