Now its potentially a reality , Will mark Robins be Coventrys greatest manager if we get promoted (7 Viewers)

Forums New posts

Is mark robins Our greatest ever manager if we get promoted

  • Yes

    Votes: 140 95.2%

  • No

    Votes: 7 4.8%
  • Total voters
    147
Boosh

Boosh

Well-Known Member
Boosh

Boosh

Well-Known Member
www.skybluestalk.co.uk

Biamou - new contract

I very much doubt Biamou is on anything like 4k. It's not really a particularly hot take. I would Biamou is closer to 4k then 1k (more likely 2.5-3k). I'm basing it on an initial average L2 wage, 2 promotion wage rises, new contract while in L1 (rise) and 3 yearly incremental wage rises. Jones...
www.skybluestalk.co.uk www.skybluestalk.co.uk

Interesting…
 
P

PVA

Well-Known Member
Boosh said:
www.skybluestalk.co.uk

Biamou - new contract

I very much doubt Biamou is on anything like 4k. It's not really a particularly hot take. I would Biamou is closer to 4k then 1k (more likely 2.5-3k). I'm basing it on an initial average L2 wage, 2 promotion wage rises, new contract while in L1 (rise) and 3 yearly incremental wage rises. Jones...
www.skybluestalk.co.uk www.skybluestalk.co.uk

Interesting…
Click to expand...

Thanks for proving my point again 👍🏻
 
Boosh

Boosh

Well-Known Member
PVA said:
Thanks for proving my point again 👍🏻
Click to expand...

Keep Biamou and Walker not Gyo, wow. Kelly over Hamer wow. Kenny Jackett hahahah

But after all that, it really makes you think… just how good is DaCosta
 
rob9872

rob9872

Well-Known Member
No mention for Gould who bought the cup final team and won it the year after with unfancied Wimbledon? 🤔🤣

In all seriousness I think Sillet for his man management, Hill for influences in the wider game and starting the Sky Blue revolution - MR currently behind them both, but we win next week and I'll contribute to any statue fund!
 
Last edited:
Torquay Sky Blue

Torquay Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Seen em all but Sillet is my favourite because of 87 . I was 28 then . Hill promotion only 8 and now with MR an old fucker.
What Robins has done is truly remarkable. I'll be at Wembley and tbh I never thought this would happen again in my lifetime. I can't wait
 
SkyblueDad

SkyblueDad

Well-Known Member
Torquay Sky Blue said:
Seen em all but Sillet is my favourite because of 87 . I was 28 then . Hill promotion only 8 and now with MR an old fucker.
What Robins has done is truly remarkable. I'll be at Wembley and tbh I never thought this would happen again in my lifetime. I can't wait
Click to expand...
Fans seem to forget George Curtis was the manager of the cup final team.
 
Hutch11

Hutch11

Well-Known Member
They're all greats in their own right , all have done remarkable things for the club
Like another poster said, MR has made watching the City a fantastic experience again
Before him I can't remember when I was last looking forward to going to games so much
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
slowpoke said:
Fans seem to forget George Curtis was the manager of the cup final team.
Click to expand...
He was the general manager, Sillet was the first team coach. They had equal billing, but Sillet was responsible for tactics and training, Curtis was the admin and motivation. Sillet generally recognised as having more influence over the team itself however.
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Skyblueweeman said:
Whilst not the whole of football, Robins has not only changed the culture of the club, but managed to unite (largely) a fan base that was fragmented, in our lowest possible situation.
Click to expand...
Different type of culture to Hill though. Hill made a club beyond a team. Hill made us at the forefront of the white heart of technology. Hill really is unique in what he did and that can't be undervalued.
 
T

theferret

Well-Known Member
Torquay Sky Blue said:
Seen em all but Sillet is my favourite because of 87 . I was 28 then . Hill promotion only 8 and now with MR an old fucker.
What Robins has done is truly remarkable. I'll be at Wembley and tbh I never thought this would happen again in my lifetime. I can't wait
Click to expand...

