Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Yep didn’t see any trouble against Sunderland lol
A guy legged it on the pitch
Non issue for me until we sell out why wouldn’t the safety advisory group seek to reduce flash points
Blocks 2 & 3.. (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter theferret
- Start date
A guy legged it on the pitch
Non issue for me until we sell out why wouldn’t the safety advisory group seek to reduce flash points
Happy_Martian
Well-Known Member
Okay, curiosity piqued. What's bizarre about it ? We've got a stadium that is rarely filled and an entire stand that has more empty seats than taken for most games (or that's how it looks). So closing one or two problematic blocks and looking for the fans to move isn't bizarre at all. And before the word "problematic" is focussed on, you have to ask why would the SAG pick those two blocks out of the whole ground if they weren't ?
<incorrect response removed>
I know everyone likes Singers Corner but is there any logistical problems why the North Stand couldn't be where the home fans congregate ? More room, same acoustics. Or is the need to be close to the away fans essential to supporting your team and watching a game of football ?
Last edited:
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Increases the requirement for considering what stewarding is there
Genuinely what do you think would happen if supporters were next to one another?
And before you answer nothing
Tell me what has happened before when fans were closer
That said there is a supporters forum but the club are not swayed by fans they prefer to agree safety issues with safety experts and the police advice. I know gove would disagree but surely we raise expert opinion rather than john from the pub
Again we are nowhere near selling out so unless you think people don’t bother coming if they can’t sit close to away fans then it’s not a priority surely
skybluelee
Well-Known Member
Not from the mid-90s it wasn't, the away fans were in the corner adjacent to the WT.
Balli001
Well-Known Member
Away fans were seated directly to left of the west terrace. At least be factual in trying to defend your argument
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Yep involved as a kid when Portsmouth and Leeds fans attacked kids it was lovely let’s do that again
David O'Day
Well-Known Member
what does that have to do with the blocks in question
David O'Day
Well-Known Member
when did you last sit in the wt?
torchomatic
Well-Known Member
Yeah, we were really close to home fans at Huddersfield on Saturday. Same with the Rotherham fans the other week. All part of the fun.
letsallsingtogether
Well-Known Member
Yes close enough to see tears in their eyes.
Happy_Martian
Well-Known Member
HR closed in 2005, I was last there 2002ish.
Thought I was. Knew away fans were in that stand at the end of the 80s as my first game was against Millwall. Came away richer than I went in with all the coins they threw at us
But thought that stand was converted to all home from the mid-90s ??!!Kilclines curly mullet
Well-Known Member
I think the reason why the SAG are all over us is because the behaviour of some fans in general - the fighting in and outside the stadium, the people running onto the pitch…how long have you got
They obviously think that blocks 2 and 3 are a potential flashpoint
Whether I agree or not or am right or wrong, there is a reason why the SAG are going what they are doing.
100 miles from Cov.
Well-Known Member
What trouble has been caused by blocks 2 and 3 this season? I think the decision is made as more people that cannot get close to SC have gone in there. They have closed these blocks in case there is a problem rather than there has been a problem.
David O'Day
Well-Known Member
if you where there after the mid 90s you would of been next to the away fansHR closed in 2005, I was last there 2002ish.
Thought I was. Knew away fans were in that stand at the end of the 80s as my first game was against Millwall. Came away richer than I went in with all the coins they threw at us
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
The Ricoh has been open nearly 20 years. How many times have away fans breached segregation at either side to attack fans?
None.
Port Vale tried once and got stopped by one police officer.
The simple fact is, they are doing everything they can to move fans further apart. That's fine on paper but completely destroys the atmosphere and limits capacity in popular areas.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
I would love more fans to be in the North Stand and think they should do what they can to increase the population in there next season.
However, the atmosphere at the majority of stadiums these days comes from the close sections to the away fans.
The best atmospheres in this league come from those stadiums.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
We go away to stadium's every week where fans are stood next to each other. There's not been issues inside a stadium at any away game this season.
At Huddersfield you could almost touch the home fans. No bother and a brilliant atmosphere.
Having a huge gap of segregation allows pumped up kids from either sides to get excited and act up.
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Is one way of seeing the decisions being taken under advisement by the club
Atmosphere is great not at the expense of safety I assume most people would agree
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Included on one of their videos was what they described as a group of people behaving appallingly
face facts that are a number of bone headed fans that ruin the experience for everyone else.
