Mcnulty Struggling at Hibs (1 Viewer)

Forums New posts
Nick

Nick

Administrator
covboy1987 said:
Why can Reading getting attendances 14000 + and we get attendances of 12000 + and they can afford to give McNulty a 4-year contract - Potentially if we had kept McNulty and he kept his scoring rate up in league 1 - more than likely we would have been in the top 2 and playing before crowds of 20,000+ the extra 8000 on the gate would have paid for McNulty wages with plenty of change
Click to expand...

It's almost as if it isn't all about attendances.
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Nick

Nick

Administrator
covboy1987 said:
Depends on who's in charge and running the business - plenty of examples such as Notts County - Macclesfield another one -
Click to expand...

Would have thought Notts County were ambitious spending so much?

Sums it up really, it's ambition if it works but then bad ownership if it doesn't. When the money tap stops, everybody gets angry and starts marching.
 
C

covboy1987

Well-Known Member
SAJ said:
Would have thought it was obvious. Championship teams receive about 10 times the money for tv than league one teams. Reading own the ground and rent it to a Rugby team. Even though they only average say 2000 more per game than we do that’s about another million just on tickets.
Click to expand...
agree championship teams receive 10 times as much money - but you need to invest to get to the championship
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
covboy1987 said:
Nearly worked as they got to the plays offs last season and were beaten by a better team with a proven goalscorer
Click to expand...

Then they got relegated from the Football League the season after after buying 2 proven Goalscorers.
 
S

SAJ

Well-Known Member
covboy1987 said:
agree championship teams receive 10 times as much money - but you need to invest to get to the championship
Click to expand...
Don’t disagree at all. There are a variety of ways of investing I guess. The most common one seems to be throw loads of money at the problem and hope you get lucky. Or the method we seem to be using at present is to try and improve slowly without quite as much risk. Since Robins has arrived he seems to have taken us forward and let’s hope he does the same next season.
 
C

covboy1987

Well-Known Member
Good example of investment are Luton Town a team relegated to the conference not so many years ago - Coventry and Luton were fighting over the signature of a certain James Collins - Coventry lost out - Collins top goalscorer in league 25 goals
 
Grendel

Grendel

Well-Known Member
covboy1987 said:
Good example of investment are Luton Town a team relegated to the conference not so many years ago - Coventry and Luton were fighting over the signature of a certain James Collins - Coventry lost out - Collins top goalscorer in league 25 goals
Click to expand...

We signed mcnulty instead who out scored Collins last season - so if we’d signed Collins we may not even have been promoted
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
covboy1987 said:
Good example of investment are Luton Town a team relegated to the conference not so many years ago - Coventry and Luton were fighting over the signature of a certain James Collins - Coventry lost out - Collins top goalscorer in league 25 goals
Click to expand...

We weren't fighting as we didn't bid, we brought in McNulty.
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
covboy1987 said:
We might now be in the championship if we had them both
Click to expand...

Depends really.

Would we be if we were playing only one of them up front in our system as opposed to Luton's attacking system?

Keep moving the goalposts about though.
 
S

SkyblueBazza

Well-Known Member
covboy1987 said:
Depends on who's in charge and running the business - plenty of examples such as Notts County - Macclesfield another one -
Click to expand...
Yes...some it has/does/will work. Very very few find it a sustainable strategy.

We tried it to an extent post '87...to push on to that next level. It caught up with us.

Sadly there is also the belief/perception out there is that unless you move to a glamour club you will only win scraps of medals & are much less likely to play for your country.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk
 
fellatio_Martinez

fellatio_Martinez

Well-Known Member
Didn't McNulty act like a bit of a twat while trying to get his move to the big time? I remember Robins saying something to that effect.
 
SBAndy

SBAndy

Well-Known Member
Oh and while we’re on the subject of McNulty, seen him playing v Rangers yesterday, looked fat as fuck.
 
fatso

fatso

Well-Known Member
Look, we had the best out of McNulty, and let’s not forget he was a bag of shite for the first half of the promotion season. He had a fantastic 5 months or so, was instrumental in us getting out of league 2, then we sold him for a profit and replaced him with the sensationally prolific Chaplin.
Now can we please move on!
 
pusbccfc

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
I genuinely think we'd have finished with at least 12 extra points with McNulty this season.
 
R

RoboCCFC90

Well-Known Member
The grass isn’t always greener...

I liked McNulty, I hoped that when he moved on he would do well as I don’t resent a player moving to further his career, but it hasn’t worked for him. I do think his agent advised him badly, Reading were always going to be fighting relegation, McNulty would’ve been better off with us, helping us to the Championship or at least League One playoffs.

Would I have him back now? I’m not sure McNulty would suit the style we are playing, but he scores goals and that’s the vital thing, so yes I would.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
fernandopartridge

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
covboy1987 said:
Probably correct statement, as your right, saying unrealistic in the current way we go about our business but something I don't agree on - for example, Salford now at Wembley and could be in league 2 next season paying Adam Rooney £4,000 a week a proven goalscorer so far 21 goals in 38 games for Salford - Salford directors are not stupid and they do not seem the type to throw money with no return - they are investing for the future which we need to follow suit
Click to expand...
They won't get a return, they are making big losses. Accumulated P&L increased by £1.7m from 2017 to 2018. Utterly unsustainable and no example to follow for anybody
 
Nick

Nick

Administrator
fernandopartridge said:
They won't get a return, they are making big losses. Accumulated P&L increased by £1.7m from 2017 to 2018. Utterly unsustainable and no example to follow for anybody
Click to expand...

Yeah but they get headlines on Sky Sports News and people go on about ambition. Fast forward a few years and it's then demanding the football league step in and let down by the EFL.

What the EFL should be doing is not allowing stupid losses and clamping down on it, they won't though.
 
B

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Nick said:
Yeah but they get headlines on Sky Sports News and people go on about ambition. Fast forward a few years and it's then demanding the football league step in and let down by the EFL.

What the EFL should be doing is not allowing stupid losses and clamping down on it, they won't though.
Click to expand...

Non league has even less regulation. If you think about it 4k a week in exchange for just 21 goals at that level is a piss poor return
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Top