An Appointment that has more Questions than Answers ! (7 Viewers)

[rupert_bear]

Think it's fair to say the appointment and speed of it surprised even shocked us all. Don't think for a minute it was a case of thank you and goodbye Mr Slade then a phone call saying hello Mr Robins fancy a job ! His sudden departure from the post in 2013 was just as much a surprise and shock. Amongst the reasons sited by MR at the time included not getting certain assurances by his bosses and lack of help from CCC, so what has changed ?
I never held anything against him jumping ship, was probably the only effective thing he could do against issues and more importantly Tim Fisher and Steve Waggott.
Fisher is still here recently. spouting cutting budgets and player sales, hardly encouragement for any new manager.
Issues with ccc affecting the club still there really but shifted from Council to primarily Wasps who won't talk due to JR2
Situation here potentially worse than 2013, probable relegation, imminent loss of training ground, loss of Acadamy cat 2, no home ground in less than 18 months, proposed further budget restraints, player sales maybe enforced and chief protagonist Tim Fisher still here and spouting.
So what has changed for MR to even consider a return ? What assurances has he had ? Does he know something we don't know ? Does he know Simon Jordan ? Yes there's more question than answers, at the moment.

 

---

[mark82]

Is he desperate for a job after failing in his last 2 posts?

 

[Flying Fokker]

I agree. Why return? Either he knows something is going to happen with new owners coming in or...? He has no love for the club although he could be a real favourite. I remember his walkout. I was annoyed he left because he was doing a good job. But I'm glad Robins is coming in. A glimmer of hope the owners are on the way out.

 

[better days]

Robins representative is one of the most well connected and respected men in football
It may well be part of other changes including perhaps owners
We can but hope but I suspect if so things will move fairly quickly

 

[edgy]

Clutching at straws gents. As people have said, he's since had two poor management spells and hasn't had a job since.
Probably needs to put food on the table.

 

[skybluetony176]

He's been out of work for over a year and has bills to pay. I can't see it being anymore complicated than that.

 

[Alan Dugdales Moustache]

No doubt wishful thinking will ensure that there will be a new wave of optimism that this signals that SISU might be selling. Lets not get carried away. Robins needs a job. The situation at Coventry is far worse than it was when he left. The problems still remain. If he comes here and revives us then the next worry will be whether the owners / Fisher will match his ambition. We all know the answer and we all know what that will mean. I would welcome Mark Robins and wish him well in his short time here .

 

[CovisGod]

I wonder how long he'll last with "Sky blue bloody running through his veins"

Before ditching us again if he gets us playing

 

[AlansEyes]

As has already been said, surely this is no more than an indication that Robins' own managerial stock has dropped since he left us. With failures at Huddersfield and Scunthorpe on his CV he isn't a very attractive proposition to many clubs, especially as when you look at this last four clubs, he left three of them with win percentages of around 30% (over 92, 68 and 71 games). Yes, he left us with around 50% win percentage but that was only over 33 games. So, I would say that needing a job to pay the bills would be the reason, rather than being made any wild promises by Fisher or a takeover being on the horizon.

Still, good appointment, I would say. On paper it looks better than giving it to Ricketts and hoping that he cuts it.

 

[Skyblueweeman]

People sounding like he's a pauper!

Listen, he's not set the world alight in his past two roles but would you go back to a club after what he said about Sky Blue blood, the council, the state of the club etc?

I just don't think you'd come back after those statements purely 'to put bread on the table'.

It's not like he'd be incapable of getting a job elsewhere.

All very strange...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Suffolk sky blues]

Give us a job.

 

[AFCCOVENTRY]

It's easy money for him. He's in a win win situation. When we get relegated it won't be his fault, if by a miracle we stay up he will be god. A guaranteed day out at Wembley.

As others have said he isn't a manager on the up anymore. He's been out of work for over a year. He couldn't cut it in the Championship and got sacked from a club in a L1 relegation fight.

I'm not looking into this anymore than he's out of work and Fisher needs a manager.

 

[better days]

Clutching at straws gents. As people have said, he's since had two poor management spells and hasn't had a job since.
Probably needs to put food on the table.

I suppose this is more likely
It's the false hope that destroys you....

 

[Voice_of_Reason]

My theory, for what it's worth, is that potential new owners are lined up who insisted Slade went and it was they who instigated Robbins return, not SISU. As many have said, something is going on, otherwise I doubt MR would have agreed to come back.

 

[italiahorse]

We can only dream

 

[Nick]

My theory, for what it's worth, is that potential new owners are lined up who insisted Slade went and it was they who instigated Robbins return, not SISU. As many have said, something is going on, otherwise I doubt MR would have agreed to come back.

Wasn't it new owners who insisted slade came?

 

[Terry Gibson's perm]

If Robins does come in Fisher and Venus have finally got one right, the shit I have watched since that clown has been in charge has left me flat but much happier this morning.

Time to change the signature at the bottom.

 

[Specs WT-R75]

As has already been said, surely this is no more than an indication that Robins' own managerial stock has dropped since he left us. With failures at Huddersfield and Scunthorpe on his CV he isn't a very attractive proposition to many clubs, especially as when you look at this last four clubs, he left three of them with win percentages of around 30% (over 92, 68 and 71 games). Yes, he left us with around 50% win percentage but that was only over 33 games. So, I would say that needing a job to pay the bills would be the reason, rather than being made any wild promises by Fisher or a takeover being on the horizon.

Still, good appointment, I would say. On paper it looks better than giving it to Ricketts and hoping that he cuts it.

30% win rate. Right now that seems like some sort of a demi-god...

All we need from here on is for every new manager to leave us better than they found us. We are starting from a low position, so with baby steps in theory it should not be impossible. Alas if he fails, in the words of Pvt Frazer... we're doomed!

 

[stevefloyd]

Wasn't it new owners who insisted slade came?

Yeah but now its new new owners

 

[Deleted member 5849]

He's been out of work for over a year and has bills to pay. I can't see it being anymore complicated than that.

Indeed. His stock was high last time he was with us, now it's low.

 

[Kingokings204]

Doesn't really wash for me about his stock his low and needs to put bread on the table. First of all I'm sure he is not short of a few bob surely? Don't know but would hardly think he is on the dole.

Secondly he could get a job with another side who isn't protesting every match and in complete free fall. Not to mention budgets cut every year and compared to 4 years ago when he was last here it's no comparison.

Now it could be as simple as he wants a job and loves football which is more plausible than needing a job. But still I guess his contract length my tell us a bit. 3 month contract and we know it's nothing give him 3 years and I would feel a bit more optimistic.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

Doesn't really wash for me about his stock his low

Are you suggesting after failures at Huddersfield and Scunthorpe that his stock is high?

 

[AlansEyes]

Doesn't really wash for me about his stock his low and needs to put bread on the table. First of all I'm sure he is not short of a few bob surely? Don't know but would hardly think he is on the dole.

Secondly he could get a job with another side who isn't protesting every match and in complete free fall. Not to mention budgets cut every year and compared to 4 years ago when he was last here it's no comparison.

Now it could be as simple as he wants a job and loves football which is more plausible than needing a job. But still I guess his contract length my tell us a bit. 3 month contract and we know it's nothing give him 3 years and I would feel a bit more optimistic.

I'm sure he has earned decent money across his career, but his playing days were before the big money came into the Premier League. I remember reading that Matt Le Tissier's biggest contract of his career was £3,500 basic wage. Good money for most, but I doubt Robins would have earned this, and he hasn't ever had a 'big' managerial job that would have earned him a fat contract. Failure at his last two clubs mean that League One clubs won't be putting him at the top of their wishlist and maybe he sees that by coming back here he has the chance to win a Cup right off the bat and boost his CV. He knows that we're already dead in the league, so he won't be blamed for taking us down and given the complete lack of success that we have had, if he brings us back up next season he'll be a hero. Plus, if he signs a three year contract and fails he'll probably get the boot after 1 year and get a nice big payout.

 

[rupert_bear]

Let's look at it another way, why has Fisher re-appointed him. MF has a track record of sticking his fingers up to Fisher and consequently Joy Sepalla and sisu and pissing off and I'm certain would do the same again doesn't need to spout from the roof tops about how bad it is working for these owners and Fisher. Holds a lot of good cards does MR now imo.

 

[Deleted member 5849]

why had Fisher re-appointed him.

Because he did a good job here, and pointed out the club needed more support from the council when he left?

 

[shmmeee]

Let's look at it another way, why had Fisher re-appointed him. He had a track record of sticking his fingers up to Fisher and consequently Joy Sepalla and sisu and pissing off don't need to spout from the roof tops about how bad it is working for these owners and Fisher

From the horses mouth:

“I spoke to the owner, I sought assurances and didn’t get any assurances from the owner of Coventry,” he said as he was unveiled today as the Terrier’s fifth manager in as many years.

“I absolutely wish them all the best, they work their socks off and as I’ve said before that club needs support from Coventry City Council .

“That led to a decision to want to speak with Huddersfield and that’s how the decision has been arrived at.”

Hardly sticking his fingers up.

