Choice of Captain, dissapointing/ (1 Viewer)

sw88 · Jan 14, 2012

I was disappointed with Thorn today for taking the armband back off Keough. We have looked a much better unit when Keough had lead from the back with the armband.

Clingan didnt do half the talking that Keough does when he has the armband, and I was disappointed I didnt see Clingan talking to Clarke after his error cost us the goal (correct me if im wrong and this happened but I dont recall seeing it).

Im pretty sure Keough would have been there, making sure he recovered from it!

I realise its not easy to change captain half way through a season, but I just dont feel that Sammy has done enough this season to warrant the armband!

Sutty · Jan 15, 2012

The armband shouldn't matter. No special power in an armband that stops Keogh talking to Clarke.

I know it's a cliche, but we need as many captains on the pitch as we can get at the moment.

sw88 · Jan 15, 2012

Sutty said:
The armband shouldn't matter. No special power in an armband that stops Keogh talking to Clarke.

I know it's a cliche, but we need as many captains on the pitch as we can get at the moment.

That is true.. However there were times in that game where Clingan should have been getting involved, because he had the armband, but he didn't. Like when there was a Derby corner, Crainie went down holding his head, ref continued to allow Derby to keep possession and the ball in play up until we got possession back and then he decided to pull play up, even before it went out. It took other players to question the ref on this but Sammy was nowhere to be seen.

speedie87 · Jan 15, 2012

Clingan did talk to Clarke,he had a right
go him! He then had a go at macca for being knocked off the ball in the build up.

Joelly · Jan 15, 2012

clingan looked like he just shouted at clarke, not a very good reaction

sw88 · Jan 15, 2012

speedie87 said:
Clingan did talk to Clarke,he had a right
go him! He then had a go at macca for being knocked off the ball in the build up.

Not the actions of a good captain imo! Having a go at Sheffers, yes as he'd been on the pitch 70+ mins, but Clarke had been on the pitch about 2 mins, after making his first app since a long term injury. Do you not think he felt shit enough? He needed guidance, not a bollocking! Was quite surprised AT didnt publicly blame Clarke in his interview!

AFCCOVENTRY · Jan 15, 2012

Clingan is a very ineffective captain.

Herman should be captain now as he is captain for Iceland.

wingy · Jan 15, 2012

Personally it was evident to me early in the seaason that AT called this one wrong ,Keogh earns/deserves the armband week in week out .

Astute · Jan 15, 2012

I would prefer captain pugwash to captain clingan

oakey · Jan 15, 2012

So one poster thinks Clingan is wrong for not speaking to Clarke, another thinks he was wrong FOR speaking to him.
Clingan...the new scapegoat.
When he leaves for better things we'll know why. Let's drive away one of our remaining decent players, who is surrounded by overhyped kids, old timers and League one players.
Only City fans could be so stupid

sw88 · Jan 15, 2012

oakey said:
So one poster thinks Clingan is wrong for not speaking to Clarke, another thinks he was wrong FOR speaking to him.
Clingan...the new scapegoat.
When he leaves for better things we'll know why. Let's drive away one of our remaining decent players, who is surrounded by overhyped kids, old timers and League one players.
Only City fans could be so stupid

sorry Oakey, but I struggle to see how you consider him one of our remaining decent players. I rate some of "overhyped" kids better than I do Clingan, based on this seasons performances. If he spoke to him, and acted in a caprainly manner i wouldnt have an issue. But as he didnt, i do! Simples.

oakey · Jan 15, 2012

Clingan has played OK. In my view many fans criticise him because he has not shone in the playmaker role. Well, he is not being allowed to be a playmaker, in which he would do better than currently. He is being deployed as a holding midfielder, wrong position....AT persists with this because he doesn't trust anyone else to have the discipline not to wander.
This is not Clingan's best position since he is not a great tackler. He is a great passer but at the base of the diamond he has little scope to make the passes count. When he tidies up he is lambasted for sideways and back passes...yet there is no movement in front of him and we have no pace in the side.
Deegan could play base of diamond but is too erratic. Thomas was growing into the role so Clingan should have been brought into the side at right side of the diamond where his ability would be best utilised...or we could abandon the diamond. If we played a flat midfield 4 we would get the best out of Sammy but we would still have no pace or width. Maybe the promised loans will sort that out.
PUSB

Otis · Jan 15, 2012

oakey said:
So one poster thinks Clingan is wrong for not speaking to Clarke, another thinks he was wrong FOR speaking to him.
Clingan...the new scapegoat.
When he leaves for better things we'll know why. Let's drive away one of our remaining decent players, who is surrounded by overhyped kids, old timers and League one players.
Only City fans could be so stupid

Opinions eh, who'd have them.

sw88 · Jan 15, 2012

Otis said:
Opinions eh, who'd have them.

Especially on a fans forum

skybluesteve76 · Jan 15, 2012

I was disappointed he took the armband off Keogh. I've not seen keough play

SkyBlue_Bear83 · Jan 15, 2012

Clingan is a good player but a bad captain, don't think I have actually every once seen him encourage a players just gives them a bollocking all the time. Always pin point the game at Watford at home when Sammy and Hussey had handbags at the end of the match. Great leadership :facepalm:

torchomatic · Jan 15, 2012

Should be Keogh all the way.

john robinson · Jan 15, 2012

Heard the name of the captain of the capsized cruise ship is andy thorn.

sw88 · Jan 16, 2012

Who changed my thread title?? Thought there was a duplicate thread, only to find it is the one I created

Choice of Captain, dissapointing/ (1 Viewer)

sw88

Chief Commentator!

Sutty

Member

sw88

Chief Commentator!

speedie87

Well-Known Member

Joelly

Well-Known Member

sw88

Chief Commentator!

AFCCOVENTRY

Well-Known Member

wingy

Well-Known Member

Astute

Well-Known Member

oakey

Well-Known Member

sw88

Chief Commentator!

oakey

Well-Known Member

Otis

Well-Known Member

sw88

Chief Commentator!

skybluesteve76

New Member

SkyBlue_Bear83

Well-Known Member

torchomatic

Well-Known Member

john robinson

New Member

sw88

Chief Commentator!

Users who are viewing this thread

Choice of Captain, dissapointing/ (1 Viewer)

Chief Commentator!

Member

Chief Commentator!

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Chief Commentator!

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Chief Commentator!

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Chief Commentator!

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Chief Commentator!

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency