Andy Thorn favourite for the Kidderminster job (31 Viewers)

Forums New posts
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
Sick Boy said:
It is interesting that his cheerleaders are absent on this thread! Easily the worst manager in the club's history, yet he was being lauded as one of the greatest by the majority on here. I am certain most other managers would have kept us up, yet it seems that many wanted his employment to continue in order for him to get us relegated. It was probably to blame SISU for something else.

One thing I don't understand, surely, as it was claimed before, he was an excellent manager, why were SISU never praised for their brave and visionary appointment? No one else would have gone near him, nor stuck with him for so long.

It is reassuring to that know that I disagree with most of his cheerleaders on here, they are utterly clueless.
Click to expand...

I don't think SISU deserve any pats on the back....the majority knew he was just a cheap option. People had seen so many names and reputations come and go, they just thought why not? Most didn't expect him to have a chance of keeping us up. The irony is he almost did.

The annoying thing is he didn't, but got us to a stage where it was in our own hands. We had the easiest run in of all the teams but capitulated.

To me he is just one of a long line of managers who have failed. I see him as no worse than Terry Butcher, Don Howe, Peter Reid, Ron Atkinson, Bobby Gould 2nd time, Gordon Strachan and I could mention more. All have failed in there own way and on varying budgets.
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
ccfcway said:
to be fair, he cant do anywhere near as much damage as SISU
Click to expand...

Disagree. We'd still be in the championship and the Ricoh without him.
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Hobo said:
I don't think SISU deserve any pats on the back....the majority knew he was just a cheap option. People had seen so many names and reputations come and go, they just thought why not? Most didn't expect him to have a chance of keeping us up. The irony is he almost did.

The annoying thing is he didn't, but got us to a stage where it was in our own hands. We had the easiest run in of all the teams but capitulated.

To me he is just one of a long line of managers who have failed. I see him as no worse than Terry Butcher, Don Howe, Peter Reid, Ron Atkinson, Bobby Gould 2nd time, Gordon Strachan and I could mention more. All have failed in there own way and on varying budgets.
Click to expand...

He almost kept us up? How?
 
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
March 31 21st having won last two games
Remaining fixtures were as follows and their league positions as the table stood Peterborough H 17th, Bristol C A 22nd, Burnley A 16th, Millwall H 20th, Doncaster H 24th, Southampton A 1st.

Take out Burnley A and Southampton A as defeats. The rest were games we could look to take results in. It was in our hands. It says as much about the players as Andy Thorne the way we capitulated.

That's how close he got.
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
How many games where we were up did we lose because he didn't know how to hold on to leads? There was one game where they scored 2 after 90 minutes and we lost (Palace rings a bell?)

How many dropped points were there?
 
S

skybluesam66

Well-Known Member
i think the biggest error that season was when super captain Carl baker got himself sent off against Leicester. Without that and a win there would have changed the belief around the squad and we would have had a much better 1st half of the season
 
stupot07

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Hobo said:
March 31 21st having won last two games
Remaining fixtures were as follows and their league positions as the table stood Peterborough H 17th, Bristol C A 22nd, Burnley A 16th, Millwall H 20th, Doncaster H 24th, Southampton A 1st.

Take out Burnley A and Southampton A as defeats. The rest were games we could look to take results in. It was in our hands. It says as much about the players as Andy Thorne the way we capitulated.

That's how close he got.
Click to expand...

We missed out by 8 points ...and what was our league position at the time?

We really weren't that close.

40 points in 46 games.
 
Last edited:
D

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
Sick Boy said:
It is interesting that his cheerleaders are absent on this thread! Easily the worst manager in the club's history, yet he was being lauded as one of the greatest by the majority on here. I am certain most other managers would have kept us up, yet it seems that many wanted his employment to continue in order for him to get us relegated. It was probably to blame SISU for something else.

One thing I don't understand, surely, as it was claimed before, he was an excellent manager, why were SISU never praised for their brave and visionary appointment? No one else would have gone near him, nor stuck with him for so long.

It is reassuring to that know that I disagree with most of his cheerleaders on here, they are utterly clueless.
Click to expand...

You will find I am absent from all threads since midday. You have not mentioned it on any of the other threads.
I assume they lost then?
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
dongonzalos said:
I have not checked this yet but did AT replace the top scorer who was sold in January?
Click to expand...

Yep he's signings have been slated -- the general feeling amongst the fans is it is the best and strongest squad they have ever had.
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
dongonzalos said:
I have not checked this yet but did AT replace the top scorer who was sold in January?
Click to expand...

Obsessing about Juke again? Doesn't alter the fact he had nothing in the way of tactics, no plan B and was pretty much clueless when it came to trying to change a game.
 
D

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
5-1??
May have to admit defeat on this one.
Still don't think u let a manager sign 9 players over a summer and he was trying to get DMC.
Then sack him after three draws!!

They are still muppets and should have sacked him in the summer if they had that little faith in him.

Instead of saying he wasps soberly in their plans

More Fisher rubbish
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
dongonzalos said:
5-1??
May have to admit defeat on this one.
Still don't think u let a manager sign 9 players over a summer and he was trying to get DMC.
Then sack him after three draws!!

They are still muppets and should have sacked him in the summer if they had that little faith in him.

Instead of saying he wasps soberly in their plans

More Fisher rubbish
Click to expand...

Should have sacked him months before the season even ended when it was obvious he wasn't up to the job......
 