 

[Senior Vick from Alicante]

Its irelavant who is the manager at the club. All any one can do is stabalise and fire fight, to build the club you need a complete change of current culture. This can only be achieved by regime change, if you destroy your infrastructure to get a better product i can kind of understand, we have done it to service debts to our owners. The club is eating itself from the inside out, I wish Robinson good luck but the club is counting on fan loyalty to keep trading at the minute whilst Fisherbtreats us all as muppets.

 

[CovBurty]

Sisu are not selling the club. Robins has no job. Slade was obviously useless with this squad. Robins is set to find out why Slade was so pants. So we go into div2 with a better chance of fighting back. Until Robins see next seasons budget, then also fails. See it coming.

 

[Kingokings204]

Are you suggesting after failures at Huddersfield and Scunthorpe that his stock is high?

No but I am suggesting he could get a mid to lower table league 1 club. Easily.

 

[Warwickhunt]

Think it's fair to say the appointment and speed of it surprised even shocked us all. Don't think for a minute it was a case of thank you and goodbye Mr Slade then a phone call saying hello Mr Robins fancy a job ! His sudden departure from the post in 2013 was just as much a surprise and shock. Amongst the reasons sited by MR at the time included not getting certain assurances by his bosses and lack of help from CCC, so what has changed ?
I never held anything against him jumping ship, was probably the only effective thing he could do against issues and more importantly Tim Fisher and Steve Waggott.
Fisher is still here recently. spouting cutting budgets and player sales, hardly encouragement for any new manager.
Issues with ccc affecting the club still there really but shifted from Council to primarily Wasps who won't talk due to JR2
Situation here potentially worse than 2013, probable relegation, imminent loss of training ground, loss of Acadamy cat 2, no home ground in less than 18 months, proposed further budget restraints, player sales maybe enforced and chief protagonist Tim Fisher still here and spouting.
So what has changed for MR to even consider a return ? What assurances has he had ? Does he know something we don't know ? Does he know Simon Jordan ? Yes there's more question than answers, at the moment.

Are we relocating and sharing the ground with Barnsley where Robins lives do you think?

 

[st john]

Didn't sell players in January despite 3 offers for Stevenson, no need to sack Slade at this point, but anyway could have appointed Ricketts and saved money. It could not have been easy for Robins to accept after how he left. All this adds up to something more IMO

 

[Edgey95]

Why would you return if the reason you left was due to uncertainty from the owners? Or am i mistaken on why he left

 

[Esoterica]

I get the 'his stock is low now' argument but do people think he'd wouldn't get a job in League 2 or at another bottom end league 1 side? I think it's all about his wife.

Tim: Hi Mark, it's Tim, sorry to phone you so late on a Sunday but we'd reeeally like you to come back and manage the City again.
Mark: Hmmmm, after last time?! Well, what's the budget?
Tim: Well you've got 40% of the budget you had last time, and as we're all but relegated it'll get slashed further in the summer. Plus you won't get any of it to spend til near the end of the summer transfer window so you'll be mostly relying on the kids.
Mark: Riiiight. And what about all the off the field bollocks?
Tim: *cough* Well, funny you should ask but we're still suing anyone that's looked at us oddly in the last 5 years, if that's what you mean?
Mark: Partly, but aren't you building a new stadium too?
Tim: Well we have looked at a couple of places but that's mostly brinkmanship because our rent deal runs out in 15 months.
Mark: Sounds pretty dodgy to me, so we might have nowhere to play in 2018?
Tim: *Laughs and forgets for a moment* Well if you think that's bad, the academy will be forced to close in 3 months.
Mark: Hang on, you just said I'll be forced to rely on the kids but there's nowhere for them to train?
Tim: *awkward silence*
Mrs Robins: *shouts up the stairs* MARK, ARE YOU ON THAT FUCKING PHONE AGAIN, I TOLD YOU 10 MINUTES AGO YOUR DINNER WAS ON THE TABLE!!! AND GET THE FUCK OFF THAT COMPUTER, YOU'VE DONE NOTHING BUT PLAY CHAMPIONSHIP MANAGER SINCE YOU GOT SACKED A YEAR AGO!!

Mark: Tim? You still there? I'll be at Ryton for 8am to take training. *Hangs up the phone*
Tim: Ah. Well, about Ryton, there's something I need to tell you about that too. Mark? You there? Mark?! MARK?!

 

[IrishSkyBlue]

He's been out of work for over a year and has bills to pay. I can't see it being anymore complicated than that.

agreed dont see any other league 1 clubs or championship clubs like blackburn offering him a job when was available, im telling you if he keeps us up and goes on another run next season and gets a better offer hell be gone again its all about the money with robins!

 

[patsy123ccfc]

No but I am suggesting he could get a mid to lower table league 1 club. Easily.

Do you understand me or not?