Match Thread West Bromwich Albion - Coventry City Match Thread - Friday 1st Mar (3 Viewers)

[Deleted member 9744]

surely robins cant go out in summer and buy another £9m striker?

No but he should have been able to bring a loan like Kieffer Moore in in January.

 

---

[2024/25 League 1 Champs?]

Why would you keep Palmer? He's on big wages and delivers very very little for it

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

I think it’s just a consistency thing, but there’s a player in there definitely - wages aside I do think he’s a good squad player

I don’t know what he’s earning, and it might be he’s overpaid, but he was one of the few to come out of this evening with credit in my opinion

 

[SkyblueDad]

Agree completely. Dasilva is the worst left wingback we have had in about 5 years. Binks isn't a defender in a million years. Huge step down from Kitching.

More rubbish Binks excellent again

 

[Nick]

No, but I'd like to treat them like we can beat them. We started tonight like we were resigned to losing the game.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Exactly!

Even at 2-1 we were still resigned to losing it. Didn't even try and go for it.

 

[SeaSeeEffCee]

I am back to being very concerned about Simms and Wright. For the money spent they simply do not look like good enough footballers.

 

[Sick Boy]

Continuing to play Wilson and JDS and a £4m CB being deemed not good enough is just odd.

 

[Major Tom]

The problem is the defence

we were so solid

then robins tinkers

he’s to blame as I feel like he’s doing weird stuff

Is Robins a better manager under pressure with a smaller squad

 

[Matt smith]

I am back to being very concerned about Simms and Wright. For the money spent they simply do not look like good enough footballers.

Yeah they are both no where near what we paid

 

[2024/25 League 1 Champs?]

MVE?

why? Can you please explain what he has done? Did you not just see how badly he played?

I really want to ignore this, but I’ll simply say you’re entitled to your opinion my friend

 

[Cally Fedora]

To qualify there is no one who has done more for us than Robins and as far as I’m concerned he has a job for life. But I think he’s been guilty of overthinking selection in this congested period. We’ve surely established the following by now.
1) Kitching and Thomas are our best centre halves.
2) Wright is effective from the left
3) Simms can’t hold the ball up
4) Bidwell is our best lb.
But we’ve tinkered endlessly. I also think he’s made the mistake of overreacting to the Sakamoto injury by abandoning what is very obviously our best formation. Just play the next best player in Sakamoto’s position. Simms would be better there than CF. MVE could do a job. I wouldn’t go as far as Tavares. We’ve solved a lot of issues this year - only to revert to what caused us issues in the first place.

 

[Matt smith]

Is Robins a better manager under pressure with a smaller squad

No, we’ve got a small squad

he’s just doing odd stuff

What’s Collins done ffs

 

[Woolly68]

Well, having watched the Preston game at the CBS last Friday and comparing against the game tonight (watched on TV with a bottle of red) that was a better performance. That’s all I’m saying. Fact! Still not good enough though. Disappointed. We had quite a few opportunities. Close but no cigar. Went to west Brom last season and I think they were better then. Today could have been a point. Very frustrated.

 

[Nick]

Continuing to play Wilson and JDS and a £4m CB being deemed not good enough is just odd.

Exactly, especially after how long we chased him and let fadz go.

 

[shmmeee]

The problem is the defence

we were so solid

then robins tinkers

he’s to blame as I feel like he’s doing weird stuff

Why do you think he’s doing that?

 

[shmmeee]

Continuing to play Wilson and JDS and a £4m CB being deemed not good enough is just odd.

Don’t make me tap the sign

 

[hamertime]

We’re the Man Utd of the championship. With Southgate in charge.

 

[Great_Expectations]

3 play off rivals, we've played Norwich, Preston and West Brom and lost them all.

After having seasons where we played our own game and beat teams going for automatic promotion, we have meekly surrendered to inferior teams going to the play offs, that's on the manager.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Not sure it’s on MR.

He has his faults and he’s tinkered a lot and made the occasional odd decision, but not sure he can be blamed for players making poor decisions, losing any sense of belief and having the resilience of tissue paper.

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Why do you think he’s doing that?

He was forced to by the red cards but swapping Collins for Wilson has done nothing to stem the tide

 

[Nick]

Don’t make me tap the sign

What sign?

 

[bigfatronssba]

Why do you think he’s doing that?

He can't seem to settle on a team.

Why do we keep changing the starting line up depending on the opposition? We're supposed to be a decent team in this division. We should know our best 11, and the opposition should be changing theirs to play us

 

[shmmeee]

What sign?

The “The best manager we’ve had in a generation doesn’t suddenly go mental and drop players for no reason and every time you think he does it turns out it was for good reason” sign.

 

[Hobo]

Simms and Wright are not top 6 forwards in the division - they are the flagship signings and whatever the excuses they are poor and underachieving - they need to look at themselves and do better

But against Preston and WBA the defence has given away soft early goals and then followed it up with another. Poor defending have allowed those two games to just unravel.

 

[Matt smith]

Why do you think he’s doing that?

God knows mate

we went on that great run because we had consistency selection

 

[JohnWH]

Oh well.
Disappointing, disjointed first half. First goal from them was a bit WTF but there's mention it was an unbeatable shot so would like to see replays again. I cannot feel that the defense shut off during their second goal. Much much better second half, but not enough to carry to a draw obviously. Too much shooting from outside the box that never really had a chance. The team has just been so off its stride for last month, which is disappointing knowing they can look great otherwise.

Still don't have my pork pie but it's a fish dinner anyway soon.

 

[shmmeee]

He can't seem to settle on a team.

Why do we keep changing the starting line up depending on the opposition? We're supposed to be a decent team in this division. We should know our best 11, and the opposition should be changing theirs to play us

Doesn’t explain why though. Why do you think we don’t play the same XI each week?

 

[Nick]

He was forced to by the red cards but swapping Collins for Wilson has done nothing to stem the tide

Was forced by the suspension but didn't revert.

Funnily enough kitching got sent off just after he brought dasilva on for no reason....

 

[SkyBlue_Bear83]

I am back to being very concerned about Simms and Wright. For the money spent they simply do not look like good enough footballers.

I don't like to dig them out because of the price tags and Haji has done well out on the left wing and Simms had shown improvement over the last 8 weeks but for £11-12 million you would expect a little bit more and to be technically a lot better footballers

 

[Nick]

Doesn’t explain why though. Why do you think we don’t play the same XI each week?

It's clearly not illness.

 

[shmmeee]

God knows mate

we went on that great run because we had consistency selection

And then Sheaf and Saka got injured and illness went through the camp and MvE got knackered and O’Hare started dreaming about La Liga. Yet this all seems to be forgotten

 

[shmmeee]

It's clearly not illness.

What’s your theory? Some kind of mad cow disease? Robins evil twin?

 

[AFCCOVENTRY]

Robins saying we didn’t deserve it.

Robins has admitted he set the team up wrong.

 

[fernandopartridge]

Robins admitting he set the team up wrong

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

 

[hamertime]

I think Robins really hasn’t a clue and just throws darts at players pinned on his fence then goes with it.

 

[Matt smith]

At least robins is owning it

 

[Nick]

And then Sheaf and Saka got injured and illness went through the camp and MvE got knackered and O’Hare started dreaming about La Liga. Yet this all seems to be forgotten

You keep saying illness, has this illness been going on for weeks???