Best City XI of all-time (Central defenders x 2) (3 Viewers)

Forums New posts
skybluelee

skybluelee

Well-Known Member
Same rules as before, your choice of ALL-TIME player (but this time TWO) and the decade you started following the club so we can see how the different generations of fans are voting.

My votes - Peake, Killer
Decade 80s

Honourable mention for Peter Atherton.
 
Moff

Moff

Well-Known Member
Trevor Peake and Gary Gillepsie.

Also a mention for Scott Dann who is now showing what a good player he is with Palace.

80's
 
CJ_covblaze

CJ_covblaze

Well-Known Member
This is the only position where I've considered putting someone in who didn't play in the Prem for us (Scott Dann). However I'm going for Babb and Breen. 1990s.
 
lifeskyblue

lifeskyblue

Well-Known Member
Otis said:
You think Alan Dugdale was better than Roy Barry?

Interesting.

I thought Dugdale as distinctly average myself.
Click to expand...

No I don't think he was better but I always felt he was a good servant of the club


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Otis

Otis

Well-Known Member
lifeskyblue said:
No I don't think he was better but I always felt he was a good servant of the club


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

Right. Just never heard his name mentioned before in terms of good players who have played for us.

Think we've had a fair few quality centre halves over the years haven't we, Curtis, Barry, Gillespie, Breen, Holton, Peake, Parker, Babb, Dann, Killer.
 
Adge

Adge

Well-Known Member
Got to be Peake and Dublin. Killer worth a shout aswell.
Decade 80's.
 
Hobo

Hobo

Well-Known Member
We have had good central defenders Peake, Gillespie, Holmes, Parker, Blockley, Barry, Babb, Holton, Dann, Curtis.....

But no one has mentioned George Mason a great player and loyal servant.
 
torchomatic

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
Peake and Gillespie
70s

Sent from my SM-N910F using Tapatalk
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
You have to look at it as a defensive duo. So you need the typical robust centre half and the more adept defensive distributor alongside.

So Kilkline and Gillespie it has to be.

The problem with this type of poll, fun as it is, is that anyone post 70's never saw Gillespie and he was one if the very few star players we had.
 
Johnnythespider

Johnnythespider

Well-Known Member
Peake and Gillespie
70s
Can't believe Breen is being mentioned here I thought he was awful and wouldn't even get into my top ten centre halves. Surprised some of the younger fans haven't mentioned big Mo yet !
 
letsallsingtogether

letsallsingtogether

Well-Known Member
Grendel said:
You have to look at it as a defensive duo. So you need the typical robust centre half and the more adept defensive distributor alongside.

So Kilkline and Gillespie it has to be.

The problem with this type of poll, fun as it is, is that anyone post 70's never saw Gillespie and he was one if the very few star players we had.
Click to expand...

The thing is that the football has changed too.
Imagine Ronaldo skipping past Killer the first couple of times, the third time wouldn't have been pleasent☺
 
shmmeee

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Hmmm. I won't pick Babb because I put him at left back. I saw Gillespie, but not when he was good. Dublin was class, but I'm going to nominate him later.

so:

90s

Breen & Dann
 
R

rupert_bear

Well-Known Member
Got to go with a pair who played in top flight so unfortunately that rubies out George Curtis due to his breaking a leg in his second match so I go for Scottish centre half the brilliant Roy Barry and Trevor Peake how he never got into the England squad is a mystery

60s
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)
Top