For some reason just remembered another random one. League Cup v Newcastle in 2008 at home. They were premier league at the time, had Owen on the bench and a starting 11 including Given, Milner, Coloccini, Butt, Gutierrez and Geremi! Absolutely battered us but we threw ourselves in front of basically everything.
2-1 down going into injury time when Gunnarsson launches one of those long throws into the box and Dann powers a header into the bottom corner to take it to extra time, cue pandemonium! Owen turned back the years in extra time and beat the offside trap to dink it over Marshall for 3-2. One of the best cup ties I've seen at the Ricoh, being 2-0 down to bring it back to 2-2 v premier league opposition and eventually lose to a great goal. I remember not even being that gutted as we left, knew it was a fair result and it had been a cracking game