Sillet is under appreciated. His 4 top flight finishes were 10th, 10th, 7th and 12th. The year we were 7th we were genuine title contenders for much of that season and should have finished higher. Add in the FA Cup win and 2 cup semi-finals, it was a remarkable period for the club, and perhaps not one fully appreciated at the time, especially as the English game was in the doldrums generally. Pity we didn't get to play in Europe.

Robins pulls this off though, it's an almighty achievement. Statue worthy.
 
C

croatskyblue

Well-Known Member
If you take all the promotions and cup wins in our history, and IF we beat Luton, here’s how it allstacks up:

Frank Scott Walford
1914/1915 promoted

Harry Storer
1935/1936 promoted (champions)

Billy Frith
1958/1959 promoted

Jimmy Hill
1963/1964 promoted (champions)
1966/67 promoted (champions)

John Sillett
86/87 FA Cup Winners

Mark Robins
2016/2017 checkatrade trophy winners
2017/18 promoted
2019/2020 promoted (champions)
2022/23 promoted

That would make Mark Robins responsible for 40% of all promotions and cup wins in our history.

what sticks out there is that no matter who your personal preference is, Jimmy Hill, John Sillett and Mark Robins are leagues ahead of the rest. Storer could maybe have matched them had WW2 not intervened, but also in terms of impact on the club and the city, which isn’t purely about results, you can’t touch the ‘big three’.
 
clint van damme

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
Hutch11 said:
They're all greats in their
Click to expand...

theferret said:
Sillet is under appreciated. His 4 top flight finishes were 10th, 10th, 7th and 12th. The year we were 7th we were genuine title contenders for much of that season and should have finished higher. Add in the FA Cup win and 2 cup semi-finals, it was a remarkable period for the club, and perhaps not one fully appreciated at the time, especially as the English game was in the doldrums generally. Pity we didn't get to play in Europe.

Robins pulls this off though, it's an almighty achievement. Statue worthy.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I always maintain if European football was at stake or if the financial rewards for the higher you finish existed then, we would have finished even higher in at least a couple of those seasons.
 
Robinshio

Robinshio

Well-Known Member
croatskyblue said:
If you take all the promotions and cup wins in our history, and IF we beat Luton, here’s how it allstacks up:

Frank Scott Walford
1914/1915 promoted

Harry Storer
1935/1936 promoted (champions)

Billy Frith
1958/1959 promoted

Jimmy Hill
1963/1964 promoted (champions)
1966/67 promoted (champions)

John Sillett
86/87 FA Cup Winners

Mark Robins
2016/2017 checkatrade trophy winners
2017/18 promoted
2019/2020 promoted (champions)
2022/23 promoted

That would make Mark Robins responsible for 40% of all promotions and cup wins in our history.

what sticks out there is that no matter who your personal preference is, Jimmy Hill, John Sillett and Mark Robins are leagues ahead of the rest. Storer could maybe have matched them had WW2 not intervened, but also in terms of impact on the club and the city, which isn’t purely about results, you can’t touch the ‘big three’.
Click to expand...
If we get promoted, only an idiot would not put him up there, with the challenge in todays game being so much harder due to finances, playing at different grounds, no pitch etc etc - but it is totally impossible to say where he would sit alongside the others - and to shout people down who think 1 way or other, is foolish, - as there is no right answer

Before MR we had only been to Wembley in 1 year, now in his 6 year stint we have done it in 3 years . Crowds have increased from around 9k to 20k average . Squad value gone up from maybe £2m to nearer £40m + . I was not around in the JH era, and my late dad used to tell me stories of that, but MR is bringing the club together and the city probably in a similar way .

