Player ratings (12 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Biamou produced some great touches today and dragged players away from McNulty.
In terms of Murphy, he had undoubtable quality, but in the second half of the season he didn't turn up in many games.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
I'd love to see the stats of the goals scored by McNulty when alongside Biamou and those when he's played Duck.
Biamou created two goals at Luton in 10 minutes.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
I thought it was a better performance from Biamou but my word he is still rubbish its lucky his competition is the equally useless Beavon.
Burge 6
Grimmer 6
Stokes 7
Davies 8 my mom does everything simply he just heads it and kicks it nothing fancy
Willis 8
Doyle 5 we play in blue
Bayliss 8
Dke 5
Shipley 5 played too many games needs a rest
McNulty 8
Biamou 5 I’m feeling generous after a win
Ponticelli 6
Haynes 10 magical performance just for Grendel but seriously 5
Burge 6
Grimmer 6
Stokes 7
Davies 8 my mom does everything simply he just heads it and kicks it nothing fancy
Willis 8
Doyle 5 we play in blue
Bayliss 8
Dke 5
Shipley 5 played too many games needs a rest
McNulty 8
Biamou 5 I’m feeling generous after a win
Ponticelli 6
Haynes 10 magical performance just for Grendel but seriously 5
Grendel
Well-Known Member
How did he create two goals? One was a direct goal from a free kick.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Do you not think mcnulty is scoring more as we don’t obsessively play it wide now to Jones and play more to his strengths , mcnulty needs to receive the ball central and usually on the floor .
Not only does mcnulty look better then but so do the team , when we adopted long ball tactics today mcnulty went missing because that’s not his game .
Otis
Well-Known Member
Sorry, but that's a bit of a daft argument. McNulty has benefited from Biamou alongside him.
I agree Biamou needs to be scoring, but you can't judge a player on simply goals alone.
Football doesn't work that way I'm afraid.
I do think he does need to be scoring too though.
pusbccfc
Well-Known Member
Put the ball through for the sending off/free kick and put the ball through for Duck.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He hasn’t benefited at all from him. His goals are mostly created from balls through the middle or his own ability to create from little.
I’ll tell you how football works - statistics. They don’t lie. No goals and no assists in nearly half a season for a centre forward.
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Burge. 6. Didn't have much to do but his kicking seems to be improving. Puts his kicks right on the opposition defence and keeps pressure on.
Grimmer. 6.5.
Willis. 6.
Davies. 7. Solid. I think McDonald should fight for his place back. Davies shouldn't be dropped to allow him straight back in. Stepped up when needed and helped keep 2 clean sheets!
Stokes 6.5.
Doyle. 5.5. Far from his best game today. Dug in and put the effort in but his passing was all over the place. Very out of character.
Bayliss. 8. Breath of fresh air. Breaks up play in the middle Well, drives with the ball putting defenders on the back foot. Same as Davies, when Kelley is fit again will have his work cut out to regain his shirt.
Shipley. 6.5. Looked like he was running in quicksand towards the end. Looked vert tired and shows the effects of so many games in such a period has on players.
DKE. 5.5. Was up against a unit of a LB. Add to that his lack of match sharpness and confidence and today wasn't his best day at the office!
McNulty. 7. Proving all the boo boys wrong. I don't think it's any coincidence that since JJ got injured and the Duck benched, he's started scoring. He's finally starting to get some service and is reaping the rewards.
Biamou. 7. I love his work rate and he reads the game very well. Gets into some great positions and works for the cause. But......... how much longer can he go without a bloody goal?!?!
Ponticelli. 7. Chased down their defenders and bought a shit tonne of energy to the game.
Haynes. N/A didn't really see much of the ball when he came on. Can't really comment.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Grimmer. 6.5.
Willis. 6.
Davies. 7. Solid. I think McDonald should fight for his place back. Davies shouldn't be dropped to allow him straight back in. Stepped up when needed and helped keep 2 clean sheets!
Stokes 6.5.
Doyle. 5.5. Far from his best game today. Dug in and put the effort in but his passing was all over the place. Very out of character.
Bayliss. 8. Breath of fresh air. Breaks up play in the middle Well, drives with the ball putting defenders on the back foot. Same as Davies, when Kelley is fit again will have his work cut out to regain his shirt.
Shipley. 6.5. Looked like he was running in quicksand towards the end. Looked vert tired and shows the effects of so many games in such a period has on players.
DKE. 5.5. Was up against a unit of a LB. Add to that his lack of match sharpness and confidence and today wasn't his best day at the office!
McNulty. 7. Proving all the boo boys wrong. I don't think it's any coincidence that since JJ got injured and the Duck benched, he's started scoring. He's finally starting to get some service and is reaping the rewards.
