Dean Austin (9 Viewers)

[Bugsy]

The two wing backs haven’t been excellent and one was signed without any input from Austin anyway

I doubt he’d have chose simms either or Joel as these are known players

they have been a big improvement on our last 2 WB

 

---

[Matt smith]

they have been a big improvement on our last 2 WB

Really like JDS

did a great turn in his own box first half and you could tell he’s technically very sound

 

[SlowerThanPlatt]

Exactly what I said, least I’m honest

If he gets 7/8 goals from here he’d have done well - his career is all or nothing

 

[clint van damme]

Having thought about it .. it's a little bit mental to be throwing his recruitment under the bus until the season is over or looks to be over ..

Imagine the amount of posts on here and in other threads that will be pulled up if we end up having a stormer of a season because we stopped conceding late

With some luck we'd be sat top 6 ? Late goals against Hull, Huddersfield, Leicester etc whilst only being in 2nd gear

Some of us have been having these arguments with the doom mongers every year, and every year their bedwetting has been proven wrong.

However, I feel this season might be one of disappointment and I've not got many positives to push back on the with other than Robins and Adi always find a way and we do tend to swing from can't buy a win to top of the form table and back again quite frequently!
.
Be great for all our well being if we could pick up points at a steadier rate.

 

[Matt smith]

If he gets 7/8 goals from here he’d have done well - his career is all or nothing

I hope he’s like a sheaf where it all just clicks second season maybe

 

[Grendel]

they have been a big improvement on our last 2 WB

They have in reality created very little yet have they?

 

[Bugsy]

They have in reality created very little yet have they?

give them a chance eh???

 

[Matt smith]

Some of us have been having these arguments with the doom mongers every year, and every year their bedwetting has been proven wrong.

However, I feel this season might be one of disappointment and I've not got many positives to push back on the with other than Robins and Adi always find a way and we do tend to swing from can't buy a win to top of the form table and back again quite frequently!
.
Be great for all our well being if we could pick up points at a steadier rate.

Last season

shit run
Great run pre WC
Shit run January
Great run

 

[clint van damme]

when scouting sakamoto originally we signed him cos he impressed in a game when we were watching another player

It's not unusual for that to happen, it's how we got Michael Rose.

 

[Grendel]

give them a chance eh???

Im saying they haven’t been brilliant - given the slime thrown around regarding other players it’s a pretty mild comment

 

[Deleted member 5849]

It's not unusual for that to happen, it's how we got Michael Rose.

Although maybe signing Ndlovu when he played well in a game against us(?) would be a better example(!)

 

[Matt smith]

Im saying they haven’t been brilliant - given the slime thrown around regarding other players it’s a pretty mild comment

What about Palmer

 

[Grendel]

What about Palmer

Palmer was a terrible signing

 

[Deleted member 9744]

So we're giving up on the new signings then?
Da Silva and Van Ewijk have been excellent.
Bobby Thomas & Hadji Wright were being raved about after the first 3-4 games. They have hit bad form, that's it.
Sakamoto has looked good, as has Lats.
Simms is starting to pick up.
Kitching and Collins haven't played

Crazy. This post is far too balanced.

 

[Grendel]

Crazy. This post is far too balanced.

It’s drivel and from the poster who described palmer saying world class I think and who said he took a corner against Middlesbrough

 

[Deleted member 9744]

They have in reality created very little yet have they?

Van Ewijk has scored as many goals in 6 appearances as Bidwell has in 64. Bidwell's was a freak goal too.

Dasilva has created chances and got at least ond assist but Godden apart we haven't been clinical up front.

 

[Deleted member 9744]

Palmer was a terrible signing

As you keep saying yet you consistently defended Kane and Waghorn.

Still waiting to hear why it's unfair to criticise Ayari as a young loan yet was fine for Norton-Cuffy and Wilson-Esbrand.

 

[Grendel]

Van Ewijk has scored as many goals in 6 appearances as Bidwell has in 64. Bidwell's was a freak goal too.

Dasilva has created chances and got at least ond assist but Godden apart we haven't been clinical up front.

They have created very little - thanks for confirming - a goal from a free kick (which is nothing to do with being a wing back) and one assist

 

[Grendel]

As you keep saying yet you consistently defended Kane and Waghorn.

Still waiting to hear why it's unfair to criticise Ayari as a young loan yet was fine for Norton-Cuffy and Wilson-Esbrand.

