Search results

  1. Rob S

    Judicial review day 3 - judgement day

    Clive Eakin has been relegated to the public area at the back with the rest of us. I'm on the back row behind TF & SG with Pat Abel, D & Jon Strange.
  2. Rob S

    Judicial review day 3 - judgement day

    Judge in and off we go with the CCC QC
  3. Rob S

    Favourite City Court Cases

    Too soon
  4. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Overall summary... TBH, it all comes down to how convinced the judge is at the end of submissions. No point in any second guessing or analysis really. Interesting potential blows landed on both sides but wait until the final call. No fun things released... Negotiations to follow...PLEASE!
  5. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Judge questioning CCC QC on time required. CCC QC waffling but says will finish before lunch (with 9.30 start) then ACL QC. We may be done mid-afternoon..? Then judge's judging time...
  6. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    “You mean my entire fallacy is wrong?” ;)
  7. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    More like Cov v Bristol in '77 :D
  8. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    It woke a few people up but I think they thought the session was over and were ready to jump up for the judge's exit. 5 mins to go...
  9. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Only thing available is free water & free electricity (well, nobody has stopped me plugging into the floor socket next to Tim Fisher). They're missing a trick here in the court complex...they'd make a fortune in coffee and tissue sales.
  10. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Bit of a ding-dong. CCC QC having a pop at Sisu being on their high horse but being hypocritical and throwing a few accusations about. Much rustling & muttering on Sisu side and Sisu QC making some points. All over different approaches to the bank.
  11. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Thickness-wise it's 93 pages v 63 in 'favour' of Sisu. Interesting stuff? Not at all. Basically 'Sisu's arguments are wrong, not state aid'
  12. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Going by the look of the skeleton arguments in the trial kit booklet, he will probably finish quicker than Sisu's guy did although he does seem to be getting into a bit of a groove now so could be going for a while. Note to self: Bring between-meal snacks tomorrow.
  13. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Bear in mind that the CCC QC will be trying to give a positive spin to his side. Judge listening a lot. Well, he was staring out of the window just now. Making copious notes so maybe some questioning to come soon. Personally I'd love a fast forward to the home stretch tomorrow :-) Into the...
  14. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    CCC QC reading in emails between PwC, Deloittes and ACL re: ACL cost savings – prospect for ACL being sustainable Refutes Sisu assertion that CCC didn't have this info before loan meeting
  15. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    CCC QC ' Confidence all round in ACL's ability to grow its business' summer 2012
  16. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    It was referred to quite a lot during Sisu QC's bit this morning.
  17. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Our lowest point according to Stuart 'Cossy' Cosgrove. And a fair few others. Was speaking to a CCFC person remembering that era before court this morning. ('Is that Ken sitting on the bench?'; 'No, don't be silly'; 'Bloody hell, it is! WTF?!')
  18. Rob S

    Judicial review thread - day 2

    Judge quizzing CCC QC on value of loan & stadium now. Got to love his facial expressions. Various versions of 'Yeah, right'.
  19. Rob S

    Favourite City Court Cases

    Spectre Vs Rector (One for Chris West there.)
Top