D

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
Nick said:
So everything revolves around 1 player? Nothing to do with a manager who hasn't got a clue what he is doing?
Click to expand...

TBF Lolley was pretty dam good I wished we were in a position to get him.

How did we fair after losing Clarke?

Losing your top striker if they are not replaced can surprisingly enough have a negative as oppose to a positive impact on your performance.

I have asked the question as I genuinely don't know if he was replaced or not?
 
Last edited:
Nick

Nick

Administrator
dongonzalos said:
You mean after we sold our top striker and replaced him with an untested kid on loan?
Click to expand...

I mean before that, when some people noticed how bad he was as a manager and people were raving about our football style because our defenders passed it between them, then back to Murphy who hoofed it because it was like Barcelona.
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
dongonzalos said:
You mean after we sold our top striker and replaced him with an untested kid on loan?
Click to expand...

While the player he signed for half a million couldn't hit a barn door with a banjo?

Freddie ladapo by the way - the fans say he's crap. I think he's signed 3 players and none are rated.
 
D

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
Nick said:
I mean before that, when some people noticed how bad he was as a manager and people were raving about our football style because our defenders passed it between them, then back to Murphy who hoofed it because it was like Barcelona.
Click to expand...

Philistine
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
Don't care what it costs just get rid. The quicker he goes the less it will cost as the longer it goes on the more long term damage is being done.
Click to expand...

Precisely - it's going cost us the same whenever, but given Thorn is causing us more damage every week, we need to act now. Please.
Click to expand...

4. As previously alluded to, Mr Thorn is inept managerially. We struggled with Burr and his insistance to do things right. I like our style of play, but at times I wanted pragmatism and the odd 'battler' type to reinforce a stronger spine. None of our current squad have that quality. However Burr did give them a system but also instruction. Thorn has changed nothing, but all the players look lost. Arguments abounded on the Salisbury game, and all aimed at poor Gash, who has been left isolated in every game thus far. He lucked out over Posh. But last night not one player looked interested or even instructed to do anything. He stands on the edge of the pitch staring. I don't wish to sound rude, but the guy is a cretin.
Click to expand...

I would estimate at least 75 - 80% of fans have accepted Thorn is an unmitigated disaster now. Leaving aside the Burr saga, the Boardroom changes and bullsh*t, even the Strange Case Of The Silent KHIST, it needs to be said loud and clear, and with as much unity as possible - THORN MUST GO.

We can then start to recover and hopefully rebuild, but it can't and won't happen until he's shown the door. Every statement of support for him, be it from the Chairman or whoever, just hastens this club's demise.
Click to expand...


He doesn't have SISU to take the attention away now as well ;)

It is interesting the people who spotted early that he wasn't very good and the people that still defend him though.
 
Otis

Otis

Well-Known Member
Think most sensible fans on here could quite plainly see that he simply wasn't a manager Nick. Totally out of his depth.


How many sensible fans do we have on here mind?
 
D

dongonzalos

Well-Known Member
Otis said:
Think most sensible fans on here could quite plainly see that he simply wasn't a manager Nick. Totally out of his depth.


How many sensible fans do we have on here mind?
Click to expand...

Oooooh look at me sensible Sally
I remind you Grendel was in your camp....
:)
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
ccfcway said:
replace the word "him" for "they" and the same rings true of our owners
Click to expand...

Funny though as some of the people who backed sisu mostly are now their biggest haters and some posters warned against them at the very start are now classed as sisu apologists because they are balanced.

It does show people's judgement
 
letsallsingtogether

letsallsingtogether

Well-Known Member
Balanced Who? name one

No one on here is balanced anymore that I can see.

Nick said:
Funny though as some of the people who backed sisu mostly are now their biggest haters and some posters warned against them at the very start are now classed as sisu apologists because they are balanced.

It does show people's judgement
Click to expand...
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
letsallsingtogether said:
Balanced Who? name one

No one on here is balanced anymore that I can see.
Click to expand...

I remember Northern Wisdom and Lord both saying how bad SISU would be when we first heard their name (SISU), without searching on the computer later it will be hard to say exact names.
 
SkyBlue_Bear83

SkyBlue_Bear83

Well-Known Member
stupot07 said:
We missed out by 8 points ...and what was our league position at the time?

We really weren't that close.

40 points in 46 games.
Click to expand...

Remember we were actually out of the bottom 3 on March 31st with only 6 games left to play after the 2-0 win at Hull. We also had a favourable run in which we played Bristol (A), Peterborough (H), Milwall (H) and Doncaster (H) as 4 of the last 6 games, all of who were struggling at the time, imo from that position we should have stayed up but we bottled it massively, only got 1 point from those 4 winnable fixtures.

It was the loss at Bristol that pretty much confirmed relegation, if you look at the table had we beaten Bristol then we would have only needed 1 win from the final 5 fixtures and we would have stayed up
 
stupot07

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Thanks CCFC, I've tried to erase that season from my memory, so had forgotten about that.

Tbh, we'd already 7 games unbeaten before playing Bristol, I never really believed we had it in us to keep that going.

Millwall had just won 3 on the bounce when we played then, and the Peterborough and bristol were games where we'd dropped points from winning positions, which we'd done consistently all season. I seem to remember Nimely getting injured too for a few games around that time. We also had a lot of younger players in the team.

Thorn was inept, but I just didnt feel we had the experience and know how to keep the run going to stay up. The damage was done pre Juke 19 points from 25 games.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 32 (members: 0, guests: 32)
Top