CWR v. Reading (1 Viewer)

[Dickie]

Just catching up on post match coverage on CWR - award winning broadcasting right there!

And the first 2 callers, what were they on

 

---

[Tommo1993]

Would be a much better programme if they spoke to people who were actually at games. You know, to truly reflect on it.

“I listened to commentary, I wasn’t there”. No Nick from Birmingham, you never are.

 

[Briles]

Would be a much better programme if they spoke to people who were actually at games. You know, to truly reflect on it.

“I listened to commentary, I wasn’t there”. No Nick from Birmingham, you never are.

Nick who phones in is a wum/troll I dont know how they havent clocked yet

 

[13th_choice_seamer]

Nick who phones in is a wum/troll I dont know how they havent clocked yet

They probably have so few callers they have no choice but to put him on.

I always thought that 606 should have a rule where they only take calls from people who'd attended games they were calling to talk about. Too often you get Man U or Liverpool fans from Kent giving it the expert view, despite clearly not having been to the game.

 

[clint van damme]

Would be a much better programme if they spoke to people who were actually at games. You know, to truly reflect on it.

“I listened to commentary, I wasn’t there”. No Nick from Birmingham, you never are.

Not too bothered about people not being at the game but half of them clearly haven't watched it or even listened to it. How on earth can they have any sort of valid opinion on it?

 

[chiefdave]

They probably have so few callers they have no choice but to put him on.

This is the problem. People who have been on in the past have said they get called up and asked to come on again as they're short on callers. I'd bin off the phone in and just find something else to fill the time when they're waiting to interview Robins.

 

[Dickie]

The first caller Andy was at the game, slagged off Rose, then went on to say Rose might have made us draw or lose the game (err Andy, he scored), said Fadz should have started. Then he said how well Rose did against Southampton. So by Andy’s logic, Rose did well against Southampton, then should be dropped as a reward?

Thankfully, more sane callers then came on who said no complaints, not a top performance but we won and scored 3 goals away. We could have easily played well and scored no goals and lost. But by then the line had dropped again and Oggy couldn’t respond

 

[Dickie]

They probably have so few callers they have no choice but to put him on.

I always thought that 606 should have a rule where they only take calls from people who'd attended games they were calling to talk about. Too often you get Man U or Liverpool fans from Kent giving it the expert view, despite clearly not having been to the game.

Half the time you wonder whether they haven’t even been screened.

Ohhh I hate that on 606, when they speak to Irish or Cockney Liverpool and Man Utd fans - ‘we’ this and ‘you’ that. So annoying

 

[DannyThomas_1981]

'Who needs CWR when we've got SBT'

Seriously haven't listened to the phone in for years - kind of redundant with the fan sites.

 

[13th_choice_seamer]

I'd bin off the phone in and just find something else to fill the time when they're waiting to interview Robins.

Me too. The views of randomers are of no more value than any other fan. I'd much rather listen to an ex-pro analysing what's happened. It's a bit like watching the news when they interview Brenda from Bristol in the street whilst the political editor, who knows what's actually going on, is sitting in the studio kicking their heels.

Ohhh I hate that on 606, when they speak to Irish or Cockney Liverpool and Man Utd fans - ‘we’ this and ‘you’ that. So annoying

When I lived in Middlesex I knew fella who was always going on about his love of Man United. When I asked him how often he went to OT, he was like "Oh I've never been of course, I'd love to go". It was a bit like Alan Partridge and the Irish. He did go in the end...for the stadium tour, said it was "my dream come true".

 

[Earlsdon_Skyblue1]

If anyone from CWR is reading this, I turn off at the exact moment you put Nick on every time. Please do something about it.

 

[Nick]

I don't get why they even let him on.. he gives his analysis without going to games or even watching or listening to them.

Plus he's a brummy.

 

[FulltimeWum]

They probably have so few callers they have no choice but to put him on.

I always thought that 606 should have a rule where they only take calls from people who'd attended games they were calling to talk about. Too often you get Man U or Liverpool fans from Kent giving it the expert view, despite clearly not having been to the game.

Only people who live in CV2 and CV3 should go on CWR?

 

[Grendel]

I don't get why they even let him on.. he gives his analysis without going to games or even watching or listening to them.

Plus he's a brummy.

I think he might be Danny Thomas

 

[Mcbean]

He makes notes on oggys commentary then asks him if he agrees !

 

[thekidfromstrettoncamp]

Only people who live in CV2 and CV3 should go on CWR?

Fair enough. Why ? if we live in Bedworth , Warwick or Rugby and have been to the game can we not have a view Mister Elite.The station is Coventry AND Warwickshire.

 

[13th_choice_seamer]

Only people who live in CV2 and CV3 should go on CWR?

No, I said only people who go to games. Some of my mates go to every home game from Kent, Essex, London and around, I'd listen to their view but not somebody who has sat on their arse watching it on iFollow in their bedroom.

 

[FulltimeWum]

No, I said only people who go to games. Some of my mates go to every home game from Kent, Essex, London and around, I'd listen to their view but not somebody who has sat on their arse watching it on iFollow in their bedroom.

Proper fans stand whilst listening to iFollow.

 

[junglej13]

Highlight of Clive's commentary is when he said their equaliser which made it 2-2 had hit the side netting. Took him about a couple of seconds and their players running off celebrating to correct himself.

 

[Johhny Blue]

No, I said only people who go to games. Some of my mates go to every home game from Kent, Essex, London and around, I'd listen to their view but not somebody who has sat on their arse watching it on iFollow in their bedroom.

I am

 

[AOM]

I think Nick on CWR is actually one of the more sane callers.
One guy last Friday said he didn't like Sheaf or McFadzean, we should revert to 4-4-2 and Jodi Jones is the clubs best striker.

I don't think most of the callers are on the windup either

 

[Earlsdon-Loyal-Blue]

Not too bothered about people not being at the game but half of them clearly haven't watched it or even listened to it. How on earth can they have any sort of valid opinion on it?

It’s becoming a joke mate, it’s like applying to be a Top Gear presenter with no driving license.

I don’t criticise Nick for his accent or his background that has led to him supporting us. I criticise him for making recommendations on player selections, formations and the game itself when he hasn’t absorbed the game in any form whatsoever. How on Earth can you reflect on the game from the Skysports News App commentary? If he’s so busy with work why is he always available just after the final whistle to ramble on CWR for 20 minutes?!

Radio 1 wouldn’t have film reviewers on that hadn’t bothered to watch the film so why does CWR put on callers that haven’t watched the game?

 

[Finham]

This is the problem. People who have been on in the past have said they get called up and asked to come on again as they're short on callers. I'd bin off the phone in and just find something else to fill the time when they're waiting to interview Robins.

Get Clive to play some music. Last time I heard him doing that, he put the new Erasure record on and afterwards exclaimed "they've still got it, haven't they?!" Vintage Partridge.

Tbf though, I do still get it in my head now and again.

 

[chiefdave]

Here's your chance, who is going to apply?

 

[clint van damme]

Here's your chance, who is going to apply?

I applied, put the wrong name down on my application, got a second interview!

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Would be a much better programme if they spoke to people who were actually at games. You know, to truly reflect on it.

“I listened to commentary, I wasn’t there”. No Nick from Birmingham, you never are.

He doesn't even listen to the commentary sometimes!

 

[AOM]

I applied, put the wrong name down on my application, got a second interview!

Clive, is that you?

 

[Earlsdon_Skyblue1]

Has Stuart Linnell applied?