Player Ratings (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Collins - 2
MVE - 4
Lati- 5
Kitching- 5
Bidwell - 5
Allen - 5
Grimes - 5
Saka - 5
Rudi - 5
Haji - 4
Simms - 2
subs - cant be arsed
fucking wank , the lot of them
MVE - 4
Lati- 5
Kitching- 5
Bidwell - 5
Allen - 5
Grimes - 5
Saka - 5
Rudi - 5
Haji - 4
Simms - 2
subs - cant be arsed
fucking wank , the lot of them
Nick
Administrator
Simms wasn't worse than mve.
Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Wouldnt even give anyone above a 4.
Players for the majority struggle with a physical battle. Set up wrong with Allen in midfield imo.
Players for the majority struggle with a physical battle. Set up wrong with Allen in midfield imo.
skyblue025
Well-Known Member
Dogshit. Not 1 player above a 5 and that’s being generous. Special mention to how bad Collins, MVE and Simms were.
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
MVE has done well to keep up his performances ( until today ) till now, mistake for the goal yes, but could pass and control a football to one of his team mates , Simms cant even do that. Him and Collins are stealing a living as professional footballers
Jamesimus
Well-Known Member
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
About right , maybe knock a point off Bidwell and Allen
Essexrobbie
Well-Known Member
If Allen had made a meal of that awful challenge the game would have been completely different. Springing up the way he did gave the ref the excuse he wanted not to send him off. All turned in that mad 10 seconds.
They’re generous
Collins - 3 Distribution is good but at fault for the goals. No escape from that as a goalkeeper.
MVE - 4. Not used to being challenged, especially with pace, as Bundu did, and he no answer to it.
Lati- 4 Out muscled and out fought
Kitching- 5 Thought he did okay. Seemed up for competing but couldn’t carry everyone else at the back
Bidwell - 3. Too slow and one cross apart (I think) offered no threat going forward
Allen - 4. No lack of effort but didn’t have the presence today
Grimes - 5. He gets and keeps possession of the ball but nothing positive happened from it. Just one side to the other most of the time when we needed to get it forward quickly. We weren’t protecting a lead, we were losing!
Saka - 2. Very poor. I’d forgotten he was still on the pitch until he had that kick out at their player on the touch line
Rudi - 5 He never stopped trying but the quality we’ve come to expect from him wasn’t there. Lots of opportunities to cross the ball weren’t taken
Haji - 4. He scored but very poor, epitomized by falling over his own feet and that weak shot in the second half. Defeated body language too early in the game
Simms - 3. Poor as Haji without the plus of scoring
Subs - Da Silva looked like he wanted to change things so credit to him for that. The others didn’t affect the game at all
MVE - 4. Not used to being challenged, especially with pace, as Bundu did, and he no answer to it.
Lati- 4 Out muscled and out fought
Kitching- 5 Thought he did okay. Seemed up for competing but couldn’t carry everyone else at the back
Bidwell - 3. Too slow and one cross apart (I think) offered no threat going forward
Allen - 4. No lack of effort but didn’t have the presence today
Grimes - 5. He gets and keeps possession of the ball but nothing positive happened from it. Just one side to the other most of the time when we needed to get it forward quickly. We weren’t protecting a lead, we were losing!
Saka - 2. Very poor. I’d forgotten he was still on the pitch until he had that kick out at their player on the touch line
Rudi - 5 He never stopped trying but the quality we’ve come to expect from him wasn’t there. Lots of opportunities to cross the ball weren’t taken
Haji - 4. He scored but very poor, epitomized by falling over his own feet and that weak shot in the second half. Defeated body language too early in the game
Simms - 3. Poor as Haji without the plus of scoring
Subs - Da Silva looked like he wanted to change things so credit to him for that. The others didn’t affect the game at all
lord_garrincha
Well-Known Member
Struggling to see what role Saka plays... comes in & lets Rudoni play on the right.
Obviously team orders, but he has looked lost for a while now.
Obviously team orders, but he has looked lost for a while now.
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
I’d be going with 1 for Collins. His job is to stop goals which he singularly fails to do.
