Swansea Ratings (10 Viewers)

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Collins 6
Lati 6
Thomas 6
Binks 6
DaSilva 4
Sheaf 6
Allen 6
Palmer 6
Saka 7
Wright 8 MOTM
Godden 6

Subs
Simms 5
COH 6
MVE 6
 

steve101

Well-Known Member
Collins 5.5
Latibeudiere 6.5
Thomas 8
Binks 7
Da Silva 5
Sheaf 8
Allen 6
Palmer 8.5 motm
Sakamota 8.5
Godden 5
Wright 8

Van Ewijk 7
O'Hare 7
Simms 6
 

SeaSeeEffCee

Well-Known Member
Collins 6
Latibeaudiere 6
Thomas 7
Binks 6
Dasilva 5
Sheaf 7
Allen 5
Palmer 7
Sakamoto 8
Godden 5
Wright 8

Simms 5
Van Ewijk 6
O’Hare 7
 

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
Collins 5 - Has he caught a ball all season?

Lati 6 - Missed MVE.
Thomas 7
Binks 7
Da Silva 5 - Nowhere near as good as Bidwell defensively or going forward.
Sheaf 7.5 - Better
Allen 5 - Poor
Palmer 7.5
Saka 8 - literally involved in everything good. 3 outstanding crosses.
Haji 8 - Very, very good but could have done better with 1/2 of the opportunities in the second half.
Godden - Pointless. Literally.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Collins: 5
Latibeaudiere: 6
Thomas: 6
Binks: 6
Dasilva: 5
Sheaf: 6
Allen: 4
Palmer: 7
Wright: 8
Godden: 5
Sakamoto: 7

Simms: 6
MvE: 6
O’Hare: 6
 

long way home

Well-Known Member
Wright's best game
Tatsu 8.5
Rest 7.5

Desilva ok on the ball but teams are going to target him. I don't mind him with Bidwell behind him not being exposed like that.

Allen looked frustrated effected his game.
 

SBAndy

Well-Known Member
Collins - 5 - looked pretty weak the last few now. Can’t concede in that side of the goal from a free kick.

Latibeaudiere - 6 - ok, nowhere near the attacking outlet that MvE is. Looked a little better in centre mid.
Thomas - 7 - far more composed performance tonight. Silly header leading to the free kick.
Binks - 6 - alright, could tell he hadn’t played in a while.
Dasilva - 5 - got exploited a lot first half, not quite as much second half, but largely got away with it. If the back 4 is here to stay then I’d be looking to get rid already as that will become a theme.

Sheaf - 6 - fantastic at times, sloppy at times.
Allen - 4 - probably the poorest game I’ve seen him have in a couple of years. Really lacked composure.
Palmer - 7 - main creative outlet for the first 60 minutes, although he still doesn’t work back and that led to some defensive issues.

Sakamoto - 7 - good as ever, tired towards the end and I’d have subbed him off.
Godden - 4 - marginally better than Boxing Day. Marginally.
Wright - 7 - threatening for most of the game but still prone to a brain fart.

MvE - 7 - gave us far more attacking impetus, although bizarre free kick when he just booted it to the middle of the pitch.
O’Hare - 6 - not as influential tonight.
Simms - 5 - poor performance when he came on to be honest. Extra mark for the goal.
 

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
On the train back

Godden, Allen shouldn’t start. Allen should not be asked to play that role in midfield again.

Sheaf, Saka, Wright stand outs.

Palmer superb - can we play him in the same team with COH?

Defensively thought we did more than ok including JDS.

Swansea very lucky with the draw - we move on.
 

higgs

Well-Known Member
Da Silva and Godden and Allen really should be squad players at best they don't warrant a starting place we need to try replace them with more quality if not this window then in the summer

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk
 

Chris1987

Well-Known Member
Da Silva 3'
Wright & Thomas 8.5
Palmer 8
Sheaf anything from 6-8 depending on how you view the 2 crucial mistakes

Still , very good performance with key players rested / suspended.
Fully expect a good crack at the play off places
 

tommy hutch legend

Well-Known Member
On the train back

Godden, Allen shouldn’t start. Allen should not be asked to play that role in midfield again.

Sheaf, Saka, Wright stand outs.

Palmer superb - can we play him in the same team with COH?

