He’s not going to be good enough for us on current showing. The decision to start him was wrong and it’s the reason we didn’t win. Thought everyone played well except Simms. If he offered things in general play i wouldn’t be bothered about the lack of goals but there is literally nothing. He looks lost.
Transfer Rumour Ellis Simms (9 Viewers)
- Thread starter Frankly_Mr_Shankly
- Start date
I saw him make several runs where the ball wasn’t played in or was played too late. The team just needs time to bed in.
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
I thought he was ok today, put through a couple of times by Palmer and nearly scored.
Ive just got a bad feeling though, because he’s not Gyokeres, people are writing him off already.
He desperately needs a goal to get people off his back
Ive just got a bad feeling though, because he’s not Gyokeres, people are writing him off already.
He desperately needs a goal to get people off his back
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
It's more to do with his price tag for me. He's a big lad who doesn't win many duels.
He's the type of player where we'll need to adapt to his style rather than him adapting to ours.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Happened a lot when Allen the season before last. Then last season we worked out he was doing it and started to pass to him.
So come 2024-2025...
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
He just needs some time to grow into his own body in a footballing sense, Gyokeres was exactly the same.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
He needs the ball to hit him and go in but he needs to be on the pitch for that, today it was ludicrous to leave on Godden and take him off.
SkyblueTexan
Well-Known Member
Sunderland fans seem glad they didn't buy Simms, especially for that high a price. Think with Gyo, it was a low-priced gamble with a lot of potential upside. With Simms (and also Wright) the expectation for success is so high partly because of the outlay. The longer the barren spell goes on for Simms, the more fans and media are going to turn against him and his confidence will obviously take a hit. Need to gel with the rest of the team fast.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Thing is, is 3-4 games really that much of a barren spell?!?
SkyBlue_Bear83
Well-Known Member
I thought at the time it wasn't a bad signing but we paid well over the odds.
For me he's not ahead in his development of where Gyokeres was at the time we bought him, but his transfer fee is massive compared to what we paid for Gyokeres.
£1.5-£2 million would have been a fair price for him.
Everton are a shit show at the moment and desperate for a striker, they played without a recognised striker today and yet they were still happy to let Simms go.
For me he's not ahead in his development of where Gyokeres was at the time we bought him, but his transfer fee is massive compared to what we paid for Gyokeres.
£1.5-£2 million would have been a fair price for him.
Everton are a shit show at the moment and desperate for a striker, they played without a recognised striker today and yet they were still happy to let Simms go.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
No. And he’s 22 and cost half as much as Wright. It’s mental that all the expectation is on him (and he plays like it!).
I think Robins had a feeling he would score against his old team. I prefer form and evidence and wouldn’t have had Simms in the team.
Bad call by Robins starting Simms today.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
I want to see him play with Wright rather than Godden.
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
Couldn't give a single fuck what they think.
ccfc1234
Well-Known Member
Me and my partner saying exactly this on the way home.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
He's played just 218 minutes in the league season, and I may be wrong but I don't think he's played a minute of league football with Wright.
For me, he looks more of a Godden type player but is being asked to do a different role to accommodate Godden.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Think they would look clueless together.
fatso
Well-Known Member
Why? are you miraculously expecting him to turn into Harry Kane or something?
Or do 2 wrongs make a right?
Exactly. Three and a bit games in. 22 years old. Fuck all service today, loads of runs ignored and some of our fantastic, supportive fan base is slagging and writing him off already. Nice one lads.
Astute
Well-Known Member
Most of our team are not up to.speed. The defence is dodgy. The midfield has no control. The forwards are not scoring enough.
Yet out of all our players the only one who seems to be getting any stick is Simms. What some need to remember is he hadn't played since January. His fitness and sharpness are still behind where they need to be. And they will only get better by playing.
Something else we need to remember is he is a young and relatively inexperienced player. He is still learning every game. And as a team we are behind where we need to be. The games we have had so far are against sides that should be in or near the playoffs so far. I reserve my judgement until he has more minutes under his belt and plays against the lower down sides.
Wagehorn got a first half hat trick today
who saw that coming?
Yet out of all our players the only one who seems to be getting any stick is Simms. What some need to remember is he hadn't played since January. His fitness and sharpness are still behind where they need to be. And they will only get better by playing.
Something else we need to remember is he is a young and relatively inexperienced player. He is still learning every game. And as a team we are behind where we need to be. The games we have had so far are against sides that should be in or near the playoffs so far. I reserve my judgement until he has more minutes under his belt and plays against the lower down sides.
Wagehorn got a first half hat trick today
who saw that coming?
M&B Stand
Well-Known Member
No one is writing him off mate, but you gotta admit it’s been a pretty poor start…
Covcraig@bury
Well-Known Member
Was working with a Everton fan this week and I asked about Simms , he pissed his sides and told me he is shite , after today I have to agree . Can we return him and get our money back ? Because he isn’t what he was advertised for ( striker / goal scorer) lazier than Walker IMO … sorry
SIR ERNIE
Well-Known Member
Agree. That's clearly what the idea was a few weeks ago and a huge amount of money was spent to make it happen.
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
He started 3 games for them
fatso
Well-Known Member
Typical bed wetters response.
No ones writing him off, no ones saying he won't be the answer.
People are just saying he's been poor so far.
That's fair comment. He's the only new signing that hasn't shown promise yet, but that may come. (Hopefully soon)
He was given a chance today, against a team he should of been motivated for, but he failed to impress. He can't blame MR for not giving him a chance.
Now stop jumping up and down, stop pulling your hair out, and just calm down.
He had a better goals per minute than Gyokeres I think.
And no, I'm not saying he's better than Vik before anyone loses their shit.
He was tidy enough today. Held ball up ok, midfielders didn’t release balls a number of times he made runs and he had one tough chance from tricky angle that keeper saved.
I’ll give it 10 games or so before judging the new lads. Teams still a bit disjointed. Played some great stuff first half, tailed off a bit second (still not fully match up fit and we looked leggy last 20)
M&B Stand
Well-Known Member
I’d give him longer than that to be honest the money we’ve spunked on him!
I just think everyone expected better than what he’s shown so far.
Micky Adams shelling out 900k on Kevin Kyle when we were skint has scarred me!!
If he was any good they wouldn’t have sold him. People will keep saying he will come good though as they think they are being a nice fan
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
The barren spell? Get a grip. Ffs.
Covcraig@bury
Well-Known Member
I hope he does become good and he proves me and everyone else wrongIf he was any good they wouldn’t have sold him. People will keep saying he will come good though as they think they are being a nice fan
