AFCCOVENTRY
Well-Known Member
But not with Cov. Appointed scout for West Brom.
Awful manager for us but can't knock his scouting skills.
Awful manager for us but can't knock his scouting skills.
Andy Thorn is back... (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter AFCCOVENTRY
- Start date
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Where would we have been without David Bell, Gary Deegan and the like?
Personally am distinctly unsure about his scouting skills. We ended up with a lot of one paced players who could pass a ball but do little else.
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
Not forgetting dross like Jordan Henderson, Jack Cork, Danny Fox, Scott Dann, Keiron Westwood, Richard Keogh, Arron Gunnarsson and Lucas Jutkewitcz
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
That would be Fox and Dann who were sourced before he came to the club?
Covkid1968#
Well-Known Member
Pffff.....I'll fold away my "In Thorn we Trust" flag and pop it back with the "In Presley we Trust flag", which is just sitting next to the "In Dowie we Trust" flag. Never appreciated just how big my flag cupboard has become.
Still onwards and upwards....In Mowbray we Trust!!!
Still onwards and upwards....In Mowbray we Trust!!!
Nick
Administrator
The gunnarson who was recommended by some one else and westwood who was in team of the year..
AFCCOVENTRY
Well-Known Member
Your flag should say "trust no one"
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
The fact that we employed Andy Thorn as manager for a year and a half just shows how badly this club has been mismanaged.
D
Deleted member 5849
Guest
Sourced?
I was going to back down after only being able to find his Linked In page... but his timescales aren't exactly easy to follow in his employment history(!)
https://uk.linkedin.com/pub/andy-thorn/7b/5b4/738
He appears to have been chief scout with us as well as being scout for Everton and Fulham at the same time(!)
Buggered if I know anymore!
I see he misses his Kidderminster stuff off, too, and is a lover of capitals.
DazzleTommyDazzle
Well-Known Member
I'd have thought it was a pretty major part of a scout's job to follow up on recommendations to see if they agree that a player is any good - rather than just buying someone "cos he was recommended...".
Although given many of our signings over the last couple of years, perhaps that's exactly how it has been working
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
I dont think I would include any of my managerial history if I was him! Yeah strange page he has there, but I'm pretty sure it was the big man himself who recommended Fox and Dann to the club.
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
Recommended by who? And so because Westwood was clearly good it doesn't count as one of his signings?
Nick
Administrator
Recommended by who? And so because Westwood was clearly good it doesn't count as one of his signings?
It was in the CET somebody recommended him to Coleman, can't remember the name but a former player. Link doesnt work now
http://www.skybluestalk.co.uk/threa...pefully-Barton?p=235158&viewfull=1#post235158
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
It was in the CET somebody recommended him to Coleman, can't remember the name but a former player. Link doesnt work now
http://www.skybluestalk.co.uk/threa...pefully-Barton?p=235158&viewfull=1#post235158
There's a difference between recommended and scouted. I doubt he would have signed the player purely on a recommendation.
Nick
Administrator
So what's the credit for if he isn't finding them?
Westwood was in the Team of the year before we signed him.
I can understand if somebody is unearthing gems from the middle of Africa or something who turn out to be amazing players.
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
The credit is for scouting, what his job was. I'm pretty certain clubs get recommended dozens of players a day so its the scouts job to filter the shite from the good.
Last edited:
ms639
Well-Known Member
We have just sold Robbie Keane too
Might be an administrator but do you comment n anything without it being condescending/ patronising. Gets a bit boring :facepalm:
Nick
Administrator
Sorry, I forgot people without a sense of humour read too. I'll try to remember it for next time that people only have moany mode.
DazzleTommyDazzle
Well-Known Member
You really expect SISU to fund speculative scouting trips to the middle of Africa??????
Hobo
Well-Known Member
It was in the CET somebody recommended him to Coleman, can't remember the name but a former player. Link doesnt work now
http://www.skybluestalk.co.uk/threa...pefully-Barton?p=235158&viewfull=1#post235158
of course the recommendation might have endorsed the scouting ;-)
Astute
Well-Known Member
Warn us when you are reading so we don't take the piss out of someone coming out with old news. Will leave all kind of banter out if you like. Would be good if we could make it boring on here.
Nick
Administrator
No I just expect people to be realistic with what people have or haven't done. Not name players who were here before him because they were good but then ignore the Malaga's.
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
i.e scouted, what his job was and what he is being credited for. Which players that were here before him?
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Every manager, every scout has picked duff ones. It's like business people, they make duff deals too, doesn't make them an over all bad business person. It's like youth teams, coaches are judged on who makes it into professional football, not just on those who makes it into their own clubs first team.
building good teams is a black art with some luck involved. It would be like me giving you a can of petrol for an engine that wasn't set up properly. It might not work or just run rough. It doesn't mean the petrol is shit or the engine is shit though; does it?
Moff
Well-Known Member
Was he eating a sausage roll in the stand when he should have been watching Kevin Malaga? or a doughnut with Adam Barton?
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Thorn didn't join until Coleman arrived. Coleman, Steve Keane and thorn all arrived together so he didn't.
Bob Dowie was chief scout then. In fact thorn has only publically claimed credit for one player - David Bell - he he said he had admired for a long time.
DazzleTommyDazzle
Well-Known Member
Then you could set an example by being realistic about what a scouts role is i.e.
Checking out recommendations - Yes
Wandering around central Africa hoping to spot the next Pele playing in the middle of the road - No
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
I dont think anyone is ignoring the rubbish players. I agree there were some dodgy ones too but you have to balance it out.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
How about scouting players before they even joined the club?