He's played in all 18 matches and scored in one of them.
So he's scored two goals in 10 starts and 8 substitute appearances. Not exactly a great record and his performances don't scream out to me that he deserves a place ahead of a consistent goalscorer in Godden.Be sensible. On paper, he's played in all 18 league games but coming on as sub for 2 minutes against Watford, 6 minutes against Millwall, 7 against Cardiff and 10 against Plymouth doesn't give him a chance to impact the game or improve his confidence. He's actually only started 10 league games this season. And to clarify, he's scored in one game but he hit the target twice against QPR.
I'd challenge any player to improve or feel more comfortable with those types of appearances.
Stats taken from Transfermrkt (Ellis Simms - Stats 23/24)
So he's scored two goals in 10 starts and 8 substitute appearances. Not exactly a great record and his performances don't scream out to me that he deserves a place ahead of a consistent goalscorer in Godden.
I find it odd that people think we are fine with three strikers one of whom needs time to settle but they want to replace Eccles and Sheaf.
You wanted Eccles loaned out no? On other threads loads are saying drop Godden for Simms.Are these people with us in the room right now?
You wanted Eccles loaned out no? On other threads loads are saying drop Godden for Simms.
Be sensible. On paper, he's played in all 18 league games but coming on as sub for 2 minutes against Watford, 6 minutes against Millwall, 7 against Cardiff and 10 against Plymouth doesn't give him a chance to impact the game or improve his confidence. He's actually only started 10 league games this season. And to clarify, he's scored in one game but he hit the target twice against QPR.
I'd challenge any player to improve or feel more comfortable with those types of appearances.
Stats taken from Transfermrkt (Ellis Simms - Stats 23/24)
I find it odd with Robins as an ex striker he typically showed early on in his career that you need give strikers a run of games in order to get them going. You only have to look at McGoldrick, Clarke, McNulty, Chaplin, godden. All of them when signed were pretty much more or less allowed to be the main man and start no matter what. We have started to see that change he slowly brought through Vik, and is now taking his time with Wright and Simms. Different players, different situations I know
How many minutes has Simms played vs Godden? Don’t disagree that we could do with another forward though, relying on the 3 of them until the end of the season is asking for trouble.He's played in all 18 matches and scored in one of them. He needs time and support but you're suggesting to keep the pressure on and start him ahead of Godden who has scored seven, and also that we don't need reinforcements. We didn't do this to Gyokeres when he arrived and we reaped the benefits in the long term. Also Simms has generally looked far better coming on as a sub than when starting when the pressure is much greater.
I find it odd with Robins as an ex striker he typically showed early on in his career that you need give strikers a run of games in order to get them going. You only have to look at McGoldrick, Clarke, McNulty, Chaplin, godden. All of them when signed were pretty much more or less allowed to be the main man and start no matter what. We have started to see that change he slowly brought through Vik, and is now taking his time with Wright and Simms. Different players, different situations I know
I'm looking forward to seeing this with a hamer replacement playing alongside sheaf in the middleSakamoto, Simms and Wright as a forward trio could work well I think.
Does Haaland miss as many as Wright ?Anyone moaning about Wright missing an easy chance should take a look at Haarand's miss against Tottenham today
Agreed, a lot of our struggles come from midfield and the switch to 4-3-3 has mitigated that a bit.I'm looking forward to seeing this with a hamer replacement playing alongside sheaf in the middle
Said it before but i am pretty confident we will come good this season. Probably finish top ten then kick on for next year
Much more - Man City create a lot of chances!Does Haaland miss as many as Wright ?
How many has Wright missed?Does Haaland miss as many as Wright ?
You can’t really do that when Godden is our top scorer. If you’re not doing particularly well, a way to attract criticism is to not start your top goal scorer.
Godden missed a pen and Simms forced an own goal with some good play. I think Simms has played better than Godden in the last 2 games so could a justification for starting him.
Sakamoto, Simms and Wright as a forward trio could work well I think.
Agreed, a lot of our struggles come from midfield and the switch to 4-3-3 has mitigated that a bit.
In January, my hope is that we can secure that marquee signing and in the summer followed up with 1-2 additional bodies. The starting unit wouldn’t be considered Top 6 standard and the quality of player we have outside of this drops considerably.
Agreed, I personally would like to see MR stick with Simms for the next few games - he’s looked good the last two games.Of course you can do that.
You only have the top scorer justification when they continue scoring. He had a hot streak at the start of the season which has now turned into 1 in 12...
