My concern with Robins (5 Viewers)

Martin180 · Oct 30, 2023

I think it will come , poor form , bad luck , call it what you will it just hasn't happened for us yet. Did we use up all our luck last season on our incredible run to Wembley , who knows ?
What I do know is that there isn't another manager I would rather have than Robins currently. He has done it before many times and I'm confident we will turn the corner.
Can't see us being in a relegation battle , we may end up lower/mid table this season however though

Saddlebrains · Oct 30, 2023

hill83 said:
More that Viveash takes the lead, doesn’t he take training as well?

He does

Ccfcisparks · Oct 30, 2023

Matt smith said:
Genuinely think he’s bereft of ideas in terms of how to improve this

The sames been said about him year after year. People are so reactionary and don’t look to what’s actually been evidenced in the past

Flying Fokker · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
How long do we give him?

3 1/2 Years…

PVA · Oct 30, 2023

Sick Boy said:
Any owner would be having doubts after 5 defeats on the bounce.

Having concerns, absolutely fine.

Actually sacking him, totally ridiculous.

SkyblueDad · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
Too busy trying to get kitching.

We had six defenders leave in the summer.
If you don’t think Kitching is good enough that’s your l opinion but he had to recruit defenders and wing backs.

Nick · Oct 30, 2023

slowpoke said:
We had six defenders leave in the summer.
If you don’t think Kitching is good enough that’s your l opinion but he had to recruit defenders and wing backs.

Isn't me who thinks he isn't good enough... It's the bloke who signed him.

We have Eccles, Kelly and sheaf in midfield.

We spent how much on Wright? Could have got a decent centre mid for that.

Sick Boy · Oct 30, 2023

PVA said:
Having concerns, absolutely fine.

Actually sacking him, totally ridiculous.

It’a hardly totally ridiculous from the owner’s perspective, especially after how much has been reinvested back into the squad.

robbiekeane · Oct 30, 2023

I still think itll come good this season. Way too early to be questioning robins position 13 games after a playoff final you fucking idiots

pusbccfc · Oct 30, 2023

robbiekeane said:
I still think itll come good this season. Way too early to be questioning robins position 13 games after a playoff final you fucking idiots

How long do we honestly keep saying this though? People were saying this when we lost to League 2 Wimbledon

Bugsy · Oct 30, 2023

There's nothing wrong with the coaching as staff or set up it's a transitional period when we come of the back of a great season and now we have invested in players like it or not we need time. The worst thing we can do is get rid. Its a tough time granted but like what's been said we need to stick through this period to see the benefits later. Every one wants success straight away it's life it don't work that way unfortunately. Keeping together is key. I'm only gonna say this once I just hope we all stay together even if it's the 15k hardcore....PUSB

Sick Boy · Oct 30, 2023

My main concern with him at the moment is the Wright signing and how much money looks to have been wasted.

The Philosopher · Oct 30, 2023

Robins learned his trade under Fergie.

Fergie always had a leader on the pitch, Roy Keane / Scholes etc.

Robins had Doyle then Hamer etc. we improved with Kelly last season.

We are one man short in the middle v

Martin180 · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
How long do we give him?

As long as it takes

pusbccfc · Oct 30, 2023

Sick Boy said:
My main concern with him at the moment is the Wright signing and how much money looks to have been wasted.

It's a real test of his management now.

For all the McNulty's and Gyökeres, let's not forget Robins failed to get the best out of JCH and Conor Chaplin who went on to do very well.

Haji was linked with 3/4 top clubs in the past year including Palace and Rangers. He's clearly got something but we aren't getting the best out of him. Same could he said about Simms.

ms639 · Oct 30, 2023

He’s tried to completely change the way we play and it’s backfired simple as that. Last season we played high tempo counter attacking football. Moved the ball quickly through the lines and fortunately had a monster of a striker who would batter defenders all game.

He’s intentionally trying to play a possession based game now and it simply isn’t working. The defenders are static and don’t drive forward with the ball like McNally and Doyle did last year, Eccles is so negative in possession, everything is sideways and backwards and our strikers are misfiring, it’s a recipe for disaster.

MR made it abundantly clear in the fans forum recently that he has final say on signings and clearly he is choosing the way we play, it’s just not working right now and the worrying thing is, I really don’t know how he fixes it at the moment.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

robbiekeane · Oct 30, 2023

pusbccfc said:
How long do we honestly keep saying this though? People were saying this when we lost to League 2 Wimbledon

People were saying this after 10/12 games last season and saying "how long can we blame the pitch" then we got to the championship playoff final and our highest ever second tier finish

SeaSeeEffCee · Oct 30, 2023

pusbccfc said:
It's a real test of his management now.