JH was not infallible, and when Chairman, some of the chants from our own fans, especially the day we lost at home to Notts county -

Just as in any sport , you cant truly compare between eras, and so it maybe impossible to say is he 1,2,3 etc - but he certainly ranks alongside them, and in our Mount Rushmore it would certainly be him with JS/GC/JH from my era (I dont know enough of those pre 60s).


Robins so far has succeeded with every challenge given to him, with the rules of the competition at the time
That said I think him and Adi are very much our Clough and Taylor

League 2 1 year
League 1 2 years
Championship Please please 3 years
he now has 4 years ....... what next
 
CDK

CDK

Well-Known Member
Remember the JH spell backed by Derrick robins through from cantwell,through the Milne era the sillet spell and FA cup victory to Atkinson and Strachan.
Then came Sisu who I thought were looking to remove the club from the league pyramid ,then came mark robins second coming and on no money re written the JH story and made it more impressive than the original on the pitch creating his own legacy,
I think he's already our greatest manager ever.
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
slowpoke said:
Fans seem to forget George Curtis was the manager of the cup final team.
Click to expand...

You keep saying this Rupert and it’s not going to change the fact he wasn’t
 
C

croatskyblue

Well-Known Member
Grendel said:
You keep saying this Rupert and it’s not going to change the fact he wasn’t
Click to expand...

they had the same job title but their roles were vastly different. Make no bones about it, Sillett was the manager of the team, Curtis was the disciplinarian/ admin/ organiser- no doubt a big factor in the team spirit though.

there’s a video on YouTube of us v Liverpool in 86/87. Pre match Sillett is in with the players the whole time, while Curtis runs around the restaurant, sorting tickets out and that type of thing. Pretty sure Sillett said himself that he was the football man- so although Curtis had the title and was in and around the players, Sillett was the man in charge of the football side.
 
H

Happy_Martian

Well-Known Member
People equate Robins with the Checkatrade win but that wasn't his squad or his efforts to get us there. We'd already qualified for the final when Robins was re-appointed and he didn't go into that with any momentum as his first 3 games (2 at home) were all defeats. So in that context, beating Oxford in the final could be considered as much Russell Slade's success as Robins'.

Everything since though, Robins, Viveash, Adi's predecessor Steve Taylor and the rest of the backroom staff have to take the full weight of praise for what has effectively been a phoenix-like transformation of the club.
 
C

croatskyblue

Well-Known Member
Happy_Martian said:
People equate Robins with the Checkatrade win but that wasn't his squad or his efforts to get us there. We'd already qualified for the final when Robins was re-appointed and he didn't go into that with any momentum as his first 3 games (2 at home) were all defeats. So in that context, beating Oxford in the final could be considered as much Russell Slade's success as Robins'.

Everything since though, Robins, Viveash, Adi's predecessor Steve Taylor and the rest of the backroom staff have to take the full weight of praise for what has effectively been a phoenix-like transformation of the club.
Click to expand...

I thought about that, but look at the run we were on, and Oxford were miles above us, Slade got us to the final alright but that was some going to win that final
 
SkyblueDad

SkyblueDad

Well-Known Member
theferret said:
Sillet is under appreciated. His 4 top flight finishes were 10th, 10th, 7th and 12th. The year we were 7th we were genuine title contenders for much of that season and should have finished higher. Add in the FA Cup win and 2 cup semi-finals, it was a remarkable period for the club, and perhaps not one fully appreciated at the time, especially as the English game was in the doldrums generally. Pity we didn't get to play in Europe.

Robins pulls this off though, it's an almighty achievement. Statue worthy.
Click to expand...
But then if you want to be picky there was Sutton United and Northampton sandwiched in that time, but then in fairness Robins cup record is not a lot to talk about with home defeats to Northampton and Wrexham.
Grendel said:
You keep saying this Rupert and it’s not going to change the fact he wasn’t
Click to expand...
Does it matter, I suggest you drop out of these manager discussions after your never to be forgotten Kenny Jackett comment.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 8 (members: 0, guests: 8)
Top