Cardiff player ratings (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
2 goals shipped again. Not sure how that changes til January.
Didn't think Sheaf went hiding but agree with the rest
no_loyalty
Well-Known Member
MVE was dreadful, what has happened to him?
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
Can only guess he's shithousing a move back home
Nick
Administrator
3rd division?
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Defence = hapless
Midfield = average
Forwards = busy but ineffective
We need some aggression and old fashioned nous.
Midfield = average
Forwards = busy but ineffective
We need some aggression and old fashioned nous.
mrfr
Well-Known Member
MvE’s worst game in a Cov shirt. Overall it was pretty dire, but I’m not sure any of it is terminal so much as a lack of confidence and in turn fluidity.
Bassette offered very little and should now be dropped for Simms but there is no point doing that unless Frank can get some confidence into him because without it there is no player who’s drop off is more extreme than his.
Bassette offered very little and should now be dropped for Simms but there is no point doing that unless Frank can get some confidence into him because without it there is no player who’s drop off is more extreme than his.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
To be fair simms won the penalty and Asante Thomas actually offered a bit of threat
SKYBLUES90
Well-Known Member
Sheaf!?
What has happened, looks a totally different player compared to last season. Just going through the motions, offers absolutely nothing going forward and the tempo is so below what you would expect for the captain. Sets the tone for everyone else.
Touted as a premier league pick up the end of last year, be lucky to get a Lower half championship move if he continues like this.
What has happened, looks a totally different player compared to last season. Just going through the motions, offers absolutely nothing going forward and the tempo is so below what you would expect for the captain. Sets the tone for everyone else.
Touted as a premier league pick up the end of last year, be lucky to get a Lower half championship move if he continues like this.
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
I don’t know how Dasilva is still in the team he is absolutely crap , it’s like watching a school boy being bullied every game , get rid in January Frank
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
I honestly don't think he looks considerably worse. He's always had the same limitations. I think it has just taken some people a while to notice.
Probably makes sense given that we've had a prolonged period of playing shit. When you are winning games these things aren't noticed as much, and people care less.
fatso
Well-Known Member
I've said it before and I'll say it again till I'm sky blue in the face, Binks and Dasilva = 2 Goals conceded every game.
Neither are Championship quality, and the same can be said for all 3 keepers, Dovin may well improve, but Collins and Wilson need moving on.
On today's performance, Eccles Sheaf and MVE were well below their best, in fact Sheaf has been a shadow of his former self since coming back from injury.
We got a lucky point today due to playing one of the few teams in this league that are actually worse than we are.
I only hope that FL has had a wake up call.
Neither are Championship quality, and the same can be said for all 3 keepers, Dovin may well improve, but Collins and Wilson need moving on.
On today's performance, Eccles Sheaf and MVE were well below their best, in fact Sheaf has been a shadow of his former self since coming back from injury.
We got a lucky point today due to playing one of the few teams in this league that are actually worse than we are.
I only hope that FL has had a wake up call.
Collins 5 (when you want a brick wall you get paper)
Van Erwijk 4 (starting to wonder if pace is his only asset)
Thomas 5 (passing woeful)
Binks 6 (part of a shaky defence but at least he is willing to drive forward with the ball)
DaSilva 6 (retained the ball better than most but is always going to be a weakness with his lack of height and pace)
Eccles 4 (worse game of the season. Was giving players acres of space at times. Was he intimidated by playing for Lampard. Looked like it)
Sheaf 7 motm (one of the only players that look like they can take a ball without panicking)
Rudoni 7 (thought he was excellent first half with his movement and link play but not involved enough second)
Sakamoto 6 (vision and technique for the assist was excellent but faded second half)
Bassette 5 (good movement and endeavour but two good chances with his head squandered)
Mason-Clark 6.5 (nice run and finish for the goal and put in some decent crosses)
Torp 7 (decent penalty under pressure and certainty more progressive than most)
Simms 6 (although the outcome may have been different, I would have liked him to have stepped forward for the pen. Workrate off the ball was better)
Thomas-Asante 6 (looked sharp and gave good energy)
Van Erwijk 4 (starting to wonder if pace is his only asset)
Thomas 5 (passing woeful)
Binks 6 (part of a shaky defence but at least he is willing to drive forward with the ball)
DaSilva 6 (retained the ball better than most but is always going to be a weakness with his lack of height and pace)
Eccles 4 (worse game of the season. Was giving players acres of space at times. Was he intimidated by playing for Lampard. Looked like it)
Sheaf 7 motm (one of the only players that look like they can take a ball without panicking)
Rudoni 7 (thought he was excellent first half with his movement and link play but not involved enough second)
Sakamoto 6 (vision and technique for the assist was excellent but faded second half)
Bassette 5 (good movement and endeavour but two good chances with his head squandered)
Mason-Clark 6.5 (nice run and finish for the goal and put in some decent crosses)
Torp 7 (decent penalty under pressure and certainty more progressive than most)
Simms 6 (although the outcome may have been different, I would have liked him to have stepped forward for the pen. Workrate off the ball was better)
Thomas-Asante 6 (looked sharp and gave good energy)
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Collins 4
MVE 0
Thomas 4
Binks 4
Dasilva 4
Eccles 3
Sheaf 4
Rudoni 4
Sakamoto 5
Bassette 3
Mason-Clark 5
Simms 6
Torp 6.5
Thomas-Asante 5
MVE 0
Thomas 4
Binks 4
Dasilva 4
Eccles 3
Sheaf 4
Rudoni 4
Sakamoto 5
Bassette 3
Mason-Clark 5
Simms 6
Torp 6.5
Thomas-Asante 5
hill83
Well-Known Member
Load up the turd reactions.