For all the McNulty's and Gyökeres, let's not forget Robins failed to get the best out of JCH and Conor Chaplin who went on to do very well.

Haji was linked with 3/4 top clubs in the past year including Palace and Rangers. He's clearly got something but we aren't getting the best out of him. Same could he said about Simms.

Zain Westbrooke was linked with a host of clubs above us in the pyramid and has ended up playing out most of career as a squad player in League Two. Imaginary links invented by agents don’t really mean anything.

Nick · Oct 30, 2023

Martin180 said:
As long as it takes

For what?

Saddlebrains · Oct 30, 2023

robbiekeane said:
People were saying this after 10/12 games last season and saying "how long can we blame the pitch" then we got to the championship playoff final and our highest ever second tier finish

Booking your hotel now then or?

Evo1883 · Oct 30, 2023

Sick Boy said:
It’a hardly totally ridiculous from the owner’s perspective, especially after how much has been reinvested back into the squad.

He's not out of pocket at all , 15 mill up

Nick · Oct 30, 2023

robbiekeane said:
People were saying this after 10/12 games last season and saying "how long can we blame the pitch" then we got to the championship playoff final and our highest ever second tier finish

We had a couple of trump cards.

Martin180 · Oct 30, 2023

ms639 said:
He’s tried to completely change the way we play and it’s backfired simple as that. Last season we played high tempo counter attacking football. Moved the ball quickly through the lines and fortunately had a monster of a striker who would batter defenders all game.

He’s intentionally trying to play a possession based game now and it simply isn’t working. The defenders are static and don’t drive forward with the ball like McNally and Doyle did last year, Eccles is so negative in possession, everything is sideways and backwards and our strikers are misfiring, it’s a recipe for disaster.

MR made it abundantly clear in the fans forum recently that he has final say on signings and clearly he is choosing the way we play, it’s just not working right now and the worrying thing is, I really don’t know how he fixes it at the moment.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nonsense regarding Eccles tonight

junglej13 · Oct 30, 2023

The Philosopher said:
Robins learned his trade under Fergie.

Fergie always had a leader on the pitch, Roy Keane / Scholes etc.

Robins had Doyle then Hamer etc. we improved with Kelly last season.

We are one man short in the middle v

And to state the obvious... Goals. Not just the strikers. I thought the centre backs would score more this season but the delivery is chronic. Need to stop playing 7 defensive minded players every game and expecting to suddenly start scoring.

Nick · Oct 30, 2023

Evo1883 said:
He's not out of pocket at all , 15 mill up

He didn't say out of pocket though.

Martin180 · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
For what?

To transition the squad

Evo1883 · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
He didn't say out of pocket though.

Well the reinvestment is a long term thing , 4 years to get a return on these players not 14 games

higgs · Oct 30, 2023

We need to go back to the pressing counter attacking game all this possession we have has no end product

Sent from my SM-A528B using Tapatalk

Greggs · Oct 30, 2023

Robins has hit his ceiling.

Nick · Oct 30, 2023

Martin180 said:
.To transition the squad

That a buzz word?

"As long as it takes" is madness. Completely deluded.

pusbccfc · Oct 30, 2023

robbiekeane said:
People were saying this after 10/12 games last season and saying "how long can we blame the pitch" then we got to the championship playoff final and our highest ever second tier finish

It's clearly very, very different now than then. People need to stop wheeling out this excuse.

This time last year we had two of the best ever Championship players and a team fighting for every point.

Equally, we were actually pretty good in those early games. We battered Sunderland, Millwall and Hull at that time.

HuckerbyDublinWhelan · Oct 30, 2023

Robins appears to be a fire fighter, when his backs against the wall he comes out on top.

different environment now - the expectation has changed ala Huddersfield and Scunthorpe, where he’s deemed a failure

Martin180 · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
That a buzz word?

"As long as it takes" is madness. Completely deluded.

So we sack arguably one of our top 3 managers of all time ?
And I'm deluded

Ccfcisparks · Oct 30, 2023

Nick said:
That a buzz word?

"As long as it takes" is madness. Completely deluded.

To suggest sacking him after 14 games is much more pathetic

pusbccfc · Oct 30, 2023

SeaSeeEffCee said:
Zain Westbrooke was linked with a host of clubs above us in the pyramid and has ended up playing out most of career as a squad player in League Two. Imaginary links invented by agents don’t really mean anything.

It's true but you can look at Walker and Waghorn. Two players that went backwards under Robins.

My concern with Robins (5 Viewers)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency