Luton player ratings (4 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Dovin 7
Mve 7
Lati 7
Thomas 7
Binks 7
Kitching 5
Sheaf 8
Eccles 6
Wright 8 MOTM - someone get him angry before every game
Saka 6
Simms 7
Rudoni 7
Torp 8
Mve 7
Lati 7
Thomas 7
Binks 7
Kitching 5
Sheaf 8
Eccles 6
Wright 8 MOTM - someone get him angry before every game
Saka 6
Simms 7
Rudoni 7
Torp 8
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Dovin 6
MVE 6
Thomas 5
Binks 5
Lati 6
Kitching 5
Sheaf 7
Eccles 6
Sakamoto 5
Simms 8
Wright 7
torp 8
Rudoni 8
MVE 6
Thomas 5
Binks 5
Lati 6
Kitching 5
Sheaf 7
Eccles 6
Sakamoto 5
Simms 8
Wright 7
torp 8
Rudoni 8
Dovin 7 - crucial save at 2-2
MVE 6
Thomas 6
Latibeaudiere 6 - good defensively, but nervous on the ball
Binks 5 - Toilet
Kitching 5 - did not really know/follow what he should be doing; he is a defender
Sheaf 6 - cannot shoot
Eccles 5 - looks tired
Sakamoto 5 - struggled
Wright 8 - aggression and bullied the defence
Simms 7 - best this season, looked up for it
Rudoni 7
Torp 7
MVE 6
Thomas 6
Latibeaudiere 6 - good defensively, but nervous on the ball
Binks 5 - Toilet
Kitching 5 - did not really know/follow what he should be doing; he is a defender
Sheaf 6 - cannot shoot
Eccles 5 - looks tired
Sakamoto 5 - struggled
Wright 8 - aggression and bullied the defence
Simms 7 - best this season, looked up for it
Rudoni 7
Torp 7
rob9872
Well-Known Member
You honestly think Thomas and Binks as bad as Kitching? And I thiught MVE challenged for motm. Strange how some see it. Think @Blind-Faith has it much closer.
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
The defence was a shambles the entire game.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Everyone did well bar Eccles really. Not that he was horrendous. Kithcing not really in a ideal position tbf to him
no_loyalty
Well-Known Member
Binks was excellent second half.
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
Dovin 7
MVE 6
Lati 6
Thomas 6
Binks 7
Kitching 5
Sheaf 6
Eccles 6
Sakamoto 6
Wright 7
Simms 7
Rudoni 7
Torp 7
MVE 6
Lati 6
Thomas 6
Binks 7
Kitching 5
Sheaf 6
Eccles 6
Sakamoto 6
Wright 7
Simms 7
Rudoni 7
Torp 7
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Dovin 7
Lati 8 thought he was really good getting tight and aggressive with their forwards
Thomas 7
Binks 7 point off for their goal but to be fair he did well driving forward second half
MVE 8 constant outlet
Kitching 6 obviously not his position, didn't do anything especially wrong just didn't look right
Sheaf 8 showed great leadership
Eccles 7 worked tirelessly
Sakamoto 6 helped to open up angles and kept the ball moving
Wright 8 constant threat
Simms 8 great running the channels and everything we need
Subs
Rudoni 9, he was excellent and showed his quality, is this one of those accidental moments that turns a season?
Torp 8 great goal and one great first time ball, worry about his physicality but he's a good footballer
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Lati 8 thought he was really good getting tight and aggressive with their forwards
Thomas 7
Binks 7 point off for their goal but to be fair he did well driving forward second half
MVE 8 constant outlet
Kitching 6 obviously not his position, didn't do anything especially wrong just didn't look right
Sheaf 8 showed great leadership
Eccles 7 worked tirelessly
Sakamoto 6 helped to open up angles and kept the ball moving
Wright 8 constant threat
Simms 8 great running the channels and everything we need
Subs
Rudoni 9, he was excellent and showed his quality, is this one of those accidental moments that turns a season?
Torp 8 great goal and one great first time ball, worry about his physicality but he's a good footballer
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Skybluecol
Well-Known Member
Binks 5??
You really are clueless
Ah here we go, you likely rate him 8/10 because he charges up the pitch, just like he did against QPR to charge in on the half way line, and left a huge gap which was then exploited for their goal
He is a fucking defender who cannot defend!! Lost his man for their second goal.
But he is the golden boy so seemingly cannot be criticised. ONE clean sheet in the whole of the time he has been here since last August, is it 23 league matches now?
My view of his, and the whole of the defence’s, performance is not clouded by the final score. Defence was bad all game, only improving slightly, ironically, when a midfielder came into the back line
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
Still more work needed with the defence but Binks stood up well second half and I thought Lati was good all game , he loves a tackle doesn't he?
Been calling for Torp to play 10 for a while and he made a huge difference with his movement and interplay.
Wright and Simms were a handful all game against a physical backline .
Sheaf rightly MotM , getting back to his very best with every game
PUSB
Been calling for Torp to play 10 for a while and he made a huge difference with his movement and interplay.
Wright and Simms were a handful all game against a physical backline .
Sheaf rightly MotM , getting back to his very best with every game
PUSB
Otis
Well-Known Member
Binks was fabulous going forward in the second half. Obviously not as strong in terms of defensive duties.
Skybluecol
Well-Known Member
No not at 8.....but defo not 5
I had him as a 7....2nd half a lot of our outlet was down to him driving us up the pitch by 20 yards each time and giving Rudoni an easy half as he never had to drop deep to defend. Binks also won plenty in the air too.
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
Dovin 7 - Good saves in the second half to keep us in it
Lati 8 - Showed good leadership and was strong throughout
Thomas 7 - Decent enough
Binks 7.5 - Think he was actually really good today
MVE 7.5 - Much better than versus QPR
Kitching 6.5 - Hard to mark due to his strange position on the pitch, did alright I think...
Sheaf 7 Generally solid, did some things very well, but cannot shoot
Eccles 7 worked very hard. Not everything came off either. Went unnoticed, but his ball out when we should have got the 4th was class
Sakamoto 6.5 - Drop half a point for the penalty giveaway. Hopefully will click for him soon as he is a great player. Saw a bit in flashes today
Wright 8.5 - MOTM. A terror for the opposition the whole game
Simms 8 - Best game in ages. Great goal as well
Subs
Rudoni & Torp 8 - Both were the difference for me when they came on. Torp is really trying to make a point at the moment. That finish is something we needed badly. Never going to happen but would play both of them in midfield next game with Eccles.
Overall this game was fucking massive. To come back in the way we did might just be the kick up the arse we need to move on this season. Absolutely delighted this afternoon with that! Quite proud actually as I think we really worked for it and therefore deserved it.
Lati 8 - Showed good leadership and was strong throughout
Thomas 7 - Decent enough
Binks 7.5 - Think he was actually really good today
MVE 7.5 - Much better than versus QPR
Kitching 6.5 - Hard to mark due to his strange position on the pitch, did alright I think...
Sheaf 7 Generally solid, did some things very well, but cannot shoot
Eccles 7 worked very hard. Not everything came off either. Went unnoticed, but his ball out when we should have got the 4th was class
Sakamoto 6.5 - Drop half a point for the penalty giveaway. Hopefully will click for him soon as he is a great player. Saw a bit in flashes today
Wright 8.5 - MOTM. A terror for the opposition the whole game
Simms 8 - Best game in ages. Great goal as well
Subs
Rudoni & Torp 8 - Both were the difference for me when they came on. Torp is really trying to make a point at the moment. That finish is something we needed badly. Never going to happen but would play both of them in midfield next game with Eccles.
Overall this game was fucking massive. To come back in the way we did might just be the kick up the arse we need to move on this season. Absolutely delighted this afternoon with that! Quite proud actually as I think we really worked for it and therefore deserved it.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Sheaf a 6 says he is
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Much better distribution from Dovin today even if we are still playing with fire at the back.
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
Course I’m not we won
4 CBs was still mad though, Kitching was never going to work out wide.
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
I’d go 7’s except:
Binks : 5. Defensive liability
Sheaf : 8 Quality
Wright : 8 Real handful
Rudoni : 8 Impact.
Binks : 5. Defensive liability
Sheaf : 8 Quality
Wright : 8 Real handful
Rudoni : 8 Impact.
SkyBlue_Bear83
Well-Known Member
Rudoni has a decent final ball/delivery on him which we've seen from the start of the season. We got to utilise it today but not sure it's a long term solution/position for him.
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
Think his distribution has been good last few games
False9
Well-Known Member
Good point on Rudoni, it looks like it doesn't it. Gives us attacking wing backs and another player who's comfortable in possession whilst allowing Torp in the 10 role.
2024/25 League 1 Champs?
Well-Known Member
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
I know everyone's opinions differ but you thought Lati was the worst of our back 3 today?
I thought he was the only one who showed up defensively all game
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
He was also more vocal. More than once I saw him demanding more from the midfield in needing to give him options moving out of the press.
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
I think for all the criticism he gets on here he's been one of our better players this season . He isn't blessed with loads of natural ability but he's combative and plays with passion and ,like you said, he leads well on the pitch
Time for some to cut him some slack
stupot07
Well-Known Member
It was mainly because I felt he was a bit too ponderous on the ball at times. He was out of position for the penalty leaving a massive gap; and then he came miles out to press for the second, and that left the hole for the through ball to be slid into. We're only talking 0.5 of a point difference, it's not like I've given him a 4 or something.
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
The first goal was a combination of MvE and Lati getting in each others way . To blame him for the second is a bit of a stretch to be honest , Binks didn't track his man .
I do agree he isn't comfortable in possession at times though
olderskyblue
Well-Known Member
Ditto these scores