Jordan Willis... would you keep or sell?? (5 Viewers)
- Thread starter steve82
- Start date
Otis
Well-Known Member
I wouldn't mind selling, but only if we have a decent replacement lined up. If we haven't, will we able to replace him quickly enough before the end of the transfer window?
skybluegod
Well-Known Member
Not really, most clubs don't lie about that stuff?
Willis continued to play when Rotherham were interested so I doubt he's throwing his dummy out the pram.
It's just a foot injury.
I would keep him, unless the valuation is met. He will compliment McDonald well, and we don't need to be rushing around for the last 3 weeks of the transfer window for another CB, as I doubt many if any good ones will be left.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
I don't think we should sell. His valuation has probably gone down after relegation, and his replacement would most likely have to be a loan or a free transfer (someone with no preseason), whilst breaking up the Willis-McDonald partnership. We get promoted, he signs a new contract and his valuation goes up. He leaves on a 'free', we get compensation anyway. No deal.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
We finnaly assemble a squad for promotion a d bow some wsbt to sell?
Replacing willis with a leagur 2 oaf is such short term thinking. Willis can help us in l2 and l1. I thibk robins knows this.
If they want him stump up 500k minimum
Replacing willis with a leagur 2 oaf is such short term thinking. Willis can help us in l2 and l1. I thibk robins knows this.
If they want him stump up 500k minimum
Warwickhunt
Well-Known Member
Bradford are struggling to get a replacement because they are looking for a cheap option! So fair play to the city sticking by their valuation, too many clubs try to rob us of our players
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
He must be in on the conspiracy then as he tweeted or instagram to suggest he was looking forward to playing for us
Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
Colin Steins Smile
Well-Known Member
I'd keep him, as with the good coach MR provides he will only get better. Unless someone offers a really big sum for him.
We need a stable back 4 to get out this league.
We need a stable back 4 to get out this league.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
How does that any sense? We'll sell a first choice CB and his replacement is a dominant centre forward?! As it stands, we only have 3 contracted CBs and one on non-contract terms. We have enough strikers for the time being.
I'd only sell if a team was willing to pay well over the odds for him, 750k to 1m - which of course is nonsensical for a L2 CB in the last year of his contract...
lifeskyblue
Well-Known Member
Must admit I'm not too worried either way as long as a) we get 500k + for him and b) we get in a commanding centre back to replace him.
I like Willis but I don't think he progressed last season; whether he has reached his potential or whether he was poorly coached last season or whether his confidence was shot in a relegation side.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I like Willis but I don't think he progressed last season; whether he has reached his potential or whether he was poorly coached last season or whether his confidence was shot in a relegation side.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Astute
Well-Known Member
At least we could trust Bradford not to use us to get rid of a player that they don't want because of a lack of effort.....
SkyblueDad
Well-Known Member
Would definitely keep him if we can. JW will be off eventually he's got better each season imo would be a star in any league one/two team
Cov kid 55
Well-Known Member
He played really well today until going off injured. Was really strong in the air. I don't think we would be able to replace him with a better player, or one with more potential.
rupert_bear
Well-Known Member
If you want promotion you keep your best players and Willis is one of those. If was Robins I'd try and keep him atleast until the January window when I reckon his value could soar.
He scores goals too.
He scores goals too.
sw88
Chief Commentator!
I like Willis. I think he's come on a lot and showed in his early days he would make a decent CB (never rated him st RB).
That said if I was to compare our defence against Notts County with Hyam alongside McDonald and the one from yesterday of Willis and McDonald, I'd say V County we looked a better unit.
Yesterday we were making mistakes too often early on.
But then Tuesday Hyam and mcDonald played, and clearly we were poor defensively.
So it makes me wonder; were we strong looking V County because we weren't tested enough?
It's nice to have a number of options in our defence for a change
That said if I was to compare our defence against Notts County with Hyam alongside McDonald and the one from yesterday of Willis and McDonald, I'd say V County we looked a better unit.
Yesterday we were making mistakes too often early on.
But then Tuesday Hyam and mcDonald played, and clearly we were poor defensively.
So it makes me wonder; were we strong looking V County because we weren't tested enough?
It's nice to have a number of options in our defence for a change
Otis
Well-Known Member
I like Willis. I think he's come on a lot and showed in his early days he would make a decent CB (never rated him st RB).
That said if I was to compare our defence against Notts County with Hyam alongside McDonald and the one from yesterday of Willis and McDonald, I'd say V County we looked a better unit.
Yesterday we were making mistakes too often early on.
But then Tuesday Hyam and mcDonald played, and clearly we were poor defensively.
So it makes me wonder; were we strong looking V County because we weren't tested enough?
It's nice to have a number of options in our defence for a change
You also have to factor in this is the first time McDonald and Willis have played together isn't it.
Will take a little time to gel.
AFCCOVENTRY
Well-Known Member
I have complete faith in Robins getting a decent replacement if not better for any player that leaves.
JulianDarbyFTW
Well-Known Member
I previously was on the sell side of things, believing he had defeat ingrained into his soul at this club. But maybe I was wrong. Perhaps it is as simple as playing with better players, albeit at a lower overall standard in L2. I guess, as a defender, if you spend most of your time on the back foot because the team is poor you'll eventually be exposed. Time will tell.
steve82
Well-Known Member
I'm still in the frame of mind if the right price is offered sell him, but only if that money can be reinvested. He's a year left and anything other than promotion he will likely leave on a free given there is still interest from the leagues above.
I like him, I'd be happy for him to stay...he's quick and athletic and does the job. A lot depends on what the offered deal would be...
But as MR has proved he's found 11 good signings on permanent deals so I'd trust he's a few targets on the white board to cover Willis departing given we'd be expecting interest for him from other clubs.
I like him, I'd be happy for him to stay...he's quick and athletic and does the job. A lot depends on what the offered deal would be...
But as MR has proved he's found 11 good signings on permanent deals so I'd trust he's a few targets on the white board to cover Willis departing given we'd be expecting interest for him from other clubs.
I_Saw_Shaw_Score
Well-Known Member
Sell him.
Get someone in who can play a decent portion of the season!
Get someone in who can play a decent portion of the season!
Winny the Bish
Well-Known Member
Would keep him. Looked excellent yesterday before going off. Just got to keep him healthy.
skybluegod
Well-Known Member
He played 46 games last season?
Year before he got unlucky with one bad injury.
Year before that he played 40 games?
What a stupid comment.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Every player has a price, so if a team would pay the money we're asking, then sure. However, the team has got off to a good start so I wouldn't want to risk breaking the group up in anyway. So it would have to be a very good offer.
I_Saw_Shaw_Score
Well-Known Member
Sell sell sell
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Such as?
I'm not gonna go into detail but I work with someone who's connected to his family.
sw88
Chief Commentator!
But wasn't County the first time we'd seen Hyman and McDonald together?.......
Otis
Well-Known Member
Didn't they both play in some of the friendlies?
Also meant in terms of Willis not even training and therefore not having chance to work together.
Nick
Administrator
Willis played on friendlies too
