JulianDarbyFTW
Well-Known Member
Marosi 6
Pask 6
Hyam 7
Ostergaard 6
Fadz 7
Giles 6
O' Hare 8
Hamer 8
Shipley 6.5
Allen 7
Godden 7
Pask 6
Hyam 7
Ostergaard 6
Fadz 7
Giles 6
O' Hare 8
Hamer 8
Shipley 6.5
Allen 7
Godden 7
Player Ratings v Bristol (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
But who covers sheaf & Hamer if he needs to come off again like today ?
we need another cdm in this week loan possibly
Eccles perhaps?
Don't get me wrong I rate Shipley when attacking but defensively he is a liability, but yea I wouldn't mind bringing in another experience cdm.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
Not at the level required mate
Was messing
, I do think maybe Pask could fit in there though I wouldn't mind seeing him play there for a game I bet he would do OK.LuigiSkyBlue
Member
Enjoyed the game and real shame for the lads as they ran their socks off (which unfortunately did show physically slowing and mentally reacting after 70+ mins).
Thought the midfield was outstanding first half picking pockets and finding space.
two biggest positives for me were: o,hare will shine in championship as more technical and so gets more space and less kicks and shirt pulling than league 1 ! Even in the mk friendly he was fouled constantly but will get more protection in championship from refs. opposition tactics: they will come at us and so more space to break with that midfield we have. No more congested parts of pitch with 11 big physical players just parking bus and kicking us !
i think it will be a very different season, take us time to adjust and we just have to support the lads as they learn and develop
Thought the midfield was outstanding first half picking pockets and finding space.
two biggest positives for me were: o,hare will shine in championship as more technical and so gets more space and less kicks and shirt pulling than league 1 ! Even in the mk friendly he was fouled constantly but will get more protection in championship from refs. opposition tactics: they will come at us and so more space to break with that midfield we have. No more congested parts of pitch with 11 big physical players just parking bus and kicking us !
i think it will be a very different season, take us time to adjust and we just have to support the lads as they learn and develop
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Good point it seemed earlier than that
capel & collindridge
Well-Known Member
True. It was the first minute that lost us a point, Never mind the other 22 mins. And I thought Kelly was playing well.
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
He was
Legia Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
7's for Giles, Hamer, Walsh, Allen, O'Hare & Godden with 6 for the rest.
Man of the match - O'Hare, although like the rest he visibly tired in that last 15 minutes.
Giles and Hamer were also close to man of the match, but Giles was part of the dozy back line that conceded the sloppy 1st goal, and Hamer's lack of discipline also cost us. While he is obviously going to pick up bookings, he needs to be cuter once he has been booked. He was clearly going to be sent off if MR hadn't subbed him, and he didn't help himself by screaming in the refs face when he was being spoken to.
Man of the match - O'Hare, although like the rest he visibly tired in that last 15 minutes.
Giles and Hamer were also close to man of the match, but Giles was part of the dozy back line that conceded the sloppy 1st goal, and Hamer's lack of discipline also cost us. While he is obviously going to pick up bookings, he needs to be cuter once he has been booked. He was clearly going to be sent off if MR hadn't subbed him, and he didn't help himself by screaming in the refs face when he was being spoken to.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
We probably tried to rush Kelly back a bit soon, especially with Sheaf not being fully up to speed? Hope it is nothing too serious as we need Kelly.
Shipley is not a DM - so lets not be too harsh when he is just trying to plug gaps in an unfamiliar role.
Hamer, Sheaf and Walker all seem excellent aquisitions. Not the start we were hoping for but not the thumping some were predicting last week.
Shipley is not a DM - so lets not be too harsh when he is just trying to plug gaps in an unfamiliar role.
Hamer, Sheaf and Walker all seem excellent aquisitions. Not the start we were hoping for but not the thumping some were predicting last week.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Once Dabo is back I would suspect it will be Pask.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
It'll be Eccles e
Hobo
Well-Known Member
If Eccles is given a shot I wouldn't be too worried. I thought he has looked half decent when I have seen him.
The reason I said Pask is he prefers to play in centre of defence and who has been brought up as a technical footballer at West Ham.
I believe he has had some experience playing as a CDM earlier in his career.
I think people are being harsh on Hamer.
He made 3 fouls.
3. It's not like it was 10!
He got booked for the first one because Bristol City were breaking with many of our players forward and he felt he needed to bring the man down. It could have saved a goal, who knows.
Tackling is part of his game and of we try and temper that we're taking something away from him.
He made 3 fouls.
3. It's not like it was 10!
He got booked for the first one because Bristol City were breaking with many of our players forward and he felt he needed to bring the man down. It could have saved a goal, who knows.
Tackling is part of his game and of we try and temper that we're taking something away from him.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
No
SussexSkyBlue
Active Member
Please explain, how Shipley is rated better than Giles?
JulianDarbyFTW
Well-Known Member
Because I thought he played better.
matesx
Well-Known Member
boom!
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Irish Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Whenever Eccles has played he has been impressive. I read on here he is 20 now? If that is the case then he needs to be given his chance. I can't see a reason for keeping him if he isn't going to be played.
DazzleTommyDazzle
Well-Known Member
I'm sure that when we signed him they said that he was a central defender, but could also play right back or CDM.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
He will play tonight alongside sheaf we have no other options.
Warwickhunt
Well-Known Member
i would look at your wifi! i had problems untili put a tether line from the router to my laptop and had perfect reception not one buffer