You are Shaw: select your starting XI for Burton Albion match (1 Viewer)

[ampthill_sba]

I have finished my ranting about captain's professionalism, tactics of hoofball, the merits of the diamond formation and the humiliation of being 17th in div 3...and now for something completely different;

My predicted starting line up based on getting inside the mind of Shaw;

Dunne
Clarke
Edj
Cameron
Hussey
Baker
Barton
McSheffrey
Daniels
McGoldrick
McDonald

Well done to 'Kersleydigs' for being closet to predicting starting line up v Crewe. No-one predicted correctly due to the surprise inclusion of Browne.

 

---

[PVA]

Murphy

Christie
Wood
Malaga
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker
McSheffrey

mcGoldrick
Elliott


Note, this is my guess at what Shaw will go with, not my choice...

 

[Martin180]

-------------------Murphy --------------------

----------Malaga--Wood---Edje------------

Christie---Barton ----Jennings----Kilbane

--McGoldrick-----Cody-----Elliott

 

[Houchens Head]

None of 'em!

 

[Jonny]

Murphy

Hussey
Malaga
Edjenguele
Clarke

Baker
McSheffrey
Barton
Kilbane

MacDonald
McGoldrick

I'll call the score too, 2-0 to Cov!

 

[Dan Griffin]

Murphy
Christie Malaga Brown Edjenguele
Kilbane
Barton Baker
Mcsheffrey
Cody McGoldrick

1-2 burton win AET

 

[rswxite]

I reckon he'll rest a few so.....

Dunn
Christie
Malaga
Willis
Hussey
Daniels
McSheffrey
Baker
Barton
Ball
Mcgoldrick

Subs

Murphy
Wood
Edjenguele
Jennings
McDonald
Elliot
Brown

 

[LJC_CCFC]

433
Murphy

Christie
Malaga
Wood
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker

Macca left wing
Cody
McGoldrick right wing

 

[Lord_Nampil]

Murphy
Christie Malaga Brown Edjenguele
Kilbane
Barton Baker
Mcsheffrey
Cody McGoldrick

1-2 burton win AET

Not going to happen no extra time!!!

 

[Lord_Nampil]

-------------------Murphy --------------------

----------Malaga--Wood---Edje------------

Christie---Barton ----Jennings----Kilbane

--McGoldrick-----Cody-----Elliott

This system could work, we have the players to play it, has shaw got the ability to see this??? Humm

 

[ampthill_sba]

Not going to happen no extra time!!!

If its a draw do we get a replay at Burton then?

 

[Lord_Nampil]

If its a draw do we get a replay at Burton then?

Straight to pens after 90 mins if it's level!!!

 

[ampthill_sba]

Straight to pens after 90 mins if it's level!!!

Thank God!!

Do you also know the exact rule about how many first teamers etc we have to play?

 

[Lord_Nampil]

Thank God!!

Do you also know the exact rule about how many first teamers etc we have to play?

No lol, but we have a 30 man squad so I guess it will be used! IMO its a game we need to win!!!

 

[DD_Daphne]

We have to play at least 6 of the players that started yesterday...thems the rules!

 

[ampthill_sba]

No lol, but we have a 30 man squad so I guess it will be used! IMO its a game we need to win!!!

I agree; not for the glory that is the JPT but for players self belief as the 'not winning' in the league is starting to weigh down on the team...imo

 

[pusbccfc]

Dunn
Cyrus-Brown-Edje-Phillips

Barton-Jennings-Sheff

--------Baker

Elliott------McGoalDrought

 

[shmmeee]

Murphy
Clarke edge Malaga Hussey
Jennings
Barton Kilbane
Baker
McDonald McGoldrick

Not been good enough to rest players, and they don't deserve a rest.

 

[Jameswilliams7771989]

4-3-3

Dunn

Christie
Wood
Edjenguele
Clarke (he can't do a worse job than hussey surely at LB)

Baker
Jennings
Barton

Mcsheffrey
Macdonald
Mcgoldrick.

Note this is the team I'd like to see. Murphy
Doesn't patrol his area.
Mcsheffrey isn't a midfielder.
If we had a better left back solution. Id like to see Clarke in a more advanced role. As his attacking is better than most players we have. Him or christie anyway.
Sorry for the rant. Drop the diamond. Useless.

 

[ampthill_sba]

We have to play at least 6 of the players that started yesterday...thems the rules!

Post a link to a reference for this ruling please. I have seen that this is true for League Cup but uncertain about JPT.

 

[skybluesalex]

Dunn

Christie
Edjenguele
Malaga
Hussey

Baker
Barton
Kilbane
McSheffrey

Ball
RO'D

Bench

Burge
Wood
Henderson
Jennings
Roberts
Jeffers
McDonald

 

[davebart]

This system could work, we have the players to play it, has shaw got the ability to see this??? Humm

looks a bit dodgy down the left hand side defensively. does anyone play three at the back successfully?

I do not expect Murphy Jennings Kilbane or Cody to play.

 

[ampthill_sba]

433
Murphy

Christie
Malaga
Wood
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker

Macca left wing
Cody
McGoldrick right wing

Well done to LJC_CCFC for the closest prediction to the starting XI last night with 9/11 choices in keeping with Shaw's selection. Shaw picked Wood for Malaga and Kilbane for Barton.