I have collated 6,261 individual player ratings on this forum from 46 league game with 28 players starting at least 1 game. The idea was to get at “the wisdom of the crowd” but just as often it shows the “inherent bias of the crowd” – predilection for centre halves, unappreciative of our top scorer. In the end 19 started at least 3 games (excluding those who have been transferred out).
Player of the Year Hyam averaged 6.8 per game, narrowly beating Kelly 6.7 Willis 6.7 Davies 6.6. Nothing in it really
Dud of the year Shipley averaged 5.5 per game (Technically O’Brien (four games) and McCallum (three games) had an average rating less ).
It is easy for central defenders to impress, I suspect. Harder for strikers and full backs
Man of the Match Kelly and Burge were both rated M.o.t.M most often - 7 games each. I’m saying nothing.
Dud of the Match Hiwula was rated Dud of the Match in nine games (four on the bounce at one point). Easy winner
Bayliss Good job he’s not commercially valued by the player raters – 5.9 – 12th best. But it’s why we should take the money. Good but not delivering for League 1
Davies Played 20 games, compared with Hyam 37 Willis and Willis 36. Shows two things – you need three good central defenders in a squad, and Davies had plenty of chance to prove himself