But Sakamoto is a one trick pony bag of shite. Absolute fanny.
Consistently out of position. Panics unless he’s got 5 seconds to get the ball under control to do his little trick, and if the time isn’t there feeds the ball back into whoever passed it to him leaving them in trouble.
But Sakamoto is a one trick pony bag of shite. Absolute fanny.
Consistently out of position. Panics unless he’s got 5 seconds to get the ball under control to do his little trick, and if the time isn’t there feeds the ball back into whoever passed it to him leaving them in trouble.
Last edited:
Rudoni 7 is absolutely mental. Game of opinions I know but thought he was terrible.
Doesn’t offer enough and seems to just stand in positions he can’t get the ball. We need three in the middle to protect our abysmal defence - Rudoni is a passenger at times.
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
lewys33
Well-Known Member
he didn’t used to be, was amazing to watch as you wouldn’t know what he would do. Since the injury he’s been half the player he was.
Cant be playing a CAM when you are defensively as bad as we are. Doesn’t offer us enough.
JoeCCFCPUSB
Well-Known Member
BINKS LOOKED GOOD???? Is this a wind up
Have you not seen the last 10 or so games, he's absolutely shit, as is Thomas.
They can't defend and they are league 1 level.
harvey098
Well-Known Member
That’s my worry with Simms. Imagine being a striker who’s just won a penalty and then let’s someone else take it. That’s what sets players like Gyokeres apart, he’s grabbing that ball and there is no one that can stop him. Simms needs some of that attitude.
harvey098
Well-Known Member
BINKS LOOKED GOOD???? Is this a wind up
Have you not seen the last 10 or so games, he's absolutely shit, as is Thomas.
They can't defend and they are league 1 level.
Tbf, the last 10 games have nothing to do with “Cardiff game ratings”
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Well well.
Collins 4
MVE 2
Thomas 4
Binks 4
Dasilva 5
Eccles 5
Sheaf 4
Rudoni 5
EMC 6 ‘MOTM’
Saka 5
Bassette 5
Subs
Torp 6
Asante 6
Simms 6
This is a team in serious trouble. Cardiff looked poor and still had a very easy afternoon.
Collins 4
MVE 2
Thomas 4
Binks 4
Dasilva 5
Eccles 5
Sheaf 4
Rudoni 5
EMC 6 ‘MOTM’
Saka 5
Bassette 5
Subs
Torp 6
Asante 6
Simms 6
This is a team in serious trouble. Cardiff looked poor and still had a very easy afternoon.
He has a nice left foot on him and that seems to fool many. Doesn’t communicate and was bullied today. Shite. Nowhere near good enough.BINKS LOOKED GOOD???? Is this a wind up
Have you not seen the last 10 or so games, he's absolutely shit, as is Thomas.
They can't defend and they are league 1 level.
I have a season ticket, so unfortunately, I have seen the majority.BINKS LOOKED GOOD???? Is this a wind up
Have you not seen the last 10 or so games, he's absolutely shit, as is Thomas.
They can't defend and they are league 1 level.
Binks and Thomas are left woefully exposed by their fullbacks, consistently. That is our problem at the back, rather than the centre halves themselves.
Sent from my SM-S911B using Tapatalk
JoeCCFCPUSB
Well-Known Member
You say the same thing even if we had Maldini and Cafu as our fullbacks.
They are league 1 talents.