Simple Question..... (1 Viewer)

[ms639]

Is our squad better now than it was when we were almost relegated again in 2014/15?

 

---

[blueflint]

no and i don't think it will be

 

[ClarkeZ]

Lee Burge
DF Jordan Willis
DF Danny Pugh
DF Andy Webster
DF Réda Johnson
MF Conor Thomas
MF John Fleck
MF Grant Ward (on loan
FW Nick Proschwitz (on loan
MF Danny Swanson (on loan
MF Jim O'Brien
FW Simeon Jackson
FW Dominic Samuel (on loan
MF Adam Barton
MF Sanmi Odelusi (on loan
DF Aaron Phillips
FW Frank Nouble (loaned
FW Marcus Tudgay
DF Aaron Martin (loaned from
FW Matthew Pennington (on loan
DF Ryan Haynes
MF Jack Finch
MF Ivor Lawton
DF Chris Stokes (on loan
MF James Maddison
MF George Thomas

FW Gary Madine (loaned
FW Josh McQuoid (loaned
MF Mohamed Coulibaly (loaned
GK Ryan Allsop (loaned
GK Jamie Jones (loaned
DF Jordan Clarke (loaned
DF Seb Hines (loaned

I think I'd prefer this squad to what we have right now.

 

[FRY-CCFC]

Yes it is and we have a better manager.

That squad is fucking atrocious.

 

[Pipehitterz]

DF Jordan Willis
MF John fleck
MF Jim O'Brien
FW Dominic Samuel (on loan
DF Aaron Martin (loaned from
FW Matthew Pennington
.

IMO
These were the only ones of credit for that season. And I'm being nice regarding O'Brien and Stokes, Stokes didn't ' get it ' till later in the season
Samuel was only with us for a short while so too can be taken out.

The rest were either too young and out of their depth
Or just plain old fucking shit.

Way too early to judge this squad

 

[Earlsdon_Skyblue1]

Someone without a boss looking over their shoulder would have to get the two squads listed in here so we can compare them. It's probably comparable though?

 

[Earlsdon_Skyblue1]

Lee Burge
DF Jordan Willis
DF Danny Pugh
DF Andy Webster
DF Réda Johnson
MF Conor Thomas
MF John Fleck
MF Grant Ward (on loan
FW Nick Proschwitz (on loan
MF Danny Swanson (on loan
MF Jim O'Brien
FW Simeon Jackson
FW Dominic Samuel (on loan
MF Adam Barton
MF Sanmi Odelusi (on loan
DF Aaron Phillips
FW Frank Nouble (loaned
FW Marcus Tudgay
DF Aaron Martin (loaned from
FW Matthew Pennington (on loan
DF Ryan Haynes
MF Jack Finch
MF Ivor Lawton
DF Chris Stokes (on loan
MF James Maddison
MF George Thomas

FW Gary Madine (loaned
FW Josh McQuoid (loaned
MF Mohamed Coulibaly (loaned
GK Ryan Allsop (loaned
GK Jamie Jones (loaned
DF Jordan Clarke (loaned
DF Seb Hines (loaned

I think I'd prefer this squad to what we have right now.

How many of those players would get into our starting XI now?

Probably at least 5 or 6. From that I'd say overall the team then is pretty similar to the one we have now, if not slightly better.

 

[SBAndy]

Allsop - RCC
Willis - Willis
Webster - Ricketts
Johnson - Turnbull
Clarke - DKE
Pugh - Page
Thomas - McCann
Fleck - Stevenson
O'Brien - Gadzhev
McQuoid - Reid
Tudgay - Agyei

That's the starting lineup vs Bradford first day of 2014/15 against the starting lineup vs Bradford last weekend.

 

[Pipehitterz]

Allsop - RCC
Willis - Willis
Webster - Ricketts
Johnson - Turnbull
Clarke - DKE
Pugh - Page
Thomas - McCann
Fleck - Stevenson
O'Brien - Gadzhev
McQuoid - Reid
Tudgay - Agyei

That's the starting lineup vs Bradford first day of 2014/15 against the starting lineup vs Bradford last weekend.

That's the match ups I'm discussion if being realistic.
The rest I would say much for much ness

That said, hoping turnbull will have a better City career.

 

[shelby76]

Fucking hell we need to sign Dr who.

 

[Gazolba]

Its not just a question of whether we are better or not but also are the other teams in the league better or not?

 

[pastythegreat]

Lee Burge
DF Jordan Willis
DF Danny Pugh
DF Andy Webster
DF Réda Johnson
MF Conor Thomas
MF John Fleck
MF Grant Ward (on loan
FW Nick Proschwitz (on loan
MF Danny Swanson (on loan
MF Jim O'Brien
FW Simeon Jackson
FW Dominic Samuel (on loan
MF Adam Barton
MF Sanmi Odelusi (on loan
DF Aaron Phillips
FW Frank Nouble (loaned
FW Marcus Tudgay
DF Aaron Martin (loaned from
FW Matthew Pennington (on loan
DF Ryan Haynes
MF Jack Finch
MF Ivor Lawton
DF Chris Stokes (on loan
MF James Maddison
MF George Thomas

FW Gary Madine (loaned
FW Josh McQuoid (loaned
MF Mohamed Coulibaly (loaned
GK Ryan Allsop (loaned
GK Jamie Jones (loaned
DF Jordan Clarke (loaned
DF Seb Hines (loaned

I think I'd prefer this squad to what we have right now.

The only player I would take from that squad is Dom Sam. At a push Reda Johnson on a payp deal.

Sent from my SM-G928F using Tapatalk

 

[ccfcway]

Allsop - RCC - BETTER NOW
Willis - Willis - SAME
Webster - Ricketts - BETER NOW
Johnson - Turnbull - TBC
Clarke - DKE - TBC
Pugh - Page - TBC
Thomas - McCann - BETTER NOW
Fleck - Stevenson - NOT AS GOOD (at the moment)
O'Brien - Gadzhev - NOT AS GOOD (at the moment)
McQuoid - Reid - TBC
Tudgay - Agyei - BETTER NOW


Clearly my opinion, but 4 better now and only 2 not as good today. The rest I would sit on the fence with at the moment