Cuffey was a championship regular before signing Esbrand was a pointless signing as he wasn’t ever hardky used

 

[Deleted member 9744]

They have created very little - thanks for confirming - a goal from a free kick (which is nothing to do with being a wing back) and one assist

Van Ewijk has scored one goal in 4 starts which if repeated across a whole season would be a phenomenal strike rate for a wing back. Certainly better than Bidwell's one in 64 appearances.

 

[Deleted member 9744]

Cuffey was a championship regular before signing Esbrand was a pointless signing as he wasn’t ever hardky used

Ayari is a 19 year old full international who has played in the Premier League. Norton-Cuffy was 18 I believe. Wilson-Esbrand had had less experience than Ayari has had prior to joining us.

So still no explanation why you feel it's unfair to criticise Ayari as he is a young loan player but it was ok to repeatedly criticise Norton-Cuffy and Wilson-Esbrand.

 

[shmmeee]

4 starts is hardly a significant sample size.

David Nugent has a 100% scoring record for England but there isn't likely to be a statue outside Wembley for him any time soon.

Bidwell might not carry the attacking threat of Dasilva - although on last seasons stats alone that could be argued - but at least he can defend.

Sent from my SM-G990B using Tapatalk

Can he though? I’d have agreed over the summer, he’s not shown it in his cameos so far though.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Can he though? I’d have agreed over the summer, he’s not shown it in his cameos so far though.

I'm here for the conspiracy that he's not feeling the love and wanted out so has kind of downed tools a little bit.

 

[Boicey]

At the minute we seem weaker everywhere on the pitch compared to last season.
So, early days, but I wouldn't call any of the new signings 'Excellent'. Even 'Good' is probably slightly pushing it too far.

 

[usskyblue]

Ayari has shown some nice touches in previous games but he looked completely lost vs Huddersfield.

 

[Bugsy]

At the minute we seem weaker everywhere on the pitch compared to last season.
So, early days, but I wouldn't call any of the new signings 'Excellent'. Even 'Good' is probably slightly pushing it too far.

That's not true is it, wing back position is alot better than last season, obviously with Milan on the right side

 

[clint van damme]

Ayari has shown some nice touches in previous games but he looked completely lost vs Huddersfield.

There's a player in there but he looks mils off at the moment.
Though he has joined the growing list of players who've s ores for us using there cock and balls.

Perhaps we should starts scouting on pornhub?

 

[Grendel]

Van Ewijk has scored one goal in 4 starts which if repeated across a whole season would be a phenomenal strike rate for a wing back. Certainly better than Bidwell's one in 64 appearances.

It’s a free kick - Ray Stewart scored 70 goals in 400 games as a full back

 

[Boicey]

That's not true is it, wing back position is alot better than last season, obviously with Milan on the right side

I remain to be convinced. Ok but not really improved us at the back or front noticeably. Tbf probably the best of the bunch

 

[shmmeee]

I remain to be convinced. Ok but not really improved us at the back or front noticeably. Tbf probably the best of the bunch

I think Fadz has deteriorated and we’ve lost end of season Callum Doyle. But I’d argue this time last season we didn’t have end of season Callum Doyle, we had what appeared to be Bambi on ice. I think Binks has started stronger than Panzo or Doyle did. Latibeaudiere I’ve been impressed with, and think he’s more consistent than McNally at least. Hopefully Kitching can come in for Fadz for a complete upgrade.

We really needed to buy a couple of CMs and a serious GK, that’s where we’re lacking IMO.

 

[clint van damme]

I think Fadz has deteriorated and we’ve lost end of season Callum Doyle. But I’d argue this time last season we didn’t have end of season Callum Doyle, we had what appeared to be Bambi on ice. I think Binks has started stronger than Panzo or Doyle did. Latibeaudiere I’ve been impressed with, and think he’s more consistent than McNally at least. Hopefully Kitching can come in for Fadz for a complete upgrade.

We really needed to buy a couple of CMs and a serious GK, that’s where we’re lacking IMO.

The only thing I'd add is that Fadz didn't start last season too well, but at his age the drop off will be permanent sooner or later.

 

[fernandopartridge]

The only thing I'd add is that Fadz didn't start last season too well, but at his age the drop off will be permanent sooner or later.

He was good in the first few games but hasn't quite looked at it since Watford

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[Matt smith]

He can rebuild us.

Can he indeed

 

[Alan Dugdales Moustache]

He can rebuild us.

He has the technology. He can make us better than before. Better......stronger.....faster.

 

[wingy]

He has the technology. He can make us better than before. Better......stronger.....faster.

Kanye lyric?