Penalty Decision (1 Viewer)

[Nick]

Still baffled at how he could stop the ball going towards the goal with his hand and have no handball given.

 

---

[Pricey1984]

Have we had a penalty since the Fulham one last October? I'm struggling to remember one

 

[Tommo1993]

Have we had a penalty since the Fulham one last October? I'm struggling to remember one

Pen against Fulham was our second of four penalties.

1. Barnsley - Aug
2. Fulham - Oct
3. Derby - Oct
4. Bristol - Nov

 

[Deleted member 2477]

Have we had a penalty since the Fulham one last October? I'm struggling to remember one

And despite several other clear dives caught on Sky where the ref took no action Godden is the only ban dished out retrospectively last season. Work that one out

 

[MalcSB]

And despite several other clear dives caught on Sky where the ref took no action Godden is the only ban dished out retrospectively last season. Work that one out

It will be the EFL equalising the vendetta against us and Wasps.

 

[Pricey1984]

And despite several other clear dives caught on Sky where the ref took no action Godden is the only ban dished out retrospectively last season. Work that one out

I've long given up trying to second guess the EFL / FA rules tbh

 

[Deleted member 2477]

It will be the EFL equalising the vendetta against us and Wasps.

Think its more the fact that Fullham made such a song and dance about it and their manager made an official complaint to the fa

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

Still baffled at how he could stop the ball going towards the goal with his hand and have no handball given.

It's another one of the bullshit laws deliberately designed to be controversial so as to make the game seem more exciting and keep people talking about it. Just say if it hits the hand it's handball and give an indirect free-kick from the spot it occurs. If it's deliberate or stopping a goal give a red card to go with it.

Same as the offside rule. Fuck off with active/inactive making it murkier than a swamp. If you're in an offside position, it's offside whether you touch the ball or not. If the team gets goals disallowed because some numpty not involved can't keep behind the last defender then the fans/coaches/teammates will soon let him know about it and he'll quickly learn or be out of the team.

 

[PVA]

Looked like a penalty to me.

I'd also like to see the challenge on Hamer again because that looked a possible red card.

Oh well.

 

[Bad Boy]

It's another one of the bullshit laws deliberately designed to be controversial so as to make the game seem more exciting and keep people talking about it. Just say if it hits the hand it's handball and give an indirect free-kick from the spot it occurs. If it's deliberate or stopping a goal give a red card to go with it.

Same as the offside rule. Fuck off with active/inactive making it murkier than a swamp. If you're in an offside position, it's offside whether you touch the ball or not. If the team gets goals disallowed because some numpty not involved can't keep behind the last defender then the fans/coaches/teammates will soon let him know about it and he'll quickly learn or be out of the team.

Better idea, scrap the offside rule altogether.
High scoring games would suit me. Extra point if you score more than 10.

Handball is handball. End of. Harsh at times but at least you wouldn't need a first class honours degree trying to figure out whether it was natural/ unnatural.

 

[TewkesburySkyBlue]

Looked like a penalty to me.

I'd also like to see the challenge on Hamer again because that looked a possible red card.

Oh well.

My first reaction when I saw it 0n the replay today was that the challenge on Hamer was definitely a red.
Then the Millwall neanderthals in the crowd were deliberately winding him up which no doubt let to his subsequent behaviour

 

[Kilclines curly mullet]

Looked like a penalty to me.

I'd also like to see the challenge on Hamer again because that looked a possible red card.

Oh well.

I thought so, Hamer was wound up from that point and was a red card waiting to happen

 

[Deleted member 2477]

Their idiots were chucking bottles at him whilst he lay injured on the touchline. Should have been a red to their player for a sinical challenge and it was clear that they had a plan to wing him up and get him sent off. Team full of cloggers followed by a bunch of knuckle draggers

 

[ccfc922]

Looked like a penalty to me.

I'd also like to see the challenge on Hamer again because that looked a possible red card.

Oh well.

When was this penalty incident roughly? Can't remember it myself but it was hot n beers etc

 

[zuni]

I thought so, Hamer was wound up from that point and was a red card waiting to happen

We could all see it, why didn't robins...he is a top manager but sometimes....aaargh, ffs
..rant over

Deffo a pen might have been close to his body but his hands were over his head

 

[Evo1883]

Didn't get a great view right behind the goal, just assumed it was blasted at his arm which was in a natural position ?

Which I'm guessing it wasn't

 

[Evo1883]

We could all see it, why didn't robins...he is a top manager but sometimes....aaargh, ffs
..rant over

Deffo a pen might have been close to his body but his hands were over his head

Replied without reading the thread properly .. really ? Was his arm up above his head .. that's a penalty

 

[WestEndAgro]

I thought so, Hamer was wound up from that point and was a red card waiting to happen

So why didn't Robbings pull him off

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

So why didn't Robbings pull him off

Cos he'd get arrested for public indecency. Though it probably would have calmed him down.

 

[Frankly_Mr_Shankly]

Still baffled at how he could stop the ball going towards the goal with his hand and have no handball given.

If that was in the Prem League it would have been given. A penalty all day long.

 

[pusbccfc]

Millwall fans did a good job of swaying the officials yesterday. He'd never send off one of their players for that tackle because of the response.

 

[mark82]

Millwall fans did a good job of swaying the officials yesterday. He'd never send off one of their players for that tackle because of the response.

That second one was a yellow whoever it would have been. Can't really complain about that.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Replied without reading the thread properly .. really ? Was his arm up above his head .. that's a penalty

Arms stretched out, excellent goalkeeping actually

 

[pusbccfc]

That second one was a yellow whoever it would have been. Can't really complain about that.

But the first yellow was given for what seemed to be two tackles. He was desperate to book Hamer for tackles other players do not get.