Player Ratings v Huddersfield (8 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Collins 6 (far too casual, even before he gave them a goal. Partly redeemed himself with some decent saves)
Latibeudiere 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 7
Bidwell 7
Eccles 7
Sheaf 7.5
Palmer 8
Van Ewijk 8
Simms 8 motm
Wright 6 (looked knackered after an hour but fair play, another last minute finish)
O'Hare 5 (doesn't want to tackle)
Godden 5
Torp 5 (looked severely off the pace)
Kelly na
Ref was abysmal
Robins should have made changes earlier, however the subs really didn't make an impact
Latibeudiere 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 7
Bidwell 7
Eccles 7
Sheaf 7.5
Palmer 8
Van Ewijk 8
Simms 8 motm
Wright 6 (looked knackered after an hour but fair play, another last minute finish)
O'Hare 5 (doesn't want to tackle)
Godden 5
Torp 5 (looked severely off the pace)
Kelly na
Ref was abysmal
Robins should have made changes earlier, however the subs really didn't make an impact
Warwickhunt
Well-Known Member
Bidwell brilliant performance nothing got past him!
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Collins 5
Lati 6
Thomas 7
Kitching 6
Bidwell 8
Eccles 7
Sheaf 7
MVE 7
Palmer 7
Wright 7
Simms 9 MOTM
Subs
Godden N/A
Kelly N/A
COH 6
Torp 6
Lati 6
Thomas 7
Kitching 6
Bidwell 8
Eccles 7
Sheaf 7
MVE 7
Palmer 7
Wright 7
Simms 9 MOTM
Subs
Godden N/A
Kelly N/A
COH 6
Torp 6
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Collins 6
Lati 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 7
Bidwell 8
Eccles 7
Sheaf 8
MVE 7
Palmer 8
Wright 7
Simms 9 motm
Lati 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 7
Bidwell 8
Eccles 7
Sheaf 8
MVE 7
Palmer 8
Wright 7
Simms 9 motm
Terry_dactyl
Well-Known Member
The Huddersfield commentators suggested Bidwell was a good candidate for our motm.
And they’re not wrong. Superb defender. Still yet to see a left back in this league I’d take over him. Need him next year.
ProfessorbyGrace
Well-Known Member
Simms first goal couldn’t have been more top bins, quite frankly. The strike of a player full of confidence. 
On the highlights, I’m sure I saw Collins get a hand on Rudoni’s shot that hit the crossbar.
On the highlights, I’m sure I saw Collins get a hand on Rudoni’s shot that hit the crossbar.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
I thought Wright played well and Palmer had a big part in both Simms goals Thomas and Bidwell were decent too.
ProfessorbyGrace
Well-Known Member
Very good.Simmense
larry_david
Well-Known Member
Never stopped, tricky player, good set pieces, tall.
Argue one weakness is he's not rapid but I'd happily have him in our squad
Tried to make things happen in a shit team. Nothing in front of him. Put him in our attacking lineup and he’d be 10x the player.
Danceswithhorses
Well-Known Member
The hudds commentators were really quite disparaging of him at the start of the game.
Might be super inconsistent ?
A lot of their fans don’t rate him. He looks skilful but maybe he’s all fart and no poo. I’ve not seen enough of him though to judge
My reaction is not to your opinion, but more for that brilliant analogy of being ‘all fart and no poo’. I’ve never heard that one!!
Agreed. Made some good stops. Just got complacent in that moment. He’ll learn.
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Sadly Callum’s head is in the prem. He could spend next season like Gus, watching us on t.v. thinking “that could have been me”
Hobo
Well-Known Member
More likely that they feel there should be more end product? But sometimes that might be down to the players around him?
Maybe, haven't seen much of him but if that's him playing shit...
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Time to start serious contract talks with Bidwell.
It's a shame, I think he still needs another season but it's his call at the end of the day.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He actually has another season left - Robins is very stubborn but is going to have to accept he made a big error of judgement in Dasilva
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Fucking Palmer. Only does it against lower league teams, championship teams and prem teams!
Never seen him do it on European stage. Flat track nearly man bully!
Never seen him do it on European stage. Flat track nearly man bully!
Largely agree with these.
First half was a pleasure, 2nd comfortable until Collins abomination…
All subs looked well off it.
Overall, a great 3 points.
mmttww
Well-Known Member
mmttww
Well-Known Member
or he'll improve Da Silva like he has with Bidwell, who is much better this season. If MR and AV can get Bidwell, Godden, Fadz, et al. to improve later in their careers, they can knock JDS into shape.
And Palmer, looks a much better all round player than when he joined.