We'll_live_and_die
Super Moderator
MULTIPLE CHOICE!!
Who has let down the Fans, if anyone.
Who has let down the Fans, if anyone.
Last edited:
If he goes, it will be the club obviously.
Marlon hasn't come out and said he is staying it is the club so it will only be them to blame.
I don't get all this betrayal and hate stuff?
Have anyone tried to do some calculation?
What is the difference between a 10K/week 2 year contract and a 15K/week 3 year contract?
If you were MK and your agent told you - you can re-sign for Coventry or you can go to Birmingham ... the difference is £1.3mio, what would you do?
If you were the owner of this club and you knew the difference between your offer and the opporsition offer is £1.3mio, knowing the state of the club finances and knowing the player is 31 year old. What would you do?
I'm not voting in this.
All are applicable imo but none too strongly.
It's multiple choice Rob. I thought people might feel that one or more is applicable.
Have anyone tried to do some calculation?
What is the difference between a 10K/week 2 year contract and a 15K/week 3 year contract?
If you were MK and your agent told you - you can re-sign for Coventry or you can go to Birmingham ... the difference is £1.3mio, what would you do?
If you were the owner of this club and you knew the difference between your offer and the opporsition offer is £1.3mio, knowing the state of the club finances and knowing the player is 31 year old. What would you do?
Sign him up and sell him after a couple of years?
I'm not voting in this.
All are applicable imo but none too strongly. IF Marlon goes (and he hasn't yet) then he hasn't let us down, but do feel that if we've offered him a decent contract that he probably owes us some service and loyalty for the faith the cljub and fans have shown in him based on the previous.
As for the miscommunication, well yes, that's exactly what it is, but much as SISU have many faults in the way the club has been run, this isn't one of them. I don't believe there were any sinister reasons in them saying what they thought to be true at the time and the open-ness is what we have all craved.. A little naive perhaps, but nothing more and I'm sure lessons, albeit harsh ones, will have been learned from the episode.
If he does go, good luck to him. We took a gamble that proved to be a decent one - he could have been useless and there would have been none of this, so I guess we were fortunate to have seen him in a City shirt and the reason we are so disgruntled is that he has reminded us just how deficient we have been for so long in the final third.
However, we will have his wages budget which I'm sure would have been the highest at he club, to go out and find a replacement (or possibly 2-3) and Ihave every faith in Thorn and his scouting network that whoever he brings in will be able to do a job.
Have anyone tried to do some calculation?
What is the difference between a 10K/week 2 year contract and a 15K/week 3 year contract?
If you were MK and your agent told you - you can re-sign for Coventry or you can go to Birmingham ... the difference is £1.3mio, what would you do?
If you were the owner of this club and you knew the difference between your offer and the opporsition offer is £1.3mio, knowing the state of the club finances and knowing the player is 31 year old. What would you do?
According to L Brody, Marlon was offered a 3 year contract.
If he goes, it will be the club obviously.
Marlon hasn't come out and said he is staying it is the club so it will only be them to blame.
I'm not voting in this.
All are applicable imo but none too strongly. IF Marlon goes (and he hasn't yet) then he hasn't let us down, but do feel that if we've offered him a decent contract that he probably owes us some service and loyalty for the faith the cljub and fans have shown in him based on the previous.
As for the miscommunication, well yes, that's exactly what it is, but much as SISU have many faults in the way the club has been run, this isn't one of them. I don't believe there were any sinister reasons in them saying what they thought to be true at the time and the open-ness is what we have all craved.. A little naive perhaps, but nothing more and I'm sure lessons, albeit harsh ones, will have been learned from the episode.
If he does go, good luck to him. We took a gamble that proved to be a decent one - he could have been useless and there would have been none of this, so I guess we were fortunate to have seen him in a City shirt and the reason we are so disgruntled is that he has reminded us just how deficient we have been for so long in the final third.
However, we will have his wages budget which I'm sure would have been the highest at he club, to go out and find a replacement (or possibly 2-3) and Ihave every faith in Thorn and his scouting network that whoever he brings in will be able to do a job.
Have anyone tried to do some calculation?
What is the difference between a 10K/week 2 year contract and a 15K/week 3 year contract?
If you were MK and your agent told you - you can re-sign for Coventry or you can go to Birmingham ... the difference is £1.3mio, what would you do?
If you were the owner of this club and you knew the difference between your offer and the opporsition offer is £1.3mio, knowing the state of the club finances and knowing the player is 31 year old. What would you do?
I don't think it would be money based if he did move to the blues. hes spent a good 3 or 4 seasons in the prem earning alot of money, upwards of 30k a week i would of thought. Hes made his money from the game, as long as he hasn't blown it on rubbish then he should be able to live the rest of his life very comfortably. I think the only reason he would go is because it gives him the chance to win things, the chance he won't get with us.
If he does move on, then feel free to abuse him all your want, but at the moment it's just paper talk.
I tried to locate where Brody actually says the club have offered a 3yr deal, but all I can find is that the club have met MOST of Kings demands.
Please point me to the source of your information.
I tried to locate where Brody actually says the club have offered a 3yr deal, but all I can find is that the club have met MOST of Kings demands.
Please point me to the source of your information.
No problem with him leaving. What I have a problem with is him telling Thorn he would re-sign (last week) and then continued looking for something better elsewhere. If he had remained honest and said he was keeping his options open then fair enough.
I hope he breaks both fcking legs on his debut. And if it happened at the Ricoh, even better.
Yep complete betrayal by MK. He dud tell thorn he was gonna stay, he's let everyone down badly. It's all in Cov mad if you haven't seen it. Can't be arsed to post it. Bored now!