Scg (4 Viewers)

[Steve.B50]

But this isn't minutes, its an Election Result. Last time I checked, the club was in Coventry, not North Korea!

Are the SCG accountable to supporters or not? If "yes" then give us the information in a timely fashion. If "no" then all pack it in and don't waste your time and our expectations. Perhaps you'd pass those thoughts onto the Chair and Vice-Chair, whoever he/she may be.

I will ask the Chairperson again why we cannot announce who the Vice Chair is as this is all a little silly.

 

---

[Steve.B50]

Vice-chair also becomes chair-elect for following year. Both Chair & vice-chair attend club Board Meetings I believe, to represent supporters interests.
I would say that it is of interest to fans who holds those positions ... but maybe I'm wrong.

The new vice chair of the SCG is Sandra Garlick.

 

[WestEndAgro]

The new vice chair of the SCG is Sandra Garlick.

Shit storm heading in your direction!

 

[Terry Gibson's perm]

The new vice chair of the SCG is Sandra Garlick.

Log out Steve save yourself

 

[lamtara2006]

Shit storm heading in your direction!

Not Steve's fault, he stood against Ms Garlick. How can the SCG reps choose a Vice Chair who has attended less than 50% of the meetings since she became a "regular member" over someone who has only missed 1 meeting in the same period? In that time Sandra has made just 2 recorded contributions to discussions while Steve is actively involved on a regular basis.

This means no disrespect to Sandra: I have found her to be personable and professional on the two occasions we have met. But she is hardly "in touch" with the vast majority of supporters in my view.

 

[Nick]

The new vice chair of the SCG is Sandra Garlick.

If true I am a bit confused, was she even part of the SCG to be voted?

That is a bit strange.

Surely no rule in asking each person who they voted for off the record, if the majority don't say here then....

Surely people must have known who was standing to know the options to vote?

 

[Grendel]

Does she attend Wasps matches?

 

[CJ_covblaze]

Does she attend Wasps matches?

I believe so. Tbf is that relevant?

 

[Terry Gibson's perm]

If true I am a bit confused, was she even part of the SCG to be voted?

That is a bit strange.

Surely no rule in asking each person who they voted for off the record, if the majority don't say here then....

Surely people must have known who was standing to know the options to vote?

Did she not transfer across from another group I forget we have so many, if it is true Steve stood against her and lost it shows what a load of shit that group is and should be dispanded.

 

[Nick]

Was the vote fixed then?

Surely if she got 11 votes, those 11 were probably from a range of things rather than all SISU lovers? I could understand if it was 1 or 2. Just a bit baffled what those 11 know about her that we don;t.

Bit baffled about it.

Also, why does a Vice Chairperson automatically become chairperson?

 

[CJ_covblaze]

Did she not transfer across from another group I forget we have so many, if it is true Steve stood against her and lost it shows what a load of shit that group is and should be dispanded.

He did stand and was the only other candidate. 23 members were eligible. 5 for Steve, 11 for Sandra.

 

[Nick]

He did stand and was the only other candidate. 23 members were eligible. 5 for Steve, 11 for Sandra.

Who could have voted?

 

[wingy]

He did stand and was the only other candidate. 23 members were eligible. 5 for Steve, 11 for Sandra.

Were there 7 abstentions or just club personnel not permitted a vote?

 

[CJ_covblaze]

Were there 7 abstentions or just club personnel not permitted a vote?

7 didn't vote. Not sure as to why that was.

 

[CJ_covblaze]

Who could have voted?

I'll ask to see if there can be an up to date list put on the club site and who they represent.

 

[Nick]

But it was a fair vote?

 

[Steve.B50]

But it was a fair vote?

Yes Nick, it was fair and democratic. Most of those who could vote did so, no club personnel could vote.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

It's not like we can't abuse them without a thread, as this thread proves.

I'm with NW, just pick some names out a hat each month and run it like a focus group, this amateur Game of Thrones crap is just ridiculous.

What I don't understand, is that to a degree the chair should be a club rep, who drives the questions forward to find things out to help the club.

(I appreciate I'm treating this somewhat naively as a research exercise for the club to find things out, but if the group had any purpose, that'd be exactly what they'd be running it for!)

 

[Jack Griffin]

But it was a fair vote?

Was it a representative electorate?

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Loved this btw.

MG reported that the corporate service has been very poor recently e.g. wine being served in plastic beer mugs. There has been no draught beer in the Legends Lounge and the service on Boxing Day was very poor. There had also been rowdyism and a failure to observe dress requirements.

:claping hands:

 

[Nick]

Was it a representative electorate?

Hard to say without a full list of people

 

[Grendel]

What percentage of the trust membership voted the current chairman in?

 

[ccfctommy]

Surely it's a secret ballot?

 

[stupot07]

Feck me all this over a being a chair / vice chair.

At the end of the day, the chair is there to make sure the meeting and agenda items run to time, and be a facilitator of discussions.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

 

[CJ_covblaze]

What percentage of the trust membership voted the current chairman in?

Steve was voted on to the board like I was by the membership. Haven't received any complaints about the vote that made him Chair. A few months ago there was an opportunity for members to put themselves or others forward for election but we didn't receive a single nomination. Are you interested in joining the board? If you have anything worthwhile to add your nomination will be looked at like any other.

 

[wingy]

What percentage of the trust membership voted the current chairman in?

Think they only have two members?
I'm more interested why 7 appear to have abstained or not used their vote.
But In all honesty not that bothered by any of it.

 

[Grendel]

Steve was voted on to the board like I was by the membership. Haven't received any complaints about the vote that made him Chair. A few months ago there was an opportunity for members to put themselves or others forward for election but we didn't receive a single nomination. Are you interested in joining the board? If you have anything worthwhile to add your nomination will be looked at like any other.

My point is that no one gives a toss about either organisation and your post proves my point.

 

[Broken Hearted Sky Blue]

Steve was voted on to the board like I was by the membership. Haven't received any complaints about the vote that made him Chair. A few months ago there was an opportunity for members to put themselves or others forward for election but we didn't receive a single nomination. Are you interested in joining the board? If you have anything worthwhile to add your nomination will be looked at like any other.

Tell you what I propose Grendel it would be fun

 

[Jack Griffin]

My point is that no one gives a toss about either organisation and your post proves my point.

Sure, that's why there are over 130 posts (so far), you fecking idiot.

 

[Broken Hearted Sky Blue]

My point is that no one gives a toss about either organisation and your post proves my point.

Obviously you do considering the amount of times you post regarding the trust

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Tell you what I propose Grendel it would be fun

Oooh, I'd second him.

Be an incentive to turn up to a few more meetings, could be more fun than the football.

 

[Broken Hearted Sky Blue]

Oooh, I'd second him.

Be an incentive to turn up to a few more meetings, could be more fun than the football.

Thing is he turn up to the meetings and we'd find out he's actually Nick

 

[Nick]

Thing is he turn up to the meetings and we'd find out he's actually Nick

I don't have time to prove fools like you wrong with 1 account, let alone 2! :claping hands:

 

[Broken Hearted Sky Blue]

Thing is he turn up to the meetings and we'd find out he's actually Nick

Only joking Nick. Honest

 

[chiefdave]

Tell you what I propose Grendel it would be fun

In that case I propose Tony to join as well