D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
I tend to agree but do you think we will score enough goals with what we have? Baka seems to have no confidence and I am not sure about Biamou's fitness
Transfer Rumour Matty James (9 Viewers)
- Thread starter rexo87
- Start date
Barnsley
Well-Known Member
It’s all about making money, we sign players with development potential, and sell on value, it doesn’t always work out for the players at our club, but we’re getting it right more often than not, but also 3 examples of players that haven’t worked out in the last two years would be, Malik Wilkes who we sold to Hull City in the summer, he’s 22 years old and plenty of scope for development. Elliot Simões 21yo who we got from FCUOM for next to nothing, this week he’s just been loaned to Donkey Rovers who have an excellent track record of developing players, and the third is a player you know well in Luke Thomas who we’re looking to move out for experience and game time. Although it hasn’t worked out for these players at Barnsley because they’ve been through the club we retain an interest in their future development, because when we sell them on we put a great big sell on percentage in the deal, so if they do turn into saleable assets we make a wedge.
If Mowatt does leave it’s because he’s found a club willing to pay him more than we are.
mark82
Super Moderator
Similar model to us to be honest. Everyone is bought with a view to selling for a profit. It's the right model to have for clubs like Barnsley and Coventry. It's the reason we're back in the Championship.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
It’s only a few games before Walker is back. I think we’ll be OK. I’d like a striker in don’t get me wrong, just don’t think it’s life or death.
Barnsley
Well-Known Member
To our recruitment committee loaning in young kids is seen as a waste of a squad place that could be used to develop our own talents, unless a permanent deal is agree should we be happy with said player. Likewise with Matty James we only loaned him in because he was proven quality that we’d never be able to afford permanently and he was ready made to step in and help keep us up. I’ve no doubt we’d loan in someone else like him such as Conor Hourihane should the chance arise but developing young kids for other clubs is highly unlikely.
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
I dont think that’s too difference from us. We just do a lot more try before you buy. I can’t think of anyone we’ve loaned recently who we haven’t attempted to buy/sign. Even James were already talking about a permanent deal if he performs. Liam Walsh arguably but I think he just performed to such a level he priced himself out of our range.
McCallum was a loan back obviously, and we still have a financial interest in his development. Giles until recently may have been available but has just signed a new contract so unlikely. But neither are the “pay massive loan fees for players you could never sign” type loans.
Gibbo
Well-Known Member
what do you mean Armstrong, Murphy and Ryan Kent?
Gibbo
Well-Known Member
Loans are a crucial part of the mix. You should, I say 'should', get players much better than par. We have done very well indeed out of loans for the last three seasons - Sterling, Walsh, Ostigaard, Sam Mac are ordinarily outside our price range.
Just don't be too dependent on them, or else you pay when they leave and the following years' perhaps are not so good. 2 is great, 3 just about ok. In particular they can provide the speed and trickery that is difficult to find in lower divisions - Sterling, Thomas & Giles.
The JCH, Sheaf and James are/were in a slightly different category as they are/were 'loan to buy'.
The ones I am most suspicious of are the loan backs, even though Sam Mac had played well, they can backfire - see Maddison.
Just don't be too dependent on them, or else you pay when they leave and the following years' perhaps are not so good. 2 is great, 3 just about ok. In particular they can provide the speed and trickery that is difficult to find in lower divisions - Sterling, Thomas & Giles.
The JCH, Sheaf and James are/were in a slightly different category as they are/were 'loan to buy'.
The ones I am most suspicious of are the loan backs, even though Sam Mac had played well, they can backfire - see Maddison.
Barnsley
Well-Known Member
We’re 6 wins away from safety, we don’t need to loan players, in my and our boards opinion, so it’s time to try and develop our own young kids further, so hopefully we don’t need to loan someone like James again next summer.
D
Deleted member 9744
Guest
True but Agyei, Wright, Akpon and Page? Plenty of others too
HuckerbyDublinWhelan
Well-Known Member
Grant Ward, Ben Turner and Bailey Cargill weren’t bad players either
Hobo
Well-Known Member
Time will tell whether you miss the experience of James on the pitch and in the dressing room? I think it is as much about Barnsley feeling they are in a reasonably safe league position and want to save some money.
Barnsley
Well-Known Member
It’s not so much the money we’ve spent money this week, it’s ether he didn’t want stay here, or we’ve thought we’ve got enough to stay up, we’ll buy our own players, our owner have always been reluctant to loan players in unless we can’t get who we want.
AFCCOVENTRY
Well-Known Member
Robins said that he’s at Cov with a view to a perm deal in the summer. So James probably asked to go back and go for us so he can sort his future out.
Hobo
Well-Known Member
I think we are looking at a permanent deal.