Referee (18 Viewers)

[Mcbean]

What’s the penalty area got to do with it? If it’s serious foul play (or whatever it’s called now) it’s a red card wherever it is.

I thought VAR only looked at incidents in the penalty area

 

---

[Nuskyblue]

OK. I didn’t remember the VAR check. Not even sure how the rule is worded these days

Excessive force, endangering and opponent, and I think something else.

I can only assume that the VAR thought it was wreckless (a yellow card offence) and left it...

 

[skybluecam]

The art of refereeing is being lost. The #1 job of a ref is to control the game. All referees will make mistakes but good ones are able to assert themselves and keep players in line. They're being undermined by VAR, pundits and players/managers and is only getting worse.

The main issue with the ref yesterday was that he looked lost out there. Maybe the early yellow for Kitching was an attempt to assert himself, but it was a strange and poor decision, and from then on he had lost many of the players.

 

[SBbucks]

I thought VAR only looked at incidents in the penalty area

No, it can be used anywhere.

 

[SBbucks]

OK. I didn’t remember the VAR check. Not even sure how the rule is worded these days

They didn’t stop play for it, so in the ground we weren’t aware of it. Mentioned on the TV commentary though.

 

[Nick]

Loads of shocking decisions in the Premier League yesterday, it's ruining the game.

 

[Nick]

Another shocker.

Simms fouled over and over but if he breaths it's a foul.

That one with their player holding was embarrassing.

 

[pusbccfc]

He was so so bad. Some of the 50/50s were laughable.

 

[David O'Day]

As I have said if we had ref from 10 Mike's from cov they'd kick off

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Thought he was ok till last 10 the mve foul just before the eccles foul was cheating

 

[letsallsingtogether]

That display was embarrassing so one sided for all to see he should be sacked.

 

[pusbccfc]

Long way back home on a loss Tom

 

[play_in_skyblue_stripes]

Thought he was ok till last 10 the mve foul just before the eccles foul was cheating

I disagree, he was biased the whole game.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

I disagree, he was biased the whole game.

Talk me through the biased decisions

 

[Nuskyblue]

Talk me through the biased decisions

Let's be fair, anything marginal went their way.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Let's be fair, anything marginal went their way.

Seriously, bias! talk to me, tell me what decisions were biased
The mve one before eccles thought sod it im going through this guy was shocking and looked like cheating but which others

 

[Nuskyblue]

Seriously, bias! talk to me, tell me what decisions were biased
The mve one before eccles thought sod it im going through this guy was shocking and looked like cheating but which others

Just a vibe, seemed to go the other way if they could.... All subjective of course.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Seriously, bias! talk to me, tell me what decisions were biased
The mve one before eccles thought sod it im going through this guy was shocking and looked like cheating but which others

Simms being held by both arms of a player, almost being wrestled, no foul given even though the ref was almost next to it.

 

[Nuskyblue]

Seriously, bias! talk to me, tell me what decisions were biased
The mve one before eccles thought sod it im going through this guy was shocking and looked like cheating but which others

The bookings annoyed me .

 

[Nuskyblue]

Simms being held by both arms of a player, almost being wrestled, no foul given

No foul.

Not Leeds.

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

The bookings annoyed me .

Sheaf was persistence, Bidwell one annoyed me
Simms yc was bollox

 

[shmmeee]

Sheaf was persistence, Bidwell one annoyed me
Simms yc was bollox

Persistence is only a yellow if it’s persistent fouling. He spent the whole game desperate to give them something and got the cards out for the most ridiculous stuff.

Couldn’t get his whistle in his mouth quick enough at the end when he realised we were through on an open goal either.

He shouldn’t be allowed near Leeds games. The most bias refs performance I’ve seen and he’s from fucking Wakefield.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Persistence is only a yellow if it’s persistent fouling. He spent the whole game desperate to give them something and got the cards out for the most ridiculous stuff.

Couldn’t get his whistle in his mouth quick enough at the end when he realised we were through on an open goal either.

He shouldn’t be allowed near Leeds games. The most bias refs performance I’ve seen and he’s from fucking Wakefield.

He’s basically from Leeds, as close as you can get. And it showed, though I was sure he’d disallow the first goal or add on 90 minutes at the end

 

[shmmeee]

He’s basically from Leeds, as close as you can get. And it showed, though I was sure he’d disallow the first goal or add on 90 minutes at the end

First time ive shouted cheat at someone in a long long time but it was just so obvious.

 

[lordy_87]

Connor Roberts too..... Diving rat should of been booked twice. Once for the dive feigning a facial injury, and again for that moustache.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

First time ive shouted cheat at someone in a long long time but it was just so obvious.

Madness to assign him to a fixture of this much importance to a club he probably supports. He’s never had them before from what I can see, so why now?

 

[David O'Day]

Long way back home on a loss Tom

View attachment 34985

They might not let him back on the team bus.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

 

[David O'Day]

Seriously, bias! talk to me, tell me what decisions were biased
The mve one before eccles thought sod it im going through this guy was shocking and looked like cheating but which others

He is ref from near Leeds who gave them everything. If we had a ref from Leamington who gave us the decisions he gave them, then they would be rightly annoyed.

Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk

 

[SBT]

Ref pissed me off no end today, but to suggest he’s a closet Leeds fan is just silly

 

[Mcbean]

The bookings and foul giving just seemed one sided - Leeds players went down like Brum prozzy and came out with free kick just about each time

 

[Mild-Mannered Janitor]

Ok until last 10 mins and then he remembered he was a Leeds fan and gave them every 50:50 and some fouls on us not given, he was waiting to give them a penalty in injury time, we just kept them out.

 

[Frostie]

Thought he started well, happy to let a lot go in terms of physicality both ways but then got steadily worse throughout with some utterly baffling decisions &, as others have said, the final 10-15mins or so were incomprehensible.

Simms was manhandled constantly & the decisions were given against him 9/10 times.

No issues with the yellows as such, all obvious bookings. The issue for me was the Eccles one was a clear foul on MVE first which he totally ignored. Also, no issue with him booking Simms & Ampadu for the spat but Simms held onto him as retaliation for being basically bearhugged, ref waved the incident away then subsequently gave them the free-kick ‍

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Thought he started well, happy to let a lot go in terms of physicality both ways but then got steadily worse throughout with some utterly baffling decisions &, as others have said, the final 10-15mins or so were incomprehensible.

Simms was manhandled constantly & the decisions were given against him 9/10 times.

No issues with the yellows as such, all obvious bookings. The issue for me was the Eccles one was a clear foul on MVE first which he totally ignored. Also, no issue with him booking Simms & Ampadu for the spat but Simms held onto him as retaliation for being basically bearhugged, ref waved the incident away then subsequently gave them the free-kick ‍

How I saw it too

 

[Chris1987]

Guilty of nothing more than a few bad decisions imo.

 

[OldBedrocker]

Don’t think he’d given Simms a free kick if they had pulled a gun out and shot him.