He is a quality defender, there's no doubt about, but he cannot do everything on his own back. He may have made a few errors, and they are literally a few IMO, but even on Daturday he was always trying to get us going forward until the final whistle. He even ran past Sideways Sammy a few times when he came on, probably knowing full well that if he passed the ball to Sammy it would have ended up with Murphy.
Without a doubt he had been out payer of the season thus far, which kind of speaks volumes when your best player is a CB, and bearing in mind how bad our goal difference is. Imagine how bad it would be if Keogh wasn't there!!
Definately not over rated IMO!!