New Offside rules? (3 Viewers)

[Alkhen]

Dunno if this is true but would just be our luck to be shafted by 12 months!

 

---

[Hobo]

View attachment 35621


Dunno if this is true but would just be our luck to be shafted by 12 months!

Approved trials so it will probably only be done in something like Dutch Division 3

 

[COVKIDSNEVERQUIT]

View attachment 35621


Dunno if this is true but would just be our luck to be shafted by 12 months!

I've been saying that for years, it should be that way , people pay to see goals, makes it easier for the linesman.

 

[shepardo01]

After so long as it has been, how difficult will it be for officials to adjust to this!?
Prem fine - they will have the new - far more accurate - automated offsides.

Lower down.....??

 

[skybluegod]

I've been saying that for years, it should be that way , people pay to see goals, makes it easier for the linesman.

How does it make it easier for linesman? This is going to be far harder judge and adds a whole new level of subjectivity when we don't have technology in the lower leagues.

 

[fatso]

It's a simple rule, big teams not offside, little teams offside.

 

[Alkhen]

What I like about this interpretation is that it's a clear advantage for the attacker at that point. I know there still be marginal calls but at least the attacker will be in a position of advantage. I just think it will be easier to stomach

 

[Paul Anthony]

I'm not sure it totally solves the whole forensic level of examination of if a person's toe nail is in line or not, it just shifts the definition around a bit.

 

[COVKIDSNEVERQUIT]

How does it make it easier for linesman? This is going to be far harder judge and adds a whole new level of subjectivity when we don't have technology in the lower leagues.

Okay, so a lineman can judge if a player is level, but not if the player is ahead of the defender.

 

[skybluegod]

Okay, so a lineman can judge if a player is level, but not if the player is ahead of the defender.

It's much easier to judge a level decision than an unclear daylight rule. With the current rule he is either ahead or not. With this a lino has to judge at speed on the move how much of the body is ahead. Far more subjective like I said. This was cause far more issues lower down. It will work well with automated offsides and VAR.

 

[skybluecam]

Don’t like this personally because it gives the attacker an effective head start and will likely lead to teams sitting deeper.

 

[Nick]

They will fuck it up and be inconsistent either way.

 

[speedie87]

Offside should just be based off torso, so not including legs/ head

 

[hill83]

Get one of the subs to run the line. Offside every time

 

[Johhny Blue]

It’s going to be retroactive to Jan 1st

 

[Briles]

didn't this used to be the rule?

 

[clint van damme]

Another rule change bought about because VAR isn't fit for purpose.
Pathetic.

 

[You'll Never Beat McPake]

Time to just dump the offside rule altogether. Would save a lot of time and after match forensic exercises

 

[Skyblue Bangkok]

I

Time to just dump the offside rule altogether. Would save a lot of time and after match forensic exercises

If you dumped offside altogether you'd just have hoofball and about 20 players goal hanging , no thanks .

 

[clint van damme]

Time to just dump the offside rule altogether. Would save a lot of time and after match forensic exercises

Once heard a Villa fan on a phone in suggest that if a player gets caught offside the attacking team should get the free kick!
Different breed!

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Time to just dump the offside rule altogether. Would save a lot of time and after match forensic exercises

Don't have it in hockey and the game works just fine

 

[JAM See]

Time to just dump the offside rule altogether. Would save a lot of time and after match forensic exercises

Radical!
I would love to see a trial fixture with no offside rule.

It would certainly spread the game and leave more space for players all over the pitch.

 

[Johhny Blue]

Don't have it in hockey and the game works just fine

There is offside in hockey. It’s based on puck position

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

There is offside in hockey. It’s based on puck position

I meant field hockey