Why do people obsess over haynes?? Has 1 good half against portsmouth reserves and suddenly he is amazing! Page is clearly better and im amazed anyone thinks differently
Seriously you must have something in your eyes.Why do people obsess over haynes?? Has 1 good half against portsmouth reserves and suddenly he is amazing! Page is clearly better and im amazed anyone thinks differently
Your days must be Long and boringI can seriously state Page is better than Haynes. Here goes:
I seriously believe Page is better than Haynes.
Simple.
I look forward to you reeling off the list of games where haynes has been above average. More than 1 manager hasnt rated haynes yet page is highly rated at west ham and both mowbray and venus both view him better than haynes. I will go with the general view of the pros and my own rather than yours. Your argument is that haynes should play purely as we own him...notice you couldnt argue he was better.Seriously you must have something in your eyes.
We aren't saying Haynes is a word beating left back, but you cannot seriously state page is that much better than him.
Haynes it's our own player which in my eyes makes him the Number one choice in that position at this Club, until, a player oust him by being a better player, and in a loaned player, I would expect him to be considerably better to must him ..
No way is page considerably better than Haynes, if you think that then you're talking garbage
Look back through the player ratings this season and see how many posters note page as not as good as Haynes.
We all talk about destroying youngsters, and how managers should be protecting them, well Fuck me, Haynes confidence must be bottom of the barrel with the way tm has treated him.
These 2 should be contesting the spot, instead Haynes sits in the stands scratching his head
We might need to understand Page's term and conditions of his loan contract before speculateI look forward to you reeling off the list of games where haynes has been above average. More than 1 manager hasnt rated haynes yet page is highly rated at west ham and both mowbray and venus both view him better than haynes. I will go with the general view of the pros and my own rather than yours. Your argument is that haynes should play purely as we own him...notice you couldnt argue he was better.
interesting you will choose an untested premier league youthy over a tested cov playerI look forward to you reeling off the list of games where haynes has been above average. More than 1 manager hasnt rated haynes yet page is highly rated at west ham and both mowbray and venus both view him better than haynes. I will go with the general view of the pros and my own rather than yours. Your argument is that haynes should play purely as we own him...notice you couldnt argue he was better.
I didnt say there was an argument i asked why people rate a clearly average at best footballer over one who has been involved with a premier league first team. You have no answers other than we own him. They are not on a par and if you genuinely think they are then i despair.interesting you will choose an untested premier league youthy over a tested cov player
especially the dull start this guy has had here
ive stated theyre pretty much on a par, which in turn suggests to me that we should play our own
your views appear to be in the minority on this forum, and this forum is where most of us find our only comparison
there was never an argument started over who was better, but seeing as you like to make up facts of your own, please enjoy your fictional self gratification
I didnt say there was an argument i asked why people rate a clearly average at best footballer over one who has been involved with a premier league first team. You have no answers other than we own him. They are not on a par and if you genuinely think they are then i despair.
I must agree. I've not seen anything in page to say he is any better than Haynes, I also don't think sterry is that much better than DKE either. If we aren't mounting a promotion charge and its another year of development, why develop other clubs players ahead of developing your own. It would be fair enough if they were head and shoulders above them like Armstrong and Murphy were. I can only assume Haynes will be culled when his contract runs out.the difference between the two players isn't significant enough to warrant playing Page over Haynes.
A loan player should bring about a big improvement in the team to warrant his place, I don't see it with Page and neither do many others.
Then reread the threadI didnt say there was an argument i asked why people rate a clearly average at best footballer over one who has been involved with a premier league first team. You have no answers other than we own him. They are not on a par and if you genuinely think they are then i despair.
To be fair loan players are here for there own profile development, all they are concerned about is if they play every week and chalk up enough appearances for there cv, im sure they dont care about the club as much as one our players or have an affinity fair enough but if were not getting promoted and just looking to hang on play haynes and the rest of our kids develop them first! its like fostering some kid feeding it looking after it and abandoning starving your own kids, makes you wonder whats going on, im sure venus will sort it out if he gets the job.I must agree. I've not seen anything in page to say he is any better than Haynes, I also don't think sterry is that much better than DKE either. If we aren't mounting a promotion charge and its another year of development, why develop other clubs players ahead of developing your own. It would be fair enough if they were head and shoulders above them like Armstrong and Murphy were. I can only assume Haynes will be culled when his contract runs out.
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
This statement is completely redundant. Reece Brown is probably the worst Centre Back I've seen through the years at Coventry and was involved at Manchester United and is now making fleeting appearances for league one clubs every now and then. Stephen O'Halloran was at a Villa side as good as the current West Ham squad and now plays for Salford City... the list would be endless. Just because you are involved in a youth set up at a Premier League club it doesnt make you decent. Allsop is still on the books at Bournemouth and is absolutely no better than what we have available to us.I didnt say there was an argument i asked why people rate a clearly average at best footballer over one who has been involved with a premier league first team. You have no answers other than we own him. They are not on a par and if you genuinely think they are then i despair.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?