I mean I won’t be sad if fewer children grow up in poverty, no.
As I said before I think the disconnect is seeing voting in a GE as either a statement of your values, or a binary choice in direction. There is no magical third option where everything is gumdrops and rainbows. And when there was it was a) questionably viable and b) fronted by, quite frankly, a weird crank, which even if a wasn’t true made it seem like it was.
This is a bit like that poll the Tory back benchers put out that was widely ridiculed that asked something like “Who would you rather vote for? Sunak, Starmer, a hypothetical new Conservative Prime Minister that focused on your priorities”
Surprisingly the imaginary candidate won by a landslide.
There’s a couple of related phrases from tech startup culture that are appropriate here: “vapourware” - a product that only ever appears in PR campaigns and never releases because it’s impossible. “Get in the arena” - never mind saying what you are going to build, put it into the marketplace and prove it.
The left never ships. Always promising something better is possible but never delivering it.
Left wing politicians need to get out there and win elections and put in place working policy. That trumps all the Oxford debates and protests and working groups put together.
How? How can the left do that exactly.
I voted for a centre-left set of broadly popular policies, as promised by the prospective Labour leader, Keir Starmer.
He then quickly rowed back on everything vaguely to the left and effectively moved the whole party towards the centre-right.
Rather than challenge that, you seem to be saying we should just suck it up.
I wasn't in a protest group, I was in the Labour party, a paying member, and we supposedly found someone of the left who was acceptable. Turns out it was all a front to get power.
The problem isn't with the left mate, it's with politicians like Starmer.
Whoever Labour put up as a leader is going to get hammered by the press. There isn't anyone in that job who won't be slandered or pulled apart.
The job of the leader is to manage that without caving in and to put the case for genuine change rather than just turning chicken every time a Tory paper might get upset.