If it was sold out revisit it
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
Except we have data showing we are one of the safest and most law abiding sets of fans. The last pitch invader came from 24. Shall we all get kicked out too?
To be honest a couple of punch ups with a 20k crowd of mostly drunk men isn’t that bad and if it is could be solved with police presence. The people starting the punchups are just going to do it elsewhere.
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
You meant he fella wh came from around 22-23? About as far away from 2 and 3 as you can get.
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
How does not selling tickets inblock 14 or blocks 2 and 3 stop a fella running on the pitch from the other end of the ground?
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
It’s a sliding scale like all H&S though Pete. What’s the cutoff we are looking for? 0 incidents over a season? It’s not possible even if you stopped selling beer and made everyone sit down in silence under threat of expulsion. Barring the Derby game last season where I didn’t like being in that atmosphere with the kids, I’ve never felt unsafe and in reality I wasn’t then either. But it was early after lockdown ended and hasn’t happened since.
Pitch invaders are dealt with harshly and some still decide to do it, always have, just be thankful we don’t get streakers!
I’m not sure what actual safety claims are being made to make this necessary other than one or two incidents over a couple of seasons which seems par for the course.
NortonSkyBlue
Well-Known Member
At the Sunderland game it was noticeable that there was much heavier stewarding than usual in the gap between fans over @1&2. At 2-0 it was clear that the temperature had risen from both sets of fans.
I suspect it’s the cost of stewarding that has become the issue here rather than the perceived threat.
as for moving to the North stand I would have agreed but for my own experience in the early days of the arena. When the sun is out it is very difficult to watch the game with squinting.
I suspect it’s the cost of stewarding that has become the issue here rather than the perceived threat.
as for moving to the North stand I would have agreed but for my own experience in the early days of the arena. When the sun is out it is very difficult to watch the game with squinting.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
If there are a small group of fans misbehaving in Block 14 or any other area of the ground, punish them or give them warnings.
The police and stewards are not doing their job if they are not dealing with anti-social behaviour.
MusicDating
Euro 2016 Prediction League Champion!!
I don't think there's any other industry that treatment of everyone is dictated by the potential behaviour of a small minority. Yet this has driven football policy for decades. 'Take your bottle tops off your water bottles in case you use it as a weapon', 'No flasks in case you're smuggling in alcohol', 'Can't sit within 3 blocks of the away fans in case you attack them'. It's pathetic and it creates more tension.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Let's say we do the unthinkable and are within a point of the play offs before our last home game of the season against Birmingham.
It's would be the most demand we've had for a League game since the Ricoh Return. Imagine the uproar if they limit the capacity.
With half of Singers Corner cut off, 1500 seats blocked off in the away end and now limited sales in Block 2 and 3. There may be 4000+ seats left empty. Shambolic.
Or even worse, we get into the play offs and have to close 15% of the ground because the police/stewarding team cannot do their jobs.
It's would be the most demand we've had for a League game since the Ricoh Return. Imagine the uproar if they limit the capacity.
With half of Singers Corner cut off, 1500 seats blocked off in the away end and now limited sales in Block 2 and 3. There may be 4000+ seats left empty. Shambolic.
Or even worse, we get into the play offs and have to close 15% of the ground because the police/stewarding team cannot do their jobs.
DazzleTommyDazzle
Well-Known Member
The issue is not atmosphere at the expense of safety though.
The issue is atmosphere at the expense of the perception that there might perhaps one day be a bit of a safety problem, even though other grounds seem to manage without problems despite not having such measures in place.
How far do you take that thinking? People might get injured driving to the ground - better stop selling tickets altogether???
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Why the present twats have fucked up everything they’ve done in the city including the football club. Just look at the City of Culture fiasco claimed and took any plaudits available then take no responsibility for the losses incurred. Put people in charge of it who wouldn’t open the visitors centre. Spend a fortune on St Mary’s Hall surrounded now by piles of rubbish, Spon Street covered in litter, unnesesary road works. How about illegal parking throughout the city, or what about enforcing local bylaws. How about them doing what they’re supposed to do??????
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
I'm not defending the 'present twats' and won't be voting for them either, but I'm not voting tory!
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Well that’s your democratic right, not to vote in a democracy