Agree with all of that apart from the “have to have played” tag. Never played rugby but feel I’ve watched enough to have a good handle on the rules. There was certainly some inconsistency with the holding calls yesterday but with SA committing more bodies generally to breakdowns it was difficult. We needed to play a bit more expansively at times to open the field up, and SA are far too willing to play a territorial game which hinders the quality of match.
Think Elliot Daly has had a rather poor tournament all in all, and his place must now be under threat at full back. Never really understood why Alex Goode hasn’t had more of a chance in the national setup but it’s probably too late for him now. Don’t watch enough club rugby to know the other options.
There's very little that escapes the referees eye these days (none at all at the level of WC with VAR) but 'interpretation' still plays a part in a lot of refereeing decisions.
I only played the game briefly in young adulthood (I can honestly count on one hand the amount of game time during 5 yrs secondary schooling when we played it.)
'Playing to your strength' will always be the best tactic in any team sport, and boy do SA have that strength thru their pack and therefore in scrum situations which as we saw regularly contributed to their score tally.
Their defence at times brought a (begrudging) admiration. You're right, not a great spectacle but I didn't tune in to be entertained, I was hoping England could move the immovable, which had it happened would and should have deserved plaudits on a par with what they received seven days prior.
Only follow Cov - on and off for a number of years but had a ST at BP for the last couple of season. Only very occasionally tune in to the Prem rugby highlights show so don't afford myself any great exposure to be confidently critical of national team selection. However, I agree with your Elliot Daly point - y'day with very little opportunity for any gain to be achieved with pace was crying out for him to play the game of his life but he just didn't show when that rare opportunity arose. He wasn't alone.
Completely different tactics (and strength) from different opponents made for a different playing field which we were disappointingly unable to combat.
England one day cricket team for the 'team of the year' award it is then!