Changed my mind give it to Richard (7 Viewers)
- Thread starter theprince
- Start date
craigSKYBLUE
New Member
Charlton did it...why not eh
WillieStanley
New Member
Not this year... Keep him in our back burner though!
Colonel Mustard
New Member
The great thing about tonight was seeing Shaw and Oggy on the touchline. A slight re-kindling of the spirit from our last good days as a club - something I'm sure any survivor from the 90s can relate to!
Gaz
Well-Known Member
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
I think some are getting a bit carried away, good performance etc. but let's wait and see what happens in the Crewe game.
I think we should go for the experienced route but if Shaw earns it, he should get it.
I'm glad he kept the diamond!
I think we should go for the experienced route but if Shaw earns it, he should get it.
I'm glad he kept the diamond!
Sky Blue Sheepy
New Member
I think some are getting a bit carried away, good performance etc. but let's wait and see what happens in the Crewe game.
I think we should go for the experienced route but if Shaw earns it, he should get it.
I'm glad he kept the diamond!
He kept the diamond but the players' off the ball movement made it effective - and the subs meant the wing backs didn't get too tired. Unfortunately for Thorn that is stuff the manager should be telling his players to do which wasn't happening I guess. Don't want to get carried away, but I enjoyed that
Paxman II
Well-Known Member
A good sign as he seemed to get something from the players Thorn was unable to do. However it's early days and it may just well be the Thorn gone factor just as easily. One thing was prominent though. Shaw/Carsley knew when and how to change it when needed. His selections were almost excellent. willis I thought did struggle a bit and is not ready for me. Edjenguele was master stroke. A footballer and quick. Confident on the ball and had King in his pocket all night.
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
Which I have said, it is more down to the manager than the system (imo) as it is ridiculous to suggest if we'd played 4-4-2 last season, we'd be in the Championship!
CCFC_Charlie
Well-Known Member
Wise, Shaw and Carsley
Astute
Well-Known Member
So should Shaw get the job straight away?
Last night the team played well. We beat a team in a division above us over 120 mins. We played at least OK for most of it. This alone is an improvement. We attacked with intent. We came from behind to win. All in all a good performance.
But....we lost the lead, drew after 90 mins, beat a team that has drawn one and lost two in the league and are in the bottom 3 in the Championship. To me it would be like when we signed AT. He had a good start considering he took over a team that was sliding down tje table. We only lost two games with him in charge to the end of the season. Shaw also has a lack of experience. I am not saying he shouldn't be given a chance, but one game against a club that have started badly playing us at home does not make him the one to take us over. We should give him some more games in the league and see what happens. Look at the results last night. Our result wasn't a shock. Stoke went out. That was an upset. Ipswich going out was a bigger upset than us winning.
Well done Shaw, well done.lads, but one result don't mean we have turned the corner yet.
Last night the team played well. We beat a team in a division above us over 120 mins. We played at least OK for most of it. This alone is an improvement. We attacked with intent. We came from behind to win. All in all a good performance.
But....we lost the lead, drew after 90 mins, beat a team that has drawn one and lost two in the league and are in the bottom 3 in the Championship. To me it would be like when we signed AT. He had a good start considering he took over a team that was sliding down tje table. We only lost two games with him in charge to the end of the season. Shaw also has a lack of experience. I am not saying he shouldn't be given a chance, but one game against a club that have started badly playing us at home does not make him the one to take us over. We should give him some more games in the league and see what happens. Look at the results last night. Our result wasn't a shock. Stoke went out. That was an upset. Ipswich going out was a bigger upset than us winning.
Well done Shaw, well done.lads, but one result don't mean we have turned the corner yet.
lordsummerisle
Well-Known Member
sotv1987
Member
Agree totally!!!! No need to rush into making a decision, give Shaw a few more games, then see!!!
I wouldn't be adverse to Wise, Shaw, Carsley
Only my opinion!!!
torchomatic
Well-Known Member
Last night was brilliant, but it was for one game. Thorn had a similar affect if you remember. Shaw certainly hasn't done his chances any harm though.
Astute
Well-Known Member
Of course I am.
We drew away to Yeovil. Could easily have won. Drew with Sheff Utd. They are favourites to win this division. We then drew with Bury. Bad result when you consider we should have had the game wrapped up by halftime.
We had a corner to turn whoever was in charge. We could have won each game this season. We could have also lost each game. AT has gone. Time to get behind whoever is in charge and hope whoever it is can get better.results than AT did.
covross
New Member
Don't give the job to Shaw. I wonder if the same people that want Shaw now championed for Thorn when he drew a few of the 10 games he took charge of 18 months ago. I'm worried that the 'great to see another black manager at a club getting a chance' brigade will influence Shaw's appointment also. Billy Davies is my choice. PUSB
iamyouralterego
New Member
Just abbreviate it to the much more refined GTSABMAACGACB.
See. Now you'll remember it.
See. Now you'll remember it.
iamyouralterego
New Member
You're looking down the wrong avenue. Car bumper stickers is the only solution i'm afraid.
skyblue1523
New Member
Just because at did'nt work out doesn't mean it wouldn't work with Shaw he was on the touchline nearly all game barking orders out he has got skyblue blood tuning through his veins and he knows how the fans feel.pusb
Colonel Mustard
New Member
There was nothing wrong with hiring Thorn. The mistake was in not sacking him much, much sooner.
Why bring colour into it does the colour of someone's skin give you a problem
sky_blue_up_north
Well-Known Member
Far to early as many other have said it's one game. I remember Thorn's first game at Burnley we were outstanding that night, I could not believe how well be played. We have to be careful, I want promotion this season like all of us, so lets take our time and get the right person to achieve that.
lordsummerisle
Well-Known Member
Did wonder that myself.
DiveDiveWhereverYouMayBe
New Member
I have heard that Shaw has 'been given' five games. Whether that is to prove what he can do or to give the board time to find someone else (or a combination of the two... or even if this is a load of bollocks - I know where it came from, but it does sound like the sort of thing that could just as easily be guesswork), I don't know. I don't think Thorn was the messiah and I think he made some errors in his tenure. I don't think he was as useless as others would have you believe. I also think he is largely irrelevant in what happens. The sensible option is to consider all options.
skyblueman
New Member
If they need five games to find a replacement then fair enough - 'trying out' Shaw for five games is mindless - they might as well have left AT in and given him a fairer crack at it with the squad he put together rover the summer - it has to be an external appointment and a decent one at that
I couldn't care less if he's black white or Australian, I just want the best man for the job. If the team were to continue performing for Shaw as they did last night, that's why I'd like to see him given the job, nothing else.