Nick
Administrator
It might just be a matter of time before this bloke and hiwula click and start scoring though? Hiwulas movement was very good at times
It might just be a matter of time before this bloke and hiwula click and start scoring though? Hiwulas movement was very good at timesIn fairness I always backed McNulty and supported him when some fans were getting on his back. Unlike some other players he was constantly coming close to scoring and I felt like it was only a matter of time.
A big name (look at Yakubu) means nothing, but quite often a negative name can be something to be genuinely worried about.
FGR want £750k for DoidgeCannot find a positive note on this guy & 9 goals in 100 games. Hmm!
Why can't we go for Doige now that I can see positives In.
Thanks for your input, it's much appreciated.
I've sadly heard the same kind of things said today, especially the bit about it being ridiculously stupid business. Unfortunately it might take a bit more than that for some of our fans to take that, or you seriously for some reason.
Exactly the same things were said about David Mcgoldrick aka Mcgoldraught who forest fans laughed at being as bad as Robert Rosario when he joined us.
Which is why you let him play a few games to judge him, surely?Yes, sometimes they are wrong.
They are also sometimes right though...
But if he had scored say 30 in a 100 games half the championship would be after him and his fee and wage would be treble. How many had Marc McNulty scored before he signed for us and in how many games ?Cannot find a positive note on this guy & 9 goals in 100 games. Hmm!
Why can't we go for Doige now that I can see positives In.
It might just be a matter of time before this bloke and hiwula click and start scoring though? Hiwulas movement was very good at times
Which is why you let him play a few games to judge him, surely?
Some of your logic is truly staggering. So because some fans say a player we’re signing hasn’t played well for them, we should never sign anyone?Yes, sometimes they are wrong.
They are also sometimes right though...
I do too, still have a feeling re Conor Chaplin totally different type of player to Bakayoko, going to be an interesting week I thinkI doubt this is the McNulty replacement. I’d imagine that Robins will have a loan signing lined up after this signing.
Two other League One clubs have tried to sign him so the professionals obviously see something in him.Equally is it wrong to err on the side of caution? Surely we shouldn't just ignore what other fans from Walsall have been saying.
What by sitting at home whinging about him? If he's dog shit after 5-10 games then by all means.Equally is it wrong to err on the side of caution? Surely we shouldn't just ignore what other fans from Walsall have been saying.
Some of your logic is truly staggering. So because some fans say a player we’re signing hasn’t played well for them, we should never sign anyone?
Two other League One clubs have tried to sign him so the professionals obviously see something in him.
What by sitting at home whinging about him? If he's dog shit after 5-10 games then by all means.
Should really have a clean slate when he signs and be judged on that.
He may come in and play a completely different role then before, he may get more service to his strong points.
If you can't ignore the Walsall fans then how can you ignore the fact that others clubs are after him and prepared to pay money for him? You can'y have it both ways.That doesn't mean it is right every case though does it? We had bidding wars for many of our shitter players over the years.
Exactly the same things were said about David Mcgoldrick aka Mcgoldraught who forest fans laughed at being as bad as Robert Rosario when he joined us.
McGoldrick always gets rolled out whenever we are signing a forward with a poor reputation, but he had played at a higher level and was a quality product of the Southampton production line. I was really excited by his signing as were my mates and brothers-the only negativity I saw about it was on here! Whereas this bloke seems, from any objective evaluation of his career to date, to be rubbish
Staggering, really, that's a bit dramatic. Of course we are going to tune in to fans of clubs where these guys have played. They may be bitter and twisted views who knows but I doubt it. Sadly at this level there is so much movement of players and no stability of teams. We are going to have to gel a whole crowd of individuals againSome of your logic is truly staggering. So because some fans say a player we’re signing hasn’t played well for them, we should never sign anyone?
I've not said anything to write off Hiwula you absolute nut case.
Has something happened in your personal life? You've being extremely out of sorts recently.
Because we've had over a month to replace McNulty and the situation appears to slowly be getting worse.
Of course final judgements can be made when the window is shut
And he has a terrible goalscoring record. One alone would be something we could perhaps treat with caution, both is cause for outright concern.Some of your logic is truly staggering. So because some fans say a player we’re signing hasn’t played well for them, we should never sign anyone?
I'll wait and see how we are at the end of the window, then I'll see how they do when they play for us and form an opinion rather then slate him before he has even signed.So you are not slightly uninspired by this potential signing given we are still trying to replace McNulty?
Not really sure what you are trying to achieve by trying to put me down for being cautious over a player other teams have warned us about.
What type of striker should we be signing then Mourinho? Forgive me but I’ll trust MR before I trust your erroneous bleatings. It’s been repeatedly said on here he doesn’t appear to be an out and out striker.Did I say that? I think it is your imagination.
All I've said is that firstly, this is not the type of striker we should be signing. Secondly I've said many Walsall fans have warned us. That second part is fact.
It's up to you if you choose to blindly ignore them.
I'll wait and see how we are at the end of the window, then I'll see how they do when they play for us and form an opinion rather then slate him before he has even signed.
People werent really shouting from the roof tops that we signed McNulty.
I'm confused by it so want to see how he will fit in and what robins has planned for him
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?