Defensively thought we did more than ok including JDS.

Swansea very lucky with the draw - we move on.
Agree Allen works hard but loses the ball to easily when challenged. Like Godden, but non existent in our current style of play
 

Chris1987

Well-Known Member
Da Silva 3'
Wright & Thomas 8.5
Palmer 8
Sheaf anything from 6-8 depending on how you view the 2 crucial mistakes

Still , very good performance with key players rested / suspended.
Fully expect a good crack at the play off places
Additionally Godden 3. Shouldn't start a game and only be used asa last resort now
 

Blind-Faith

Well-Known Member
Collins 4 - second goal his fault, you don’t get beat in that corner from a free kick, handling is frightening
Lati 7
Thomas 8
Binks 7
DaSilva 5
Sheaf 8.5 MOTM
Allen 5
Palmer 8 - changed his rating from a 7, probabaly the best I’ve seen him play
Saka 7
Wright 6 - from the sublime to the utter embarrassing all in 90 minutes, I can’t mark him so just gets a 6
Godden 6

Subs
Simms 6
COH 6.5
MVE 6.5

The central striker role Simms/Godden play, I’m starting to think is a bit of a thankless task. All the good stuff happens in the wide areas from Wright or Sakamoto , neither of them are getting a sniff really at anything. Even Simms goal tonight he has had to basically rob from Wright.
 
Last edited:

Deity

Well-Known Member
Godden … anonymous
Allen …careless
Da Silva…. exposed

Tats, Palmer, Wright and Thomas all performed well.

Matt Grimes would slot into our midfield perfectly !
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
Collins 4 - second goal his fault, you don’t get beat in that corner from a free kick, handling is frightening
Lati 7
Thomas 8
Binks 7
DaSilva 5
Sheaf 8.5 MOTM
Allen 5
Palmer 7
Saka 7
Wright 6 - from the sublime to the utter embarrassing all in 90 minutes, I can’t mark him so just gets a 6
Godden 6

Subs
Simms 6
COH 6.5
MVE 6.5

The central striker role Simms/Godden play, I’m starting to think is a bit of a thankless task. All the good stuff happens in the wide areas from Wright or Sakamoto , neither of them are getting a sniff really at anything. Even Simms goal tonight he has had to basically rob from Wright.
Sheaf 8.5 and MOTM. Did You watch the match?
 

SeaSeeEffCee

Well-Known Member
People were praising Collins handling a couple of weeks ago and now one person has said it’s dodgy and everyone is piling in saying the same 😂
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
On the train back

Godden, Allen shouldn’t start. Allen should not be asked to play that role in midfield again.

Sheaf, Saka, Wright stand outs.

Palmer superb - can we play him in the same team with COH?

Defensively thought we did more than ok including JDS.

Swansea very lucky with the draw - we move on.

Agree with that apart from the comment on JDS, thought he was poor, though as others have said, not culpable for either goal .
 

MalcSB

Well-Known Member
I was there, the amount of times he wins the ball back and gets tackles in, he’s had a great game. Doesn’t hide away, always showing for the ball and keeps us ticking over.

The ball over the top of their left back for Saka in the second half was absolutely top class.
Yes, that was a great ball. But not MOTM.
 

Terry_dactyl

Well-Known Member
Collins 5.5
Latibeudiere 6.5
Thomas 8
Binks 7
Da Silva 5
Sheaf 8
Allen 6
Palmer 8.5 motm
Sakamota 8.5
Godden 5
Wright 8

Van Ewijk 7
O'Hare 7
Simms 6
These are the scores.

Dasilva is technically good but they targeted him today. Had some very good moments…but unfortunately its just not enough.
If he was taller he’d probably be awesome.

But he’s not.
 

Sky Blue Pete

Well-Known Member
Collins 5 - Has he caught a ball all season?

Lati 6 - Missed MVE.
Thomas 7
Binks 7
Da Silva 5 - Nowhere near as good as Bidwell defensively or going forward.
Sheaf 7.5 - Better
Allen 5 - Poor
Palmer 7.5
Saka 8 - literally involved in everything good. 3 outstanding crosses.
Haji 8 - Very, very good but could have done better with 1/2 of the opportunities in the second half.
Godden - Pointless. Literally.
Yep caught one tonight from a corner
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top