Todd Kane/Michael Rose/Gyok (8 Viewers)
- Thread starter Saddlebrains
- Start date
I'm not comparing their ability, I'm comparing the simple fact of left foot vs right foot.
Rose hasn't put a foot wrong this season and was the best defender against Blackburn.
It's all very well being left footed but if JCS keeps putting in performances like Luton and last night then which foot he kicks the ball with is irrelevant.
Warthog
Well-Known Member
He wasn’t and he was superb at Hull.
I have yes, because his positioning is awful.
I said it after his debut and was told it was his first game he needs time to settle in. Then Luton happened and I was told it was a one off. Then last night happened and a few people are now highlighting his mistakes.
I know you're not asking for it (nobody is!) but I will do a big long post later showing his poor positioning
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Didn't Dabo put a great ball in when he played on the left?
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
Games like last night and Luton it appeared he had two left feet! But to be fair to him he has also had a few excellent games, so it's a consistency issue.
I think MR needs to recognise those games he's off the pace and be willing to change it. It's good to have a natural left footer in the back three for balance, but it's better to have three right footers than one left footer who's having a 'mare..
TomRad85
Well-Known Member
Can't be mate. Sheaf is shit, lazy and doesn't tackle remember.
Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk
Marty
Well-Known Member
Dabo is overrated by our fan base, can't beat the majority of full backs in this league, largely poor passing, he struggles to make 10 yard passes at times, terrible crosser of the ball, against the weaker full backs, he runs riot, but those are few and far between at this level. Haven't seen enough of Kane to say hes better or not overall, but he's got a killer cross on him and we know he can put goals on a plate for the forwards. He seems very aggressive in the tackle too, I think he deserves a chance.
mark_ccfc
Well-Known Member
Isn't it a good thing to have two left feet if you are playing on the left?
It’sabatch87
Well-Known Member
I’d have Tavares on the bench on Saturday give him 20 mins at the end.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
I agree. I think Rose has done ok when asked upon on the left defensively, but its attacking and playing progressively thay gets hindered by playing a right footer on the left centre back. And Rose is by far pur best passing centre back, but the games he has filled in, it looks unbalanced in possession
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Also Maatsen was hugely culpable at Luton, he provided no defensive support at all, didn't track the runners.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
It’sabatch87
Well-Known Member
Matty James went off injured for Brizzle City last night, a foot injury apparently and a big doubt and miss for them on Saturday.
It all went pear shaped when he was subbed.
It all went pear shaped when he was subbed.
So this is what I mean by JCS' (lack of) positioning.
He is constantly higher up than the other defenders. I don't know if it's ball watching or what but he is always 5 or 10 yards higher up than the other two and leaves a gaping hole in behind him which is so easy to exploit.
The second picture shows him getting caught pressing too high which is another fault and he gets turned.
Pictures 1, 3 and 4 are almost identical - 5 yards higher for no reason whatsoever and just begging for Swansea to slip the ball in the gap behind him. People slate Maatsen's positioning but look, he's deeper than JCS and covering his man in those three examples.
These were all just from the first 20 minutes of last night then I got bored. It's not like I had to go through 3 or 4 games worth to get these examples.
And it's not just last night.
Here's Derby's goal. Hyam gave the ball away higher up the pitch than JCS' starting position and he's made up more ground than JCS who just ambles back and then makes the laziest attempt at closing down.
Actually that's's not the laziest attempt at closing down. This is. He's been at it for years!
He is constantly higher up than the other defenders. I don't know if it's ball watching or what but he is always 5 or 10 yards higher up than the other two and leaves a gaping hole in behind him which is so easy to exploit.
The second picture shows him getting caught pressing too high which is another fault and he gets turned.
Pictures 1, 3 and 4 are almost identical - 5 yards higher for no reason whatsoever and just begging for Swansea to slip the ball in the gap behind him. People slate Maatsen's positioning but look, he's deeper than JCS and covering his man in those three examples.
These were all just from the first 20 minutes of last night then I got bored. It's not like I had to go through 3 or 4 games worth to get these examples.
And it's not just last night.
Here's Derby's goal. Hyam gave the ball away higher up the pitch than JCS' starting position and he's made up more ground than JCS who just ambles back and then makes the laziest attempt at closing down.
Actually that's's not the laziest attempt at closing down. This is. He's been at it for years!
Attachments
Earlsdon_Skyblue1
Well-Known Member
CovBrummie94
Well-Known Member
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Taking away from these stills , what we also have to remember is we play a way that allows our left and right centre halves to progress up the pitch , so a couple of these are easy to explain .
If you want rigid , then we take that option away and stay as a unit throughout
I dont think Rose is the answer
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
Did he have a knock or something? Some of his game and demeanour does remind me of Pask
Yeah of course, they are encouraged to progress up the pitch and I am fine with that.