Simms has equally a bad a record of course but you can't rely on the top scorer argument for the rest of the season with godden.
I'm not sure what the reasoning was behind playing 5-2-1-2 and trying to play possession higher up the pitch. Sheaf/Eccles were constantly outnumbered & we were so vulnerable in transition.
The answer is probably we thought we'd have Hamer who could cover so much space in the middle.
It was undoubtedly unlucky, but even as a kid, I was always encouraged (in that type of situation) to aim for the most open part of the goal. Instead he tries to tank it towards the near post, similar to how you would if the keeper was on his line.View attachment 32777
Just to continue the how unlucky is Wright theme... Keeper completely out of control not even looking at the ball arms nowhere close and it hits him in the face...
Why didn’t he just play it to simms , he would of had a tap in.It was undoubtedly unlucky, but even as a kid, I was always encouraged (in that type of situation) to aim for the most open part of the goal. Instead he tries to tank it towards the near post, similar to how you would if the keeper was on his line.
Or indeed, if you didn’t realise how close the keeper was until the last second.
Wright just needs to chill his beans in front of goal, because he’s proven that he can actually finish, it’s where he’s putting the ball at times that’s letting him down.
There’s a really, really top drawer player in there, but does he even realise it?
It was undoubtedly unlucky, but even as a kid, I was always encouraged (in that type of situation) to aim for the most open part of the goal. Instead he tries to tank it towards the near post, similar to how you would if the keeper was on his line.
Or indeed, if you didn’t realise how close the keeper was until the last second.
Wright just needs to chill his beans in front of goal, because he’s proven that he can actually finish, it’s where he’s putting the ball at times that’s letting him down.
There’s a really, really top drawer player in there, but does he even realise it?
His head was down and he didn’t look up, judging by the highlights. I think Ruddy’s position took him by surprise as well, to be honest.Why didn’t he just play it to simms , he would have had a tap in.
Ruddy was in good form and the Millwall keeper’s save with his foot was top drawer. At least he’s making the keeper really work as opposed to shanking stuff wide or over the bar.It was undoubtedly unlucky, but even as a kid, I was always encouraged (in that type of situation) to aim for the most open part of the goal. Instead he tries to tank it towards the near post, similar to how you would if the keeper was on his line.
Or indeed, if you didn’t realise how close the keeper was until the last second.
Wright just needs to chill his beans in front of goal, because he’s proven that he can actually finish, it’s where he’s putting the ball at times that’s letting him down.
There’s a really, really top drawer player in there, but does he even realise it?
Absolutely, however he’s not looked up, it’s debatable if he’s seen where Ruddy is (advancing on him) and a bit more awareness and that would have been a goal.View attachment 32778
What I cropped out the picture was the covering defender on the line I'm not saying he couldn't have gone for the other side of the goal just that it wasn't open.
I'm sure Robins will continue to coach hard but the reality is he got a decent shot away the keeper was very very lucky to save.Absolutely, however he’s not looked up, it’s debatable if he’s seen where Ruddy is (advancing on him) and a bit more awareness and that would have been a goal.
I’m still not convinced that going near post (even if he saw Ruddy properly) was the best option, with at least 50% more of the goal to aim at far post. Even with the defender, who would have struggled to keep the ball out if Wright had tanked it with that pace anywhere but where he actually did.
Again, just the old (very old) rudimentary football training kicking in.
And it’s always easy to dissect stuff, with the blessing of hindsight and highlights.
I agree, especially with the way he creates space and gets into goal scoring situations; that in itself can only be trained into someone to a degree.I'm sure Robins will continue to coach hard but the reality is he got a decent shot away the keeper was very very lucky to save.
The other thing that was good to see is how he creates the space in the first place.
When Tats received the ball how close the defender was to him
View attachment 32780
Vs when he receives the ball
View attachment 32781
He'd started to drift away from his defender giving Tats the option then uses his pace to give himself more space. that is a footballing brain to do it in a way that your marker doesn't spot and follow he is helping us create. It's a shame Simms didn't play as well as we know he can given his chance. I do hope we don't just slot Godden back in to the side for the sake of it though...
I agree, especially with the way he creates space and gets into goal scoring situations; that in itself can only be trained into someone to a degree.
He did show great tenacity to shrug off the defender and create the space for the shot in the first place, but I’ll still maintain, that what he does with the ball (shooting angles etc) does need some work.
Again, I don’t think Wright realises what a talented player he is, and how he could progress into a Vik MkII.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?