Ccfcisparks
Well-Known Member
Go!
Worst Manager since premier league relegation (11 Viewers)
- Thread starter Ccfcisparks
- Start date
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Slade's our worst manager ever. Next question.
Dimi_Konstantflapalot
Well-Known Member
God there are so many. On record it's Thorn, but Coleman for me was dreadful considering the resources he had available and the players he managed to attract. Honourable mentions for McAllister, Reid and Slade.
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Russel Slade. Close thread, move on
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
skybluesam66
Well-Known Member
Ignoring the spelling - put these in the order of choice
Coleman
Venus
HArbin
Slade
Thorn
Shaw
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Tat's why it's Slade and not Thorn in my view. Thorn was thrust into the job by inept owners and fans proclaiming he was the savoir when he clearly wasn't up to the job, not his fault so much. Slade was supposed to be a proper football manager bought in who could turn us around and improve things and the way he failed was so miserable, if you take out cup games his win ratio is something like 4%.
SkyBlueCRJ
Well-Known Member
IMO it's out of Slade and Coleman. Thorn wasn't a manager and was simply a cheap appointment by SISU to cut costs. Blame shouldn't be directed towards him really as he was set up to fail.
Slade: Took over an already abysmal side so didn't stand much of a chance. However his January signings were the nail in our coffin.
Coleman: The side he had a was probably one of the best in the Championship. Criminal how we didn't at least reach the play-offs.
Slade: Took over an already abysmal side so didn't stand much of a chance. However his January signings were the nail in our coffin.
Coleman: The side he had a was probably one of the best in the Championship. Criminal how we didn't at least reach the play-offs.
I_Saw_Shaw_Score
Well-Known Member
My top 3-
Coleman (with that squad 17th!)
Slade
Thorn
Coleman (with that squad 17th!)
Slade
Thorn
Nick
Administrator
The thing with Slade is that he inherited loads of shite from a dodgy transfer window in the summer so then had to try and fix it in January. Not doubting he was awful but there has probably been worse.
As said, Coleman was throwing silly money around at the time and did nothing.
As said, Coleman was throwing silly money around at the time and did nothing.
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
From worst to best
Slade
Coleman
Thorn
Shaw
Venus.
Wouldn't necessarily put Venus in a list of bad manager tbf. He done an ok job with a pile of shit team Mowbray left him with.
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Nick
Administrator
Surely if Venus is excused then Slade would be as well?
skybluesam66
Well-Known Member
for me it has to be Richard shaw
5 games 5 defeats with a budget at the top end of league 1 - and virtually killed any hope of promotion that year
Robins did very well in trying to turn it around before he jumped ship - and then there was the points deduction
but they were 5 bad games
Crewe Alexandra 1–0 Coventry City
Coventry City 1–2 Stevenage
Tranmere Rovers 2–0 Coventry City
Shrewsbury Town 4–1 Coventry City
Coventry City 1–2 Carlisle United
5 games 5 defeats with a budget at the top end of league 1 - and virtually killed any hope of promotion that year
Robins did very well in trying to turn it around before he jumped ship - and then there was the points deduction
but they were 5 bad games
Crewe Alexandra 1–0 Coventry City
Coventry City 1–2 Stevenage
Tranmere Rovers 2–0 Coventry City
Shrewsbury Town 4–1 Coventry City
Coventry City 1–2 Carlisle United
JulianDarbyFTW
Well-Known Member
For me it's Pressley. He made me fall out of love with football for the best part of a year. Yes, we did well at Northampton, but I didn't get to see that, and when we came back to the Ricoh it was pure, unadulterated dross. Plus his post-match interviews made me want to punch myself in the face so I'd lose consciousness and not have to hear his utter claptrap.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
For once we've got an embarrassment of riches
Reid - turned a team that appeared to be improving the season previously to relegation fodder
Slade - he inherited an atrocious squad but his signings made it worse, e.g. Clarke
Coleman - he had one of the better squads we've had post relegation (it wasn't as a brilliant as some say) but he didn't get us any higher than where we were when he took over
Add to that, worst assistant / director of football:
Jim Smith - the decision to bring this dinosaur in completely derailed the season (probably alongside the sale of Lee Carsley), our squad in the first season in Division 1 was strong enough to go straight back up. Once we'd failed at the first attempt the writing was on the wall for the long term
Reid - turned a team that appeared to be improving the season previously to relegation fodder
Slade - he inherited an atrocious squad but his signings made it worse, e.g. Clarke
Coleman - he had one of the better squads we've had post relegation (it wasn't as a brilliant as some say) but he didn't get us any higher than where we were when he took over
Add to that, worst assistant / director of football:
Jim Smith - the decision to bring this dinosaur in completely derailed the season (probably alongside the sale of Lee Carsley), our squad in the first season in Division 1 was strong enough to go straight back up. Once we'd failed at the first attempt the writing was on the wall for the long term
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
I wasn't a fan of Thorn but don't blame him, honest bloke out of his depth. The owners should have stepped in in the middle of that season and could have saved our Championship status.
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Venus was given what he had, slade had a transfer window and chose to bring in Stuart Beavon
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk
skybluetony176
Well-Known Member
Slade, Thorn, Boothroyd. In that order.
Dimi_Konstantflapalot
Well-Known Member
Foley, Rawson, Yakubu and Clarke were far, far worse signings than Beavon was
steve82
Well-Known Member
Venus was a active part of the whole summer recruitment still.
Beavon didn’t turn out to be what we hoped or needed in terms of goals but he added something slightly more than what we had in pressing from the front.
Both windows were poor but I put the summer slightly worse than January one
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
Yeah that was dreadful, am I right in thinking our second season was when we signed Adebola, Suffo et al?
Nick
Administrator
Venus was in charge of recruitment though?
skybluetony176
Well-Known Member
I thought I had the worst three nailed on. Then you start reading through the thread and the names mentioned and F me we’ve had it bad.
usskyblue
Well-Known Member
Don’t remember him m8
Paul Anthony
Well-Known Member
For me, Coleman.
We underperformed drastically under him, with the squad we had at that time. It was surely reasonable to think we could have been at least in the top half of the table with that team. Yet it remains some of the most dour, dull and depressing football we've played. And, when we really needed to win to stay up, we were saved by a Stoke goalkeeper, because we put in a disgraceful performance.
We underperformed drastically under him, with the squad we had at that time. It was surely reasonable to think we could have been at least in the top half of the table with that team. Yet it remains some of the most dour, dull and depressing football we've played. And, when we really needed to win to stay up, we were saved by a Stoke goalkeeper, because we put in a disgraceful performance.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
mowbray
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
In the summer of 2002 we appointed McAllister, we didn't sign Adebola / Suffo til 2003. We still had Joachim on the books as well as Bothroyd at this point.
steve82
Well-Known Member
ajsccfc
Well-Known Member
Good point that, changing my answer to match