My issue is that in all of those examples he is not progressing up the pitch with the ball. The opposition have the ball, he is nowhere near it, yet he's consistently out of position
Must have been a bad knock because he still has it!
I see what you mean about Pask actually, that's not a bad shout.
CovBrummie94
Well-Known Member
Absolutely shockingIt's shocking isn't it
But going back to how JCS fits into our team. I do believe our best CB 3 is JCS, Fadz and either Rose or Hyam. I think JCS gets left woefully exposed by Maatsen a lot of the time.
He certainly made a mistake for the opening goal last night but overall I have been impressed with his start to the season. He was apparently brilliant at Hull if you listen to the people that went, and more often than not he has been brilliant when I have watched him.
Warthog
Well-Known Member
Lad I know plays for the u18s and was training with the first team in preseason. He told me Dabo used to stay behind after every training session and practice whipping a cross around a mannequin.
Unfortunately he had to stop after the first week as he’d already took the head off all 25 mannequins in the set.
Unfortunately he had to stop after the first week as he’d already took the head off all 25 mannequins in the set.
Absolutely shocking
But going back to how JCS fits into our team. I do believe our best CB 3 is JCS, Fadz and either Rose or Hyam. I think JCS gets left woefully exposed by Maatsen a lot of the time.
He certainly made a mistake for the opening goal last night but overall I have been impressed with his start to the season. He was apparently brilliant at Hull if you listen to the people that went, and more often than not he has been brilliant when I have watched him.
But look at images 1, 3 & 4 from my post. Maatsen is perfectly in position covering his man, JCS has gone wandering.
I appreciate they are stills and stills don't always tell the whole story. I also accept that Maatsen is often caught high up the field and I'm not saying he's blameless. But he has to attack and he will spend plenty of time up the pitch, so the defence has to be able to cope with that. We manage fine on the right side when Dabo is high up the pitch.
And also I'm not saying JCS is bad every game, he has put in some really good performances I don't deny that. He was good against Fulham and Hull, to name two.
Great_Expectations
Well-Known Member
I wouldn’t bring Kane in yet, his final ball is far superior but if we want to play on the front foot Dabo is the option. Saying that, his form isn’t great, I’m hoping it’s temporary and not the step up.
No way I’d drop Gyokeres. He hasn’t scored or been quite as pivotal but the ball sticks to him, he’s happy to run at players and he’s always an option. He still offers more as an overall striker, and the international break hopefully offers him the rest he needs (assuming he isn’t called up again?!).
JCS is either bang average or absolutely on it. He sometimes looks lackadaisical (thankfully not as bad as that Bristol clip) but I do think the left foot advantage is important. Saying that Rose is a good passer of the ball so os maybe worth a go to see if he can link with Maasten.
No way I’d drop Gyokeres. He hasn’t scored or been quite as pivotal but the ball sticks to him, he’s happy to run at players and he’s always an option. He still offers more as an overall striker, and the international break hopefully offers him the rest he needs (assuming he isn’t called up again?!).
JCS is either bang average or absolutely on it. He sometimes looks lackadaisical (thankfully not as bad as that Bristol clip) but I do think the left foot advantage is important. Saying that Rose is a good passer of the ball so os maybe worth a go to see if he can link with Maasten.
SBAndy
Well-Known Member
I find some of those stills a bit disingenuous to be honest. It was clear we had no left sided midfield cover yesterday - it needed one of JCS or Maatsen to step out to Ntcham (who is the player JCS is pressing in all of those images from last night) and the other to pick up the winger. It looked like a conscious decision and it was actually reversed at half time, with JCS covering the winger and Maatsen pressing higher.
I don’t think he’s perfect by any stretch - in fact I think he’s been a bit lax at times - but the examples you’ve provided strike me more as tactical.
I don’t think he’s perfect by any stretch - in fact I think he’s been a bit lax at times - but the examples you’ve provided strike me more as tactical.
stupot07
Well-Known Member
Definitely, in pretty much all of those screenshot he has had to step in to press into midfield, because there's either no midfielder in there (Swansea) or Maatsen is too far out of position (Derby).
Thats one of the flexibilities of 3 at the back, that if one presses you have cover behind you.
It looks as though JCS is out of position but he is having to put pressure on the ball and cover someone else
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
stupot07
Well-Known Member
I would say Kane does play on the front foot but does it in a different way to Dabo. Dabo likes to drive with the ball, but Kane attacks the space to run on to passes in a way it means Kane often gets it in more space than Dabo.
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Are people really going on record as saying kane is better than dabo?
But it's not just last night, it's every game, whether we've had midfield cover or not (and I agree we were extremely light in midfield last night).
He's not pressing in some of those images, he's just simply out of position.
Every player has weak points, for O'Hare it's finishing and for JCS it's positioning. Look at that Bristol rovers clip, it's clearly an issue he's had throughout his career.
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
I think most are arguing that his final ball is better than Dabo's. Just depends on who we're playing whether that is more important.