Robins era best signing (1 Viewer)

Forums New posts
pipkin73

pipkin73

Well-Known Member
slowpoke said:
I think that is forgotten where we could have been but for that we squeezed out of division 2 sold McNulty for big bucks for us and used a lot of it to help create what we have now and where we are. Our owner wouldn’t have given a shit where we might have been, don’t forget that.
Click to expand...
Apart from the owner bit agree 100% not getting in to that conversation.
 
KG7

KG7

Well-Known Member
Bayliss and Shipley weren’t signings though…

And Bayliss was absolutely key in getting us out of league two. He basically gave us the thrust we were missing after Jones got injured, without him, McNulty and Doyle we may never have got up that year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
pipkin73

pipkin73

Well-Known Member
KG7 said:
Bayliss and Shipley weren’t signings though…

And Bayliss was absolutely key in getting us out of league two. He basically gave us the thrust we were missing after Jones got injured, without him, McNulty and Doyle we may never have got up that year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
À couple of you are saying Baylis done well (rember no one mentioned him till I did) if he done better than I remember then great, hope he gets it back and has a brilliant career.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KG7
KG7

KG7

Well-Known Member
pipkin73 said:
À couple of you are saying Baylis done well (rember no one mentioned him till I did) if he done better than I remember then great, hope he gets it back and has a brilliant career.
Click to expand...

I would def have mentioned him as a key player, but the thread is about signings, so I didn’t.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Londonccfcfan

Londonccfcfan

Well-Known Member
I think it can be argued Grimmer had as much or more influence than Bayliss. When you consider he played most games And he was a big upgrade on previous Right backs.
 
higgs

higgs

Well-Known Member
,Doyle with his winning mentality for me was key in stopping our slide. He was a leader on and off the pitch the passion he showed rubbed off on others. You could see what it meant to him getting promoted. He hadn't the legs for league 1 the next season

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: ptr
P

play_in_skyblue_stripes

Well-Known Member
Different era slightly but Did MR sign Eddie Mcgoldrick? If only we had kept him?

Said this many times Michael Doyle was truly invaluable. Let's hope however it turns out the new Swedish wondorboy Viktor is the best signing.
 
KG7

KG7

Well-Known Member
Londonccfcfan said:
I think it can be argued Grimmer had as much or more influence than Bayliss. When you consider he played most games And he was a big upgrade on previous Right backs.
Click to expand...

Grimmer was poor IMO. Couldn’t pass and shirked his tackles.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
S

Skybluebeliever

Well-Known Member
Kelly not for what he has done on the pitch but what he has done off it , MR relies on him a lot to keep the unit tight and be his voice in the dressing room with fadz as his number two , I’m afraid Doyle was fantastic on the pitch a leader etc but was not as great in the dressing room etc as Kelly has been
 
usskyblue

usskyblue

Well-Known Member
KG7 said:
Grimmer was poor IMO. Couldn’t pass and shirked his tackles.
Click to expand...

Yeah m8 … but

3248.jpg


Yz9zH0epaGqrCGVQ1XR2sYXyvrhtvJfeqtGVqgOQOi0RP3SnZsO5Pur_h4zcycID1JTNTn0
 
P

ptr

Well-Known Member
A very good question and I wouldn’t argue with any of those on the list being named as the best signing.

I will go with Kelly/Doyle. For the first time in years, we actually controlled a game from the midfield. They added bite and let the better players around them play. Their experience started the fight back that gives us the platform we play at today.
 
Mr Panda

Mr Panda

Well-Known Member
Kelly or Hyam for me due to their abilities they have carried forward to this level. My argument in another thread is that Kelly is coming to a bit of a conclusion with regards to his on field abilities. Hyam I think can be a success at this level so he's my pick

League Two > Championship and still a regular is Football Manager stuff.
 
rob9872

rob9872

Well-Known Member
Skybluebeliever said:
Kelly not for what he has done on the pitch but what he has done off it , MR relies on him a lot to keep the unit tight and be his voice in the dressing room with fadz as his number two , I’m afraid Doyle was fantastic on the pitch a leader etc but was not as great in the dressing room etc as Kelly has been
Click to expand...
Wtf‽??? Doyle was pivotal to that dressing room. He was also influential to the young lads and the reason we got the other pompey boys in.
 
lordy_87

lordy_87

Well-Known Member
So far McNulty IMO. If not for his goals that season we wouldn't be where we are now. Not the best player he signed for us, or most valuable sale but the most important individual by far.
 
COV

COV

Well-Known Member
rob9872 said:
Wtf‽??? Doyle was pivotal to that dressing room. He was also influential to the young lads and the reason we got the other pompey boys in.
Click to expand...

Doyle was to us what Vinnie Jones was to Leeds- someone to come in for one season in a lower & very tough division purely to help get us out of that divison- by galvanising, cajoling, encouraging, fighting and in doing so giving more talented but younger & more ‘fragile’ players room to play. Then when we went up he was moved on as he wouldn’t be suitable. A very smart signing & exactly what was needed for that season- but not sure you can say he was the best.
 
Tea & Busquets

Tea & Busquets

Well-Known Member
Has to be O’Hare for me, valid reasons for most of the other shouts, but to bring in a player of that calibre for free? that’s probably at least £8m profit if we were to sell him NOW. That amount of money is pretty good at just about any level let alone Championship. And we can already see how big of an impact he makes when he plays with the team.
 
rob9872

rob9872

Well-Known Member
COV said:
Doyle was to us what Vinnie Jones was to Leeds- someone to come in for one season in a lower & very tough division purely to help get us out of that divison- by galvanising, cajoling, encouraging, fighting and in doing so giving more talented but younger & more ‘fragile’ players room to play. Then when we went up he was moved on as he wouldn’t be suitable. A very smart signing & exactly what was needed for that season- but not sure you can say he was the best.
Click to expand...
You've misunderstood my response which was about him not helping off the pitch and not about being the best or otherwise.
 
COV

COV

Well-Known Member
rob9872 said:
You've misunderstood my response which was about him not helping off the pitch and not about being the best or otherwise.
Click to expand...

not at all, if anything I’m agreeing. Exactly what was needed to get out of a very physical, tough League. I just wouldn’t put him as MR’s best signing, but he was perfect for what we needed right then.
 
Londonccfcfan

Londonccfcfan

Well-Known Member
COV said:
Doyle was to us what Vinnie Jones was to Leeds- someone to come in for one season in a lower & very tough division purely to help get us out of that divison- by galvanising, cajoling, encouraging, fighting and in doing so giving more talented but younger & more ‘fragile’ players room to play. Then when we went up he was moved on as he wouldn’t be suitable. A very smart signing & exactly what was needed for that season- but not sure you can say he was the best.
Click to expand...

He was that steel missing from previous seasons. Remember how he got a Swindon player sent off at their place. He may have grabbed a goal there too. Think he grabbed his bollocks lol or something stupid like that. He man managed the refs too. He was the statement signing and probably the most important signing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Top