Theory and practice don't always work though do they - Italy being a case in point. You also get undue influence from minority extreme parties too - imagine a coalition of DUP, UKIP, Greens... not overly central, that.
And if everything moves to the centre regardless of election, is there a point in elections full-stop?
Not against PR as such, but not sure it's the saviour it's made out to be. Our system is certainly not perfect (it elects the wrong PM far too often for my liking) but there is something to be said for a strong government able to put into action its own manifesto.
Don't Germany use PR? They're thriving as a nation
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors
Don't Germany use PR? They're thriving as a nation
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors
Isn't our recovery stronger than theirs?
I may be wrong but I didn't think they had been hit as hard as U.S. By the recession owing to their much higher proportion of industry and our economies reliance on financials services/banking sector?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors
Do you mean the recovery under a coalition governmentIsn't our recovery stronger than theirs?
Isn't our recovery stronger than theirs?
Most countries that use PR have a minimum % threshold to block out the really extreme parties with very small support. The UKIP argument seems to be the new stick to beat down PR with but whatever you think of them is it fair that they have 13% of the vote and 1 seat?
PR as a system would seem to work as something like 21 of 28 countries in Western Europe use PR. We stand with USA and Canada as proponents of FPTP. USA is a genuinely two party system (there are other parties but in their last election no other party gained even 1% of the vote), so a stronger arguement for FPTP and Canada is in a similar position to us having historically been two party but now more fragmented with growing calls for voting reform.
If you want to engage people in politics you have to make sure peoples vote counts for something.
It looks like the same old tory's as details emerge. Cutting welfare and service for the poor whilst giving the rich more tax breaks.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors
It looks like the same old tory's as details emerge. Cutting welfare and service for the poor whilst giving the rich more tax breaks.
The system works. Given the choice of who people wanted as prime minister the correct candidate won.
The boundaries are currently waited to Labour. The first act will be to introduce the boundary commission proposals of reducing constituencies to 600 and making them fairer in terms of number of voters.
this is likely to mean labour will never achieve power again - and rightly so after this pathetic attempt. Milliband put personal glory ahead of his party and it will cost them dearly. The country is conservative by nature. Milliband was like those other hapless Marxists - Foot and Kinnock (but a lot richer) and deserved his night.
As for the odious Clegg I am glad he won his seat and can sit in parliament and see the wreckage he has caused after years of work and endeavour from ash down and Kennedy. A lust for power and a dishonesty that would have even made Blair blush. Another fitting outcome.
Seems Chuka Ammuna Is ruling himself out as Its to early for him
So Yvette Cooper should in theory be the one
A good one too
God no, not if you support Labour. On the other hand if you want them to forever remain in opposition vote the sharp cat in ! Andy Burnham is their best candidate for me !
Think he's already been written off. Too much old Labour and rather dull.
It needs a fresh face and fresh thinking.
The wife of Ed Balls........no, no, no !!! Biggest cheer of the election for me when that spin doctor lost his seat !
We need some of this:
[video=youtube;lkh9Va8FD7E]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lkh9Va8FD7E[/video]
Are people still dumb enough to listen to the media and think the Lib Dems sold out? Ashdown said a wonderful bit on BBCQT on Friday that seems to sum it up perfectly.
People don't seem to know what a coalition actually means and as for selling out, 75% of the lib dems manifesto was put through while they blocked plenty of tory policies that hurt the vulnerable. All this election has resulted in is parties scared of going into a coalition of fear of the same thing happening to them and releasing the chain that was holding the Tories.
Soundbite Ashdown has never said anything remotely wonderful. He's always been an obnoxious, patronising irrelevance.
Like all politicians then.
You clearly didn't hear what he said.
UKIP haven't accepted Farage's resignation.
Have kept away from this thread during the election, there is enough arguing over on the SISU/Wasps/Council as it is. Now the dust has settled there is 1 viewpoint I read weeks ago that no one else seems to have picked upon,or considered.
That there is one leader who is more happy than Cameron that he won and that is Sturgeon,that the idea she wanted a 'progressive' (whatever that means) left alliance to lock Cameron out of Downing St was utter garbage.
His reasoning was that the SNP raison d'etre is independence , and that the best way of achieving that is a Conservative government, with little or no representation North of the border, and that every contentious decision would be presented as anti Scottish. Next year's Scottish elections would be run by the SNP on the need for another referendum to 'protect' Scotland against the 'wicked' Tories.
However if Labour had won but needed some kind of arrangement with the SNP, then despite all the anti austerity crap. the realities of office would have meant that unpopular cuts would have been needed, and that SNP would have suffered just like the Liberal Democrats. As he pointed out Greece elected a far left government on the promise of fighting austerity, and look what is happening there, huge capital outflows on the banks as people take flight, and a real expectation now that Greece will have to leave the Euro.
Sturgeon's daily rhetoric about locking Cameron out of Downing Street, was purely designed to drive English floating voters back to the Tories, and boy did it work.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?