Biamou. 7. I love his work rate and he reads the game very well. Gets into some great positions and works for the cause. But......... how much longer can he go without a bloody goal?!?!
Ponticelli. 7. Chased down their defenders and bought a shit tonne of energy to the game.
Haynes. N/A didn't really see much of the ball when he came on. Can't really comment.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Grendel
Well-Known Member
So that’s an assist officially is it?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
You are correct , 1 assist v Luton.
I’ve attended all but 1 game this season and I’m still struggling to see what biamou offers
Harry_Walker
Well-Known Member
Burge 7
Grimmer 7
Willis 7
Davis 8
Stokes 6
Bayliss 8
Shipley 5
Doyle 6
DKE 3
Biamou 7
McNulty 7
Grimmer 7
Willis 7
Davis 8
Stokes 6
Bayliss 8
Shipley 5
Doyle 6
DKE 3
Biamou 7
McNulty 7
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Brilliant in the 93rd minute against a defeated team.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I just don’t think he’s good enough , and I can’t understand this fanbase and their love for players who try over their love for players with ability .
It’s weird and a result of years of failure
Mcnulty has had more stick this season than biamou , far more stick , and he’s got 12 goals
Otis
Well-Known Member
We have looked a better side when Biamou has been up front for the most part and have been rather lost when he has either not played or been taken off.
Good job we're not all Crewe supporters. Charlie Kirk, a striker there, scored his first goal in 49 matches the other week.
This place would have been in meltdown for the previous 48.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Probably why they are 19th Otis
BackRoomRummermill
Well-Known Member
Thete is too much made of assists , it’s still down to the player to score else the stat assist could go the other way when the person does not score, it’s somthing those two chimps of Sky sports invented before they got sacked and I hope it goes away , any old flick on does not equal an assist. Ask any manager they will agree . You cannot play someone based on assists , people are played and selected on how they have or could create a win or change a game or in Biamou case there is no one else, we could go through the whole team as well like Burge who is doubtful at best , I still panic every time he has the ball . Just like everyone else.
Otis
Well-Known Member
But as I have said, it is not a love. I am sure there are loads of people like me who are not even fans of Biamou.
I clearly am not.
It's well known I like Beavon, but I have said there that he needs to be contributing or scoring. When Beavon plays it doesn't work. He's not scoring and not contributing. Biamou has been contributing.
I would most definitely be looking to bring some better in though. I clearly don't love him.
Just honest enough to praise him when he does have a good game.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I think the argument is that mcnulty is scoring because he’s playing off biamou , which is not true
Anyway it’s difficult to argue here about this , I have stats totally on my side , sitters missed almost every game to back up my opinion .
Hopefully he proves me wrong and chips in with the goals
Otis
Well-Known Member
WITH Biamou.
We look a better side with him. Without him balls are just sailing over players' heads.
Not going to argue anymore.
I stand by Biamou deserving the applause today and also stand by my notion he had a good game.
I am very quick to criticise him when he doesn't.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
Biamou could go past 49 games easily he doesn’t get into the right positions same as Beavon I will be stunned If the two of them got 3 goal between them this season.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
THought we played better football when he went off today ,difficult to judge as they had 10 men
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
You have to have the quality there aswell ,bad players don’t just keep scoring confident or not
Nick
Administrator
I thought that, made both of them.
BackRoomRummermill
Well-Known Member
Biamou does have one attribute in that he often finds himself in positions and I emphasise find, which totally baffle everyone including his own team, the goal which was disallowed at Carlisle is more proof of that as he did not realise he was offside, on the other spin re watch the pen that mcnulty missed two of their players were there to kick it away when he should have thrown himself in behind mcnulty if he scores or not . These are the things that make the difference , this is the difference why someone like Biamou against McNulty stands out as if was the other way McNulty would have been there .
Grendel
Well-Known Member
He was our worst player today
BackRoomRummermill
Well-Known Member
The results are carrying him , Robins is fully aware we have no one else to play there hopefully it will change.
Otis
Well-Known Member
I find that totally laughable.
Doyle and DKE were much, much, much worse. By a country mile!!!
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
Spot on Grendel part from Max very harsh 4? I think a 6 from from me. Other than that my ratings too.
Grendel
Well-Known Member
They weren’t - name one positive contribution he made today?
Otis
Well-Known Member
Watch the highlights.
He showed some lovely touches in that first half and one in particular stood out when he brought the ball down really well and slid a lovely ball through to Shipley, but Shipley overran it.
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
I think what’s worrying about DKE apart from his physicality which he try’s to make up.
His sense of positioning today was woefull. I’m assuming he has played wide right most his career? Was at times like running around like a headless chicken.
Don’t want to focus on negatives today. He wasn’t that bad as he did do his best and did some good things...didn’t give the ball away as much, but his shooting was woefull again for a forward minded player.