4,for Simms, Lati, MVE and Bidwell and 5 for the rest.
4,for Simms, Lati, MVE and Bidwell and 5 for the rest.
Torquay Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Wright was bloody awful today
Otis
Well-Known Member
Yeah, I thought Grimes did okay
Not Allen though. He deserves a 5 the same as the rest of them
Nick
Administrator
It's weird that people didn't even seem to notice
clint van damme
Well-Known Member
If Wilson doesn't play Saturday he needs to change his CV/LinkedIn etc from 'professional footballer' to 'someone who hangs around with professional footballers'.
CovveeBreak
Well-Known Member
Not even worth the energy rating the players after that sadly, top to bottom terrible. Will say a few things:
- If I was looking for any positives, Lati and Kitching were the most progressive people on the pitch. Lati with some wonderful long ball distribution and Kitching trying to run forward a lot.
- Maybe a bit controversial at least for the former, but if we can get our money back and then some on Wright and Simms in summer I'd probably take it. I love both of them when they're on it. But Wright is feeling "all talent-no fight", and Simms is "all fight-low talent". Combined nowhere near clinical enough on a consistent basis.
- If we don't find decent cover/competition for Dovin, we are destined for yet another "Coventry City slow start to the season".
- If I was looking for any positives, Lati and Kitching were the most progressive people on the pitch. Lati with some wonderful long ball distribution and Kitching trying to run forward a lot.
- Maybe a bit controversial at least for the former, but if we can get our money back and then some on Wright and Simms in summer I'd probably take it. I love both of them when they're on it. But Wright is feeling "all talent-no fight", and Simms is "all fight-low talent". Combined nowhere near clinical enough on a consistent basis.
- If we don't find decent cover/competition for Dovin, we are destined for yet another "Coventry City slow start to the season".
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Simms shows no fight at all
CovveeBreak
Well-Known Member
He does but het gets knackered after about 48 minutes
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He is passive
hinckley cov
Well-Known Member
That wasn’t Collins worst game he’s crap in nearly all games he plays in, the bloke should never of ever become a professional goalkeeper he simply isn’t good enough he’s stealing a living .
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
He has been largely excellent and playing 90 minutes most weeks, but yes today he was honking. Our only option there though
Based on what I saw.
Collins - 2. Shambolic
MVE - 3. Very poor today but has been o/s all season
Bidwell - 3. Very poor
Lati/Kitching - both 5’s. Battled
Grimes - 5. Far too deep whole game
Allen - 4. Ineffective, offered little
Rudoni - 5. Nothing came off
Saka - 2. Wore his cloak of invisibility well today
Simms - 3. No service and what little he got he didn’t do anything with
Wright - 2. Waste of the shirt today. Not even the tap in redeems that woeful showing
subs: only JDS had any positive impact
FL. Didn’t read the script today. Easy in hindsight. Patterns didnt create any overlaps/overloads or space in behind. Too slow and ponderous of movement, nobody trying to beat their man and bring them out of their very low block.
hats off to Plymouth who followed their game plan to the letter and got a thoroughly deserved victory.
PS: definitely a red card in my view.
Only caught part of FL post match but I’m sensing/expecting they will be getting a rocket and a few changes for Luton.
Collins - 2. Shambolic
MVE - 3. Very poor today but has been o/s all season
Bidwell - 3. Very poor
Lati/Kitching - both 5’s. Battled
Grimes - 5. Far too deep whole game
Allen - 4. Ineffective, offered little
Rudoni - 5. Nothing came off
Saka - 2. Wore his cloak of invisibility well today
Simms - 3. No service and what little he got he didn’t do anything with
Wright - 2. Waste of the shirt today. Not even the tap in redeems that woeful showing
subs: only JDS had any positive impact
FL. Didn’t read the script today. Easy in hindsight. Patterns didnt create any overlaps/overloads or space in behind. Too slow and ponderous of movement, nobody trying to beat their man and bring them out of their very low block.
hats off to Plymouth who followed their game plan to the letter and got a thoroughly deserved victory.
PS: definitely a red card in my view.
Only caught part of FL post match but I’m sensing/expecting they will be getting a rocket and